SuperCoach Grand Final selection thread

[The Sultan]

Fellow SC's.....I am in the GF in a cash league at work and am contemplating a strategy to go for the win, they guy i am playing agst has a few differences with me in the backs, diffs are:
me
Puopolo
Gibson
Broughton

Him
Adcock
Suckling
Daniel Talia.

whilst we boths have
Gibbs
Goddard
Enright
Delidio
Fisher

so contemplating benching one of the players that we both have i.e. enright so that I have three points of difference in the backs, if this a worth while risk and is enright the man to bench??

due to plethora of outs (and no trades left ) have nothing I can do in terms of changes to my mids, rucks, and fwds.

 

[toxic]

Re: SC Grand Finals Strategy - Opinions Please.

Fellow SC's.....I am in the GF in a cash league at work and am contemplating a strategy to go for the win, they guy i am playing agst has a few differences with me in the backs, diffs are:
me
Puopolo
Gibson
Broughton

Him
Adcock
Suckling
Daniel Talia.

whilst we boths have
Gibbs
Goddard
Enright
Delidio
Fisher

so contemplating benching one of the players that we both have i.e. enright so that I have three points of difference in the backs, if this a worth while risk and is enright the man to bench??

due to plethora of outs (and no trades left ) have nothing I can do in terms of changes to my mids, rucks, and fwds.

Can't see benching enright as a viable option - go with two of your other 3 and fingers crossed, quick qestion - have you benched enright all season?? if answer is No why start now??

 

[The Sultan]

Re: SC Grand Finals Strategy - Opinions Please.

Whom should I bench then? Have had puopolo on bench but he killed it last week

 

[toxic]

Re: SC Grand Finals Strategy - Opinions Please.

Whom should I bench then? Have had puopolo on bench but he killed it last week

id go gibson on the bench, not sure why but poo seems to be getting more midfied time and broughton surely will play mid as well

 

[Ed D]

Re: SC Grand Finals Strategy - Opinions Please.

I'd probably bench either Gibson or Broughton, although really any of those players mentioned could score well.

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Re: SC Grand Finals Strategy - Opinions Please.

Broughton seems to be struggling with injury..

FWIW, the only bloke who deserves his own thread on this board in Prompts.

 

[Reg Hickey]

Backline conundrum

Hey guys,

I'm in 3 GFs this week, and have a tricky decision in my backline - 7 spots available and 8 good players to fill them. Who to leave out?

The players are: Goddard, S Fisher, Deledio, Gibbs, Bock, Broughton, Enright and Suckling. Who's most likely to spud it up out of that lot??

Was originally thinking Broughton given his form has been average and he seems to have a rib problem, but with Freo having so many out you'd think he'd spend more time in the middle than usual which is where he's racked up his big scores. Enright against Pies could be shut down. S Fisher hasn't been in great form but scored 120 vs Blues last time and has put up some huge numbers at the 'G this year. Gibbs v Saints?? Aaaahhhh!

And I know I could move Goddard, Deledio or Gibbs to the midfield, but have a full list there of Pendles, Swan, Ablett, Boyd, Dal Santo and S Thompson, and don't want to leave any of those blokes out either.

All thoughts greatly appreciated!!

 

[rocker_oz33]

l have a full team this week but slim pickings with talia and one of s mckernan or callinan on the ground l think callinan could be the sub.where mckernan could get subbed off mmm which way to go grrr.dam you sylvia and lower and hawthorn.

 

[ubeaut]

Re: Backline conundrum

Hey guys,

I'm in 3 GFs this week, and have a tricky decision in my backline - 7 spots available and 8 good players to fill them. Who to leave out?

The players are: Goddard, S Fisher, Deledio, Gibbs, Bock, Broughton, Enright and Suckling. Who's most likely to spud it up out of that lot??

Was originally thinking Broughton given his form has been average and he seems to have a rib problem, but with Freo having so many out you'd think he'd spend more time in the middle than usual which is where he's racked up his big scores. Enright against Pies could be shut down. S Fisher hasn't been in great form but scored 120 vs Blues last time and has put up some huge numbers at the 'G this year. Gibbs v Saints?? Aaaahhhh!

And I know I could move Goddard, Deledio or Gibbs to the midfield, but have a full list there of Pendles, Swan, Ablett, Boyd, Dal Santo and S Thompson, and don't want to leave any of those blokes out either.

All thoughts greatly appreciated!!

On recent form and taking injury/sorenes into account Broughton on the pine. I'd do it myself but unfortunately I have to play him.
Who to bench out of Didak,I.Smith and Mzungu?

 

[ubeaut]

HIM - ME -


Grundy Broughton
Talia Puopolo

D.Swallow Boyd
Liberatore Selwood

Smith Sandilands

Lecras Daulhaus
Yarran N.Riewoldt
Darling ?
Lobbe ?
Looking at my match up, who gets the last spots? Didak,Mzungu I.Smith? Who misses out? This is hard!

 

[Spudregus_87]

Re: SC Grand Finals Strategy - Opinions Please.

FWIW, the only bloke who deserves his own thread on this board in Prompts.

This

FFS, you've been around here long enough to know better Sultan

 

[rocker_oz33]

^^ thats a tough call i smith playing suns Mzungu at home on the padlocks of subi and could be moer mid time with no pav fyfe etc.and theres dids who could score well.

 

[The Sultan]

Re: SC Grand Finals Strategy - Opinions Please.

Broughton seems to be struggling with injury..

FWIW, the only bloke who deserves his own thread on this board in Prompts.

so why not shut down every thread on the board other than the one that Impromptu posts in?????

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Re: SC Grand Finals Strategy - Opinions Please.

so why not shut down every thread on the board other than the one that Impromptu posts in?????

Because I'm not a mod!

There are Trade and Player v Player threads already