Universal Love Sidebottoms Form...

[TradeDraft]

Has been very good. Last season he Started On Fire then Dropped away badly.

But This season it has been kept a High Level and Seems like he is keeping himself in this Form.

Getting Quite a Few Touches and Using it well.

Smoky Chance for AA.

Thoughts?

 

[ash84]

he has been good, but not AA.
Has had a few games where he has gone missing for too long.
Hasn't kicked enough goals to make the team in the fwd line.
Has no chance of making it in the midfield.

 

[TradeDraft]

he has been good, but not AA.
Has had a few games where he has gone missing for too long.
Hasn't kicked enough goals to make the team in the fwd line.
Has no chance of making it in the midfield.

So you would send him to the VFL then?

 

[tazzawazza]

Has been very good. Last season he Started On Fire then Dropped away badly.

But This season it has been kept a High Level and Seems like he is keeping himself in this Form.

Getting Quite a Few Touches and Using it well.

Smoky Chance for AA.

Thoughts?

Was in All Australian form in the first half of the season last year, then dropped away completely second half. Similar season so far, hopefully he can keep his good form.

 

[jamieb1983]

So you would send him to the VFL then?

Such a silly post. He never said hed send him to the vfl.

You asked for thoughts and were given one which you didnt like.


Sidebottom is not in AA form

 

[Pie in the Sky]

He's been OK, played a couple of very good games and some average ones. Think he can play better to be honest.

 

[the mighty T]

I actually think hes been average to be honest. Hasn't used the ball particularly brilliantly, hasnt really impacted the scoreboard and in general hasnt been in the same form as this time last season.

I think he's got a lot more to show us

 

[Frankie23]

So you would send him to the VFL then?

Well that escalated quickly...

 

[bucksisbest]

He did some very good things today and was unobtrusive for the rest of the game. I'm not satisfied where he is at overall, but he has had some good games this year.

Harry O is our AA level player.

 

[Mickaman]

Good but not AA.

 

[Hotpies4]

Sorry but disagree with AA form, not even close. Far more better players ahead of him. He's been ok in patches, don't think he's consistent though. Drops off at times, then goes in hard. If he misses a tackle, does not rebound and get back into it. Occasionally has appeared to be lazy and waits for the ball.

 

[TheBigH]

He is one player that is copping unfair criticism at the moment (Or maybe it is just the people around me at the footy). He is having a great year and has been good for quite a while. His disposal is very good, rarely turns it over, can win contested ball etc etc. Not AA yet, however, he has been very good. I have no doubt he will be close by years end. Getting players like Beams back will help him as well.

 

[MeisterBot]

Not in AA form. Also think he's being played out of position due to necessity. I really don't see him as a wingman/engine room midfielder.

 

[ash84]

So you would send him to the VFL then?

Geez. That is probably the most idiotic thing i've seen posted on here.
Believe it or not we probably have 20 players in our best 22 that aren't AA...

 

[blaze036]

Sidebottom is a player who you can't tell whether he is overrated or underrated.

Sometimes frustrating, but has tonnes of great attributes and works hard

 

[Scodog10]

Up and down.

Much like the team unfortunately.

Beams coming back in the second half of the season will help him more than any other player though

 

[TradeDraft]

Such a silly post. He never said hed send him to the vfl.

You asked for thoughts and were given one which you didnt like.


Sidebottom is not in AA form

Then he said he does not Kick Enough Goals to be a Forward and saying he is a Dud Midfielder.

So what the F**k is he?

 

[jamieb1983]

Then he said he does not Kick Enough Goals to be a Forward and saying he is a Dud Midfielder.

So what the F**k is he?

Theres no mention of dud midfielder either. No one is saying steele is a dud just not in good enough form to be AA geez get a grip

 

[Scodog10]

Then he said he does not Kick Enough Goals to be a Forward and saying he is a Dud Midfielder.

So what the F**k is he?

FFS TD he meant that he hasn't kicked enough goals to be in the AA team and that he won't be making the AA team in the midfield.

If you didn't quite understand the content of the post just ask for clarification instead of flying off the handle like a kid that's just been told that Christmas has been cancelled!

 

[ash84]

Then he said he does not Kick Enough Goals to be a Forward and saying he is a Dud Midfielder.

So what the F**k is he?

Not once did i say he is a dud midfielder.
I said he has no chance of making the AA team as a midfielder, and hasn't kicked enough goals to make it as a fwd.

He is a good player, thats what he is.

Mod Edit: Removed insult (FYI ash84)

 

[TradeDraft]

Theres no mention of dud midfielder either. No one is saying steele is a dud just not in good enough form to be AA geez get a grip

Well sound like he says as a Player he was saying it about and not for the AA Team

 

[jamieb1983]

Well sound like he says as a Player he was saying it about and not for the AA Team

You seem to ne the only one that read it wrong

 

[tazzawazza]

My Mid Year All-Australian team (Collingwood players)

- Harry
- Sidey
- Pendles/Swan
- Cloke

If Lynch could kick, he would probably have 15-20 goals by now and he would be in there for me as well.

 

[TradeDraft]

You seem to ne the only one that read it wrong

Well Sorry Then We all can't be Geniuses

Your an idiot, not once did i say he is a dud midfielder.
I said he has no chance of making the AA team as a midfielder, and hasn't kicked enough goals to make it as a fwd.

He is a good player, thats what he is.

I admit I got it wrong but calling me an Idiot is Uncalled for

 

[ash84]

TD, Sidey has been good, but where would you play him in your AA team?