Stringer and Cloke both dumped....

[Markfs]

Stringer being dumped to the VFL is an obvious sign that the Dogs dont want him anymore. What else could it mean? Obviously Cloke has one foot out the door.

Rumours that Cloke could be going to the Dogs is obviously a signpost that Stringer is coming to the Pies.

I think it's a good swap. Thoughts???

 

[RupetFan]

Stringer being dumped to the VFL is an obvious sign that the Dogs dont want him anymore. What else could it mean? Obviously Cloke has one foot out the door.

Rumours that Cloke could be going to the Dogs is obviously a signpost that Stringer is coming to the Pies.

I think it's a good swap. Thoughts???

absolutely. cloke and a third for stringer and their first, witts to gws for Hoskin - Elliot and tomlinson (gun) and then first on that young forward I only suggest because he's a a "Tall forward" battle.

 

[Markfs]

absolutely. cloke and a third for stringer and their first, witts to gws for Hoskin - Elliot and tomlinson (gun) and then first on that young forward I only suggest because he's a a "Tall forward" battle.

You must be crazy to post a deal like that.... we might have to use the third round to sweeten the deal for stringer but i'd be waiting until the last possible minute to offer him to the dogs. I'd be offering blair to GWS and saving Witts for bigger fish....

 

[JOELY]

Finally some realistic trade scenarios.

 

[TW Sherrin]

Apparently Jake pinched Beveridges skateboard.

 

[RupetFan]

You must be crazy to post a deal like that.... we might have to use the third round to sweeten the deal for stringer but i'd be waiting until the last possible minute to offer him to the dogs. I'd be offering blair to GWS and saving Witts for bigger fish....

blair for hoskin elliot, tomlinson and 1st rounder seems fair.

 

[adammania9]

How does dropping a player mean the club doesn't want them anymore? He's a lazy footballer and they're showing them they're not afraid of sending him down to the seconds for a week. 100% guarantee he'll be recalled for next week. To me, it just looks like they're resting him for a guaranteed win. No way will they get rid of him unless the world gets thrown at them.

 

[Kilmo]

I doubt it will be a straight swap.

Possible trade scenario:

Out: Witts
In: Stringer & Witts

 

[Anzacday]

I think the OP took a dare.
I'm not a fan of Stringer, too inconsistent and selfish for me, (and over-rated).
We just got Fasolo right, don't want another one.

 

[Markfs]

blair for hoskin elliot, tomlinson and 1st rounder seems fair.

i see you have a soft spot for gws....

 

[Markfs]

I think the OP took a dare.
I'm not a fan of Stringer, too inconsistent and selfish for me, (and over-rated).
We just got Fasolo right, don't want another one.

well stringer is gone from the dogs. He's playing in the vfl this week. If we dont take him someone else will. clokey deserves the same respect we gave to Sav Rocca when Malthouse turfed him out the door....we should swap the two

 

[Anzacday]

well stringer is gone from the dogs. He's playing in the vfl this week. If we dont take him someone else will. clokey deserves the same respect we gave to Sav Rocca when Malthouse turfed him out the door....we should swap the two

He had a bad game.

 

[RupetFan]

How does dropping a player mean the club doesn't want them anymore? He's a lazy footballer and they're showing them they're not afraid of sending him down to the seconds for a week. 100% guarantee he'll be recalled for next week. To me, it just looks like they're resting him for a guaranteed win. No way will they get rid of him unless the world gets thrown at them.

It's called sarcasm...

 

[PicaBoo]

Vickery being dumped to the VFL is an obvious sign that the Tigs dont want him anymore. What else could it mean? Obviously Cloke has one foot in the door.

Rumours that Cloke could be going to the Tig is obviously a signpost that Ty is coming to the Pies.

I think it's sucks. Thoughts???

EFA

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

I doubt it will be a straight swap.

Possible trade scenario:

Out: Witts
In: Stringer & Witts

Confused: Witts

 

[pablo disco bar]

Ia this for real? No chance of happening

 

[Saintly Viewed]

How does dropping a player mean the club doesn't want them anymore? He's a lazy footballer and they're showing them they're not afraid of sending him down to the seconds for a week. 100% guarantee he'll be recalled for next week. To me, it just looks like they're resting him for a guaranteed win. No way will they get rid of him unless the world gets thrown at them.

If we dropped stinger they'd be hell to pay around here.
But the darling Beverage does it, send message etc.
It's he right move by the way.

 

[Vicky Park]

It's really pleasing to see Markfs venturing into trading scenarios. Especially those based on solid sources and detailed analysis, and not flimsy speculation and fanciful conjecture. Some of you others could learn from him.

 

[Hardas]

Finally some realistic trade scenarios.

HAHAHAHAHA!!!

 

[Hardas]

It's really pleasing to see Markfs venturing into trading scenarios. Especially those based on solid sources and detailed analysis, and not flimsy speculation and fanciful conjecture. Some of you others could learn from him.

Here, here!

 

[frizzle]

How does dropping a player mean the club doesn't want them anymore? He's a lazy footballer and they're showing them they're not afraid of sending him down to the seconds for a week. 100% guarantee he'll be recalled for next week. To me, it just looks like they're resting him for a guaranteed win. No way will they get rid of him unless the world gets thrown at them.

Boooooooo - I was quite enjoying the trade scenarios.
I'm pretty sure each & every one of them will happen.
I'm just going to sit back & be smug from now on. Well done guys.

 

[frizzle]

I think Markfs is Hine or Rendell. It just makes sense.
Come on Markfs - Fess up buddy.

 

[SpongePie]

Wow Stringers stock has fallen greatly.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Is my sarcasm metre broken?

 

[BEEG]

Haha Dogs supporters would burn down Whitten oval if they traded Stringer.