Remove this Banner Ad

Review The Midseason Review

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Ludovico

Team Captain
Jul 28, 2017
354
1,619
AFL Club
Collingwood
I thought this could be a good time to do a bit of a review of our season so far, what has gone right, what we are seeing, and a look forward to the rest of the season.

The numbers

At the top line the numbers tell a story. 11 wins 2 losses and a percentage of 134.

On pure numbers we are almost identical to our equivalent position in 2023. I dont think it is that simple though, and I feel we are better placed than we were in 2023.

What's different

Our system, particularly defensively, seems to have developed to a stronger degree and is harder for opposition teams to break down. We have more tall options in our forward line, giving us flexibility, and run from defence is improved with our ins.

We seem mostly able to keep opponents at arms length more effectively, with a pleasing decrease in heart attack finishes (tough wood).

Its notable this has come while often losing clearances. The mantras of the past seem to have been abandoned and it works for us so far.

Improvers

One thing that stands out for us is how many I see in this category who are older players. Collingwood (at least in the Malthouse and Buckley years) were renowned for players falling off a cliff once their ages got that 3 at the start. Now we seem capable of renewal and reinvigoration well into the 30s'.

Unless we have found a deposit of the Spice Melange, you have to give a huge thumbs up to conditioning and coaching here.

Sidey

I thought he was gone a few years ago. Now he looks like a young greyhound tongue out running around to empty every other dogs food bowl before they can catch him.

Howe

An intercept marking behemoth, seemingly unbothered by his former leg issues and in some ways taking the lead in this which covers for some challenges for Darcy.

Billy

Having a career defining year. After all his injury worries through his career, this one tastes especially sweet. My favourite Magpie.


Add to this some players new or not as new finding a new level or refinding a high level.

Ned Long

Not much needs to be said. Changes out inside midfield dynamic and still with significant room for growth.

Issac Quaynor

One who had a poor year last year for mine but has bounced back strongly.

Darcy Cameron

Would be in AA consideration and his marking around the ground is a barometer of our play.

Ed Allan

HAs stepped up to deliver AFL level performance and as he gains confidence I think can be a weapon on the wing.



Where can we improve?

Well, two names stand out for mine. One is JDG - has been essentially nonexistent this year. If he can get his body right has the potential to be a difference maker in the late season.

The second is Darcy Moore. Patchy form nor helped by his injury. I felt he was getting there right when he copped the shoulder injury and is now back down the hill trying to climb.

Both could add an extra dimension to our play if they get it in place by finals.



What could go wrong?

Injuries remain the known unknown but apart from Darcy Cameron or our key backs, I am confident we can cover.


The crystal ball.

At the moment the side that really scares me, and the only one that does, is Geelong. I feel we can take the others but the Cats have the abaility to pick through our system and has the forward firepower to make their forward entries hurt enough.




So, what are your thoughts? Anything you disagree with? Agree with? Pineapple on pizza?
 
I think we're pretty well placed. Our backline is playing incredibly well, stopping big scores coming against us and getting some really good attacking play launched through J. Daicos, Houston & Quaynor.

Elliott, Howe and Sidebottom are playing as well as I can ever remember seeing them play. Cameron and McCreery are also in career best form.

Perryman has been an excellent pickup, Schultz is fitting in better this year, and both Houston & Membrey are growing in their roles. Long has been a revelation.

The best part is the room for improvement. N. Daicos, Houston and De Goey are the big ones for me. Having three incredibly good players with some real levels to lift is pretty exciting
 
Love where we're at. There's only been one game this season where I wasn't confident at that was against Freo given the 5 day break and the players we had out. I think winning that game has given this group enormous confidence.

As gouki88 said above, we scarily have room for improvement. Our backline is the best in the comp and Houston, J.Daicos and Quaynor are only getting better as the season progresses. Moore has the opportunity to regain his pre shoulder injury form too. I feel like we've hardly had continuity in our backline due to injury which is crazy given how they're playing.

Our midfield has been fine at generating scores though we're yet to see what a fit JDG or Mitchell can do with Long in there. We're lucky to be in a position where we can tweak our midfield rotation prior to finals.

Our forward line is looking bloody good and similar to the backline, we haven't had much continuity with McStay, Schultz and Mihocek missing games.

The league knows we've got room to improve as well. It's why the cliche question of "are they peaking early?" is being shut down.

We have the potential to see something special unfold over the next 3 months.
 
Club42 Dinner last night.
Leadership group in attendance.

Bruzzy was asked if this is the best backline group he’s played with.
He reflected on 2018, saying that group was amazing and that Langmuir made a huge difference as backline coach. Got them playing to an amazing system. That defence he thought was second only to the current group.

But he thought a big part of the difference is also that this year we have the forwards to convert the rebounds and score and that is what makes this team better.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Geelong are a huge threat to our chances.

The thing with them is they have been developing and implementing a plan that combats our strengths.

A couple of points in that plan includes:

- Mullin to daicos - Mullin can play midfield and down back, I’d hope if we faced them in finals fly is brave enough to throw Daicos to Half back to break the tag as mullin can’t really play as a half fwd and it would take him to a place he hasn’t played before.

- Dempsey as a marking, goal square to goal square wingmen (Scott has done this is the past to us using Blicavs)

Scott has been getting games into a plan that’s built to beat us.
Scott is coaching smart to negate our strengths.

I have faith in fly to be doing the same and picking apart Geelong’s game style, but I think
 
I feel like this team is better than 2023, we’re putting teams to the sword rather than going into defensive mode with a 2 goal lead with 10 mins to go

The Hawks and Lions really stand out for that among others

Just have to keep this up, we will drop some games towards the end (it’s just how it is for every team at the top)

And as someone else said Geelong will be our thorn in our side
 
Big room for improvement if Jordy comes back as a good version of himself.

Not sure what Mitch can add as Ned seems to have gone past him.

Nick is clearly below last years output so can go up a few notches when he strikes form.

If we need Cox as a 2nd ruck, he needs to rediscover some of his best form.

Q and Moore as shown in their bottom of ladder status in the Didaka award are having below par seasons.
 
What’s better:

Biggest difference IMO is that we no longer have a clear “Best 22”. It’s more like a “Best 25”, with around 3 players rotating through each week with rest or short term injury. Have a look at the side to picked to play St Kilda, it’s solid with perhaps Sullivan the only fringe player. And we still have Maynard, Schultz, Mitchell, and DeGoey on the sidelines. And I know Cox isn’t exactly the flavour of the month but he’s a handy backup, as is Markov.

Ned Long and Ed Allan have been solid contributors and cemented their spots in the team this year - which is remarkable given Ned Long has only played 25 AFL games, and Ed Allan only 10.

Billy Frampton has shown remarkable improvement this year.

The senior players have been solid this year with no noticeable dropping off.

Giving a player - Will Hayes - a taste of senior footy has been a nice bonus. Maybe if we’re able to qualify quickly, we can see a bit more of our future exposed to senior footy.

What needs to improve:

Clearances, we need to improve our clearances. We’ve been smashed at them in the last 5 or so games. It’ll be interesting to see if / when Mitchell comes back in - I’m surprised he wasn’t brought in for Sullivan for the St Kilda game.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Review The Midseason Review

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top