Competitions SBFFL 2018 redistribution draft.

[St Kilda Death]

Available players:
Mark Baguely
Josh Battle
Grant Birchall
Travis Boak
Shai Bolton
Thomas Boyd
Luke Breust
Tomas Bugg
Shaun Burgoyne
Charlie Cameron
Nakia Cockatoo
Hayden Crozier
Charlie Curnow
Majak Daw
Jordan De Goey
Willem Drew
Mitch Duncan
Jamie Elliot
Corey Ellis
Tim English
Andrew Gaff
Jordan Gallucci
Jeff Garlett
Todd Goldstein
Toby Greene
Jack Gunston
Aaron Hall
Jarrod Harbrow
Shaun Higgins
Luke Hodge
Will Hoskin-Elliott
Jeremy Howe
Bradley Hill
Josh J. Kennedy
Matthew Kreuzer
Mark LeCras
Jordan Lewis
Tom Langdon
Jayden Laverde
Tom Lynch
Eric Mackenzie
Todd Marshall
Jack Martin
Chris Masten
Steven May
Brayden Maynard
Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti
Jeremy McGovern
Andrew McGrath
Daniel McKenzie
Tim Membrey
Darcy Moore
David Mundy
Nic Newman
Luke Parker
Sam Petrevski-Seton
Lewis Pierce
Ben Reid
Cyril Rioli
Daniel Rioli
Joel Selwood
Dylan Shiel
James Sicily
Zac Smith
Rhys Stanley
Harry Taylor
Zach Tuohy
Daniel Venables
Nick Vlastuin
Jared Waite
Michael Walters
Jack Watts
Jimmy Webster
Sam Weideman
Jacob Weitering
Jack Ziebell

Draft order:
1. CursingFijian
2. simonoz
3. majortinkle
4. Death
5. Left_Billings
6. Phoenix_9
7. Jonzi
8. PetWussy

results.
1.Gary Ablett
2.Scott Pendlebury
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.

Cursing you're up.
No time limit, but hopefully we can keep rolling at a good rate.
Please tag next up after you take your pick.

 

[CursingFijian]

Pick 1. Gary Ablett

simonoz you're up.

 

[simonoz]

Pick 2: Scott Pendlebury

 

[CursingFijian]

majortinkle

 

[majortinkle]

majortinkle

looks like I’ve found a 10th manager.....if we stayed at 10 no redistribution would be needed.....

Although personally if I was one of the 4 I’d like to draft from the ones available rather than taking old teams......

Let me know if still keen to stick with 10 and I’ll link them in to the main thread....I certainly am!

I can’t believe you guys had so little faith - I just had to up the posts - left it late as it was a bit all in at work this week.....

 

[CursingFijian]

looks like I’ve found a 10th manager.....if we stayed at 10 no redistribution would be needed.....

Although personally if I was one of the 4 I’d like to draft from the ones available rather than taking old teams......

Let me know if still keen to stick with 10 and I’ll link them in to the main thread....I certainly am!

I can’t believe you guys had so little faith - I just had to up the posts - left it late as it was a bit all in at work this week.....

My vote is to stay at 10 teams, and do away with the redistribution draft.

 

[simonoz]

Do I still get to keep Pendles!

 

[majortinkle]

Do I still get to keep Pendles!

Overrated mate - count it as a lucky escape......

 

[Jonzi]

Does that mean I slide down the draft order to 9??? Stiff penalty...

 

[majortinkle]

Does that mean I slide down the draft order to 9??? Stiff penalty...

Depends how you think about it I suppose. Only 1 team would pick after you now and only one will with 10.

All relative.

I presume you must have picked the team that came second. You could always pick lower ranked one.

Chances are we’re only talking about the 1st years and zero gamers in this scenario as well.

 

[St Kilda Death]

Ok lads this is good news.
I won't get a chance today but will sort out the new draft in a couple days....
Unless someone else is keen to get it started!

 

[Phoenix_9]

Was thinking, did Jonzi take over 12Chill’s team? Is that why he’s been penalised to 9th?
I think that’s a bit harsh. While I don’t think he should get pick 1 because 12Chill abandoned his team, I don’t think Jonzi should be penalised that severely.
Maybe he should get a randomly generated placing from 4-10, or something similar? What are other coaches thoughts?

 

[majortinkle]

Was thinking, did Jonzi take over 12Chill’s team? Is that why he’s been penalised to 9th?
I think that’s a bit harsh. While I don’t think he should get pick 1 because 12Chill abandoned his team, I don’t think Jonzi should be penalised that severely.
Maybe he should get a randomly generated placing from 4-10, or something similar? What are other coaches thoughts?

Not sure - where am I on the list - maybe random above that.....

Only kidding - he must be armooos team. Whoever took 12chill would have an earlier pick than that. Armooo and saintbatty managed right up to the end and finished where they did due to their players

12chill was too low because he jacked it in. Whoever got his team got a better pick than they should if anything

Having said that I’ve no problem randomising last years finalists but i was about to offer some players for picks tonight and the idea would stuff that up

Is it really that big a deal considering the players available?

 

[St Kilda Death]

Jonzi took on chills team.
Chills team tanked.
I made a call on short notice to penalise by sending 1st pick behind all but premiers.
It is open for debate until the draft, but we need to decide soon if we are to start drafting.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Jonzi took on chills team.
Chills team tanked.
I made a call on short notice to penalise by sending 1st pick behind all but premiers.
It is open for debate until the draft, but we need to decide soon if we are to start drafting.

Yeah, that’s what I thought. I don’t think Jonzi should be penalised completely. Let the RNG (random number generator) gods decide his fate. Somewhere from 4-10? Happy to film it and upload it aha.

Every other team should be based on ladder and finals placings from last year tho!

 

[Jonzi]

Bring on the lucky dip....

 

[majortinkle]

Jonzi took on chills team.
Chills team tanked.
I made a call on short notice to penalise by sending 1st pick behind all but premiers.
It is open for debate until the draft, but we need to decide soon if we are to start drafting.

Oh right I didn’t realise you’d done that. I was just going to put them in the order that the teams actually finished. I just hadn’t worked it out yet.

I don’t see the point of penalising personally. It’s not like danger is up for grabs. I’m not sure there’s any season changers available - unless someone wants to give me some hints......

 

[St Kilda Death]

Oh right I didn’t realise you’d done that. I was just going to put them in the order that the teams actually finished. I just hadn’t worked it out yet.

I don’t see the point of penalising personally. It’s not like danger is up for grabs. I’m not sure there’s any season changers available - unless someone wants to give me some hints......

For the scraps draft it wouldn't matter, just considering cursing, and now bogan who inherited Drouin danger, actually missed finals without tanking might deserve the leg up when it comes to first choice of this year's kids.

Also when I did it, it was for the redistribution draft, and danger wasn't available, but Ablett was!

 

[Phoenix_9]

Just penalise him from 1st to 4th? Like this post if you’re fine with that.

 

[majortinkle]

For the scraps draft it wouldn't matter, just considering cursing, and now bogan who inherited Drouin danger, actually missed finals without tanking might deserve the leg up when it comes to first choice of this year's kids.

Also when I did it, it was for the redistribution draft, and danger wasn't available, but Ablett was!

Ha, I didn't check whether danger had been available in the redistribution. I agree if we'd gone that way there would have been a big step down in quality at some point and it could have made a difference.

I make it that with no penalties the draft order would be:
1.Bogan
2.Jonzi
3.Cursing
4.Simonoz
5.Orazio
6.Major
7.Death
8.Left
9.Phoenix
10.Pet

I think Cursing is dropping a place from how last season looked like panning out before 12chill stopped posting teams, but otherwise its ok - he wouldn't have been guaranteed to be higher (probably would have mind you).

Cursing liked my post saying no penalties so I reckon we go with this - any objections can reply to this post and we can see if we can come up with a solution tomorrow.

 

[PetWussy]

Ha, I didn't check whether danger had been available in the redistribution. I agree if we'd gone that way there would have been a big step down in quality at some point and it could have made a difference.

I make it that with no penalties the draft order would be:
1.Bogan
2.Jonzi
3.Cursing
4.Simonoz
5.Orazio
6.Major
7.Death
8.Left
9.Phoenix
10.Pet

I think Cursing is dropping a place from how last season looked like panning out before 12chill stopped posting teams, but otherwise its ok - he wouldn't have been guaranteed to be higher (probably would have mind you).

Cursing liked my post saying no penalties so I reckon we go with this - any objections can reply to this post and we can see if we can come up with a solution tomorrow.

Last..ahh lol and dangers defs not up for grabs. First pick back when first draft happened couldnt have been a primer selection