Remove this Banner Ad

Stats & History S31 Rules & Tribunal Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

NaturalDisaster said:
Do you have links to said examples?




Never
Click to expand...
Ant Bear said:
Not sure if rules from 6 seasons ago are going to help you, but if you help me break back into Committee I could find a more recent example where Committee ruled that twin errors in the same teamsheet is a single infraction.
Click to expand...


there isnt two errors dumbarse

dumbarse has ****ed up because he doesnt own a dictionary

sooner this is retracted the better for everyone #freeturbo
 
Ant Bear said:
Not sure if rules from 6 seasons ago are going to help you, but if you help me break back into Committee I could find a more recent example where Committee ruled that twin errors in the same teamsheet is a single infraction.
Click to expand...

- Natural Disaster hiding evidence i see.

Time to acquit
 
Sterge said:
- Natural Disaster hiding evidence i see.

Time to acquit
Click to expand...

and more importantly, he cannot read

the rule was:

  • Team sheets must be displayed in a logical format that is comprehensible by the game simmers. Each positional line {e.g. B, HB, C, HF, F, Foll, INT} must be defined clearly and in case of positional changes the specific positions must be communicated in the listed changes. The only acceptable format is:
B: BP – FB – BP

HB: HBF – CHB – HBF

C: W – C – W

HF: HFF – CHF – HFF

F: FP – FF – FP

FOLL: RU – RR – RO

INT: INT – INT


(1) the format must be logical to the simmers (Turbo met this)

(2) each positional line must be defined clearly (Turbo met this)

(3) each positional change must be communicated in the listed changes (Turbo met this)


(4) the only acceptable format is (the above)

Now lets look at that little word "format". Oxford dictionary defines it as "the way in which something is arranged or set out". The way Tigerturbulance arranged and set out his team was identical to how the rule required it. And if you look at the rule it confirms this. Does the rule talk about how many spaces or hyphens are used, or font sizes and styles are mandated? No. So the question is, did Turbo arrange and set out the team as per the templates guidance, and he did.

More importantly, the intent of this was to make life as easy as possible for the simmers. the hyphen has no impact upon their work.

Finally we have precedent. Turbo used a hyphen last week, and it was deemed acceptable by our Admin that week. What has changed? Nothing, so his interpretation of this rule should not be changing.

Like an overeager puppy who pisses on the couch every morning, NaturalDisaster has gotten a little excited by ONE low level offence of missing a space in a players name, and has attempted to make this into something bigger. Is it because he is trying to prove he is a big tough admin? Maybe. Is it because he's trying to distance himself from the only team that has survived his reign of terror? Very likely. Is he just trying to throw a bone to the ailing Hawks before another week of disappointment? Probably. Motive doesn't matter however. Dumbarse have overreached and gone all in on a pair of threes. The committee needs to put him in his place, throw out this charge, and let me get back to my lockdown drinking FFS.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Ant Bear said:
And you lot thought that I cracked down hard...

:rolleyesv1:

Furies should be arguing that this is a single case of an incorrect teamsheet and a single low impact charge.
Click to expand...

NaturalDisaster's heavy-handed penalty system is just what this board needs! Unless our team is involved in which case any penalty is too harsh.
 
So NaturalDisaster and members of the committee, the Furies appeal grounds are simple:

- as explained in this thread already https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/s31-rules-tribunal-thread.1253771/post-68750261, an extra hyphen doesn't change the format (which was consistent with the rules), and past precedent has confirmed this

- even if this charge were to stand, the precedent the committee has already established is to ONLY apply one low level charge for one fu**ed up team sheet - even if multiple low level fu** ups occurred in said team sheet

- it's the vibe

- naturaldumbarse is a poopyhead, and he isnt boss of us!!!
 
Ned_Flanders said:
So NaturalDisaster and members of the committee, the Furies appeal grounds are simple:

- as explained in this thread already https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/s31-rules-tribunal-thread.1253771/post-68750261, an extra hyphen doesn't change the format (which was consistent with the rules), and past precedent has confirmed this

- even if this charge were to stand, the precedent the committee has already established is to ONLY apply one low level charge for one fu**ed up team sheet - even if multiple low level fu** ups occurred in said team sheet

- it's the vibe

- naturaldumbarse is a poopyhead, and he isnt boss of us!!!
Click to expand...

Ned deserves a 1 game suspension too.
 
Tigerturbulance adds an extra hyphen to team sheet. NaturalDisaster puts him up on charges citing rules around making it easier for simmers yada yada.

Barrybran deliberately sims iDon's name as iDont ... Admin turns a blind eye.

Farce.
 
Cadsky said:
Suck it up princess
Click to expand...

Lol.

You've got shit tattoos, even by Cranbourne plasterer standards, but no ones buying this tough guy act mate :thumbsu:
 

Remove this Banner Ad

CASE #2 - The case of the Admin not updating our playing badges

It is less then 24 hours until round 2 of the SFA season is completed and all of us turncoats and rookies still don't have our current team badges.

The Half Back said:
I can't fully appreciate the win until NaturalDisaster gets rid of that horrid little Furies logo under my name...
Click to expand...

NaturalDisaster, you have been charged with being a lazy **** and your penalty will be to return to the Furies unless you give out the correct badges.
How do you plead??
 
The Half Back said:
CASE #2 - The case of the Admin not updating our playing badges

It is less then 24 hours until round 2 of the SFA season is completed and all of us turncoats and rookies still don't have our current team badges.



NaturalDisaster, you have been charged with being a lazy fu** and your penalty will be to return to the Furies unless you give out the correct badges.
How do you plead??
Click to expand...

I actually agree NaturalDisaster

Even the Furies have standards FFS
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Cadsky said:
He's actually played the third most games in SFA history
Click to expand...

I didn't know Headless had a rival for most games played in an insignificant position noone give a **** about

You learn something new every day
 
Ned_Flanders said:
I didn't know Headless had a rival for most games played in an insignificant position noone give a fu** about

You learn something new every day
Click to expand...

You seem insecure about how relevant I am. 🤗
 
Headless said:
You seem insecure about how relevant I am. 🤗
Click to expand...

Dude, noone - not even I - can take away your 162 games of "participation"

It people like you who pad out a list, and make it possible for the rest of us to be on the field :)
 
Ned_Flanders said:
I have no idea, but apparently youre in the SFA, so welcome. Now fu** off and don't tag me
Click to expand...
He didn’t tag you illiterate, ill-bred, unwashed dumpster baby.

He quoted you.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom