Remove this Banner Ad

Tarks, Woey, obree?

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

tarrant

Senior List
Suspended
Sep 30, 2004
226
0
Other Teams
collingwood
out of these three players...who would you keep..


i believe shane woewodin has alot more to offer the club than the other two.......
 
Keep all of them!

If I was the coach, and we weren't crippled with injuries, they'd probably wouldn't get a game. Still, all three of them are handy in their own weird ways.

We complain about depth, then complain that our depth players aren't A-graders!

The key is to have them paid accordingly and to also let them know that they have to do some amazing feats to get a gig. Would be very healthy for the Club!

Of course if we can get a trade for any of them, which is doubtful on a risk/return feasibility, then by all means flick em!!
 
The reality is we need to clear 10 spaces on our list if we wish to use all our draft picks and promote some rookies, which means there is 4 more to go. Because of this, we will either have to delist players or most likely accept trades that aren't really fair. For Tarks we can't expect anything under a pick 20, and O'bree and Woey 30-40.

I think they're all in trouble, although I like Woey and Tarks and won't be upset if they stay.
 
Trade all 3 plus Chad Morrison. While we have these players on the list they will play and we will be slow, soft and poorly skilled. These guys are the problem with our game plan as much as anything. If I could be sure only 1 at most would ever play then they could be ok as depth but there isn't much point having players solely as depth for each other. In any event I am sure 3 to 4 will nearly always play and on that basis we can't move forward.

The fact is these guys played and we invariably lost. When required to step up and win games they couldn't do it. O'Bree was bets of that lot but his best is rare and he still turns it over. If we are going to carry Rhyce Shaw and Johnson then that's enough dicey disposal and O'Bree has to go so I can’t see how we can keep any of them. We will though. I’ll be surprised if more than 1 goes and not surprised if they all stay for another year of frustrating, painful mediocrity and what’s worse, at 200k+.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Tony Francis said:
The reality is we need to clear 10 spaces on our list if we wish to use all our draft picks and promote some rookies, which means there is 4 more to go. Because of this, we will either have to delist players or most likely accept trades that aren't really fair. For Tarks we can't expect anything under a pick 20, and O'bree and Woey 30-40.

I think they're all in trouble, although I like Woey and Tarks and won't be upset if they stay.

i dont know what teh dpeth of teh draft is going to be like but i dont think it would warrant trading woewodin or obree for pick inbetween 30-40. If we are one day to be dominant players like that are needed as depth players or 4th 5th string midfielders in our case!

but to answer the original question id trade woewodin because he will not be around by the time we get around to winning a premiership! obree and tarks are in the prime and are both awesome players if we cant find anything better!

i believe that everybody is tradeable for the price (bar bucks and burnsy guernsey and the rest that have been supporting the club thru the tough times)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Tarks, Woey, obree?

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top