Salty top 10

[Fastcrew]

Nearly every top 10 in phantom drafts on this site is the same so i have decided to give it some more salt with reasons to its happening.

Priority pick Tom Scully (melb)

Vic metro captain, star midfielder enough said. Melbourne will pick him as their star recruit with the same reasons they picked Watts last year and none of the Perth boys.

2. Dustin Martin (melb)

i thought i would make things spicy. Personally i believe Jack Trengove is the best player in this draft but that does not mean Melbourne will pick him. Dustin is a hard refined midfielder who is definitely in the best 3 players in the draft. I just believe the Dees will opt for him over Trengove

3.Jack Trengove (rich)

pretty obvious pick, sublime midfielder rated best in draft, will be surprised to see him slip.

4.Anthony Morabito (freo)

Dockers have their mind set on the WA boy just like Stephen Hill last year, not going anywhere else

5.Ben Cunnington (N.M)

Would regret letting him pass at pick 5. Definitely deserves to be top 5, suits the roos and their spirit, will have big first season impact like Ziebell

6.Kane Lucas (SYD)

expected to be a slider but i think the swans will surprise taking Lucas over Rohan knowing they have pick 14 for safety.

7.Lewis Jetta (WCE)

no surprises here will immensely help young forwards LeCras, Kennedy, McKinley by crumbing their drops. Eagles could be a dark horse for a top 8 spot next year.

8.John Butcher (P.A)

Super talent, best kpp in the draft has dropped off but will be a star for port and has lots of time and oppurtinuty to develop

9.Gary Rohan (P.A)

you could argue his place in the top 5 and i think he is worthy of that but could slide. had great draft camp results, somewhat of a steal for Port. In my pesonal top 3 favourites with Trengove and Carlisle

10.Koby Stevens (ess)

tough choice ahead of tapscott but i think he will suit well and be better in the long run.

and that is my salty top 10 please complain or applaud just exprees your opinion.

 

[swans16]

Very Spicy indeed.

 

[coasting]

6.Kane Lucas (SYD)

expected to be a slider but i think the swans will surprise taking Lucas over Rohan knowing they have pick 14 for safety.

That comment doesn't make any sense to me. At pick 14 they could easily get a very similar player to Lucas EG Bastinac so if pick 14 is "for safety" then wouldn't they go with the rare commodity at #6?

 

[Vantz]

7.Lewis Jetta (WCE)

no surprises here will immensely help young forwards LeCras, Kennedy, McKinley by crumbing their drops. Eagles could be a dark horse for a top 8 spot next year.

If only Jetta was a crumbing forward.

 

[Mrs Mercuri]

Definately think that if Port overlook Tapscott then the Bombers will grab him at #10 over Stevens.

 

[Nater]

If Rohan is there then im happy as hell to pass on Tapscott. Think theres more chance of West Coast picking Taylor at 7 than Jetta if Lucas goes beforehand.

 

[coasting]

There is 0% chance we take Troy Taylor at that pick. He tested very poorly and doesn't want to play for us anyway.

 

[indieswan96]

I like that you have mixed it up but i cant see martin going at 2 if anyone was going to do that it would be butcher or maorabitio as for Sydney's pick i think we will take rohan and take talia at 14 but if NM take rohan we will snag cunnington which is my hope we get cunnington talia

 

[swannies]

If only Jetta was a crumbing forward.

Thankyou, thankyou, thankyou!

Although in a flukish manner the OP is correct, Jetta will help the forwards, by hitting them on the tit with lace out passes from the wing though!

 

[budge11]

5.Ben Cunnington (N.M)

Would regret letting him pass at pick 5. Definitely deserves to be top 5, suits the roos and their spirit, will have big first season impact like Ziebell

... I don't understand how that's part of the reasoning?

 

[Die Hard Eagle]

Dustin Martin before Jack Trengove??????????? doesnt make any sense and there is not even the slightest of chance of that hapenning in my dreams!!!!!!!!!!!!! seriously do you see that hapenning???

 

[melbournemartin]

As good as Dustin Martin looks, I'd be shattered if we took him over Trengove.

Okay, perhaps not shattered...and I'd get over it quickly but...disappointed is the better word.

[/bad grammar]

Would you care to stretch your list to #11 please?