Top 70 players since 2000

[Substance]

Shaun Burgoyne grossly over rated. All Australian once, never club best and fairest.

You seen him play finals yeah?

 

[OnceKicked50]

As much as it pains me to say it, Stephen Milne should be in there somewhere late.

 

[magpieswmb]

Robbie Gray has been AA 4 times.

yeah mistake by me, should be in there, but its hard, every player in the list is quality

 

[magpieswmb]

Definitely good criteria to make a list. Goddard (2x AA) and Dal Santo (3x AA) unlucky, I'd take them over Thompson (Ade) and Kerr, both with 1 AA.

Josh P Kennedy should be higher, he's been immense in finals. Josh J Kennedy also deserves a spot.

Jono Brown too high. Great player at his peak but wasn't there for long enough. There's no way he's above Lloyd

yeah west coast kennedy has had a solid career, should be in there, probaly a better play than s.thompson and kerr

yeah lloyd was more consistent

 

[magpieswmb]

Jack Riewoldt, 3 x Coleman Medals - you're surely taking the piss?

my bad, his not in the list, you think better than neitz or Loewe?

 

[magpieswmb]

Good list. Barry Hall unlucky from a Swans perspective.

yep, 4 time aa, better than neitz or Loewe?

 

[Hounddd]

my bad, his not in the list, you think better than neitz or Loewe?

Yep