Trade with Blues

[barnesy]

In all honestly would you tiger supporters be interested in:

Whitnall / Hulme for Bowden / Zantuck or Rodan

Not being smug, smart or anything about this.

On the surface this may sound good, may sound bad, but we all know with trades that there is often more to it than it seems on the surface.

Eg - Salary restrictions, new coach's thoughts on what they can get out of a player etc

Bowden has proven something (obviously) this year, I would love him at Carlton, while Whitnall simply has historical Potential, but depends on how much of a calculated risk a coach is prepared to take.

While Hulme will give some mental and physical hardness.

 

[corporal]

In all honestly would you tiger supporters be interested in:

Whitnall / Hulme for Bowden / Zantuck or Rodan

Not being smug, smart or anything about this.

On the surface this may sound good, may sound bad, but we all know with trades that there is often more to it than it seems on the surface.

Eg - Salary restrictions, new coach's thoughts on what they can get out of a player etc

Bowden has proven something (obviously) this year, I would love him at Carlton, while Whitnall simply has historical Potential, but depends on how much of a calculated risk a coach is prepared to take.

While Hulme will give some mental and physical hardness.

We have enough talentless scubbers who try hard, so you can keep Hume,

We already have a injury prone forward in Richo, I guess we would give you Zantuck & Rodan for him if his salary wasn't more then 250,000

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

unlikely!!

Bowden is a new cult hero at Richmond now after his one good season.

LOL

I'd offer you Rodan and Zantuck for peanuts, pretty much what they are worth.

 

[Colonel Matrix]

No offense intended, but if Greg Miller even thought about this trade, he would be shipped off to go work for Frawley on his spud farm in Ballarat.

 

[SurreyBlue]

No offense taken but if Carlton even considered this trade, I would shoot someone. Fairdinkum.

 

[itsintheblood]

No offense taken but if Carlton even considered this trade, I would shoot someone. Fairdinkum.

I've got a few spare guns for you surrey. Carefull you dont hurt yourself now.

I think the trade is fair. Rodan for whitnall and a draft pick is reasonable. Anyone who takes witnall off your hands is doing you a HUGE favour.

 

[Colonel Matrix]

Surely the Blues are trying to get rid of Camporeale, am I the most mistaken footy fan in the comp, believing that he's one of the biggest hacks in the league?

Bring back Ratten, Bradley, Brown, all in their prime, and then he might play well.

 

[koutawalker]

We have enough talentless scubbers who try hard, so you can keep Hume,

Or axe him. How would Ottens for Whitnall sound?

 

[chilled]

Or axe him. How would Ottens for Whitnall sound?

No chance. Even if Ottens was blindfolded with one leg and one arm I wouldn't do that trade. For the simple reason that if this was the case Ottens would still be able to play better than Whitnall. Carlton would have to pay us if they wanted to get rid of Whitnall.

 

[Bojangles17]

In all honestly would you tiger supporters be interested in:

Whitnall / Hulme for Bowden / Zantuck or Rodan

.

Congratulations on posting the stupidist concoction thus far in the prelude to the silly season

an overweight hasbeen/reserves hack for RFC B&F plus another....as a weaver once said...you could not smoke sh$%^ strong enough to even warp ones mind to a point that it could be positive.

Pls reconsider your posts in this forum with some respect to ornaments of the game

 

[Sideshow Fev]

I don't think this will work Richmond will never trade their B&F winner and no-one seems to rate Whitnall for some reason. I think that Carlton should look at Zantuck - maybe Livingston+Hulme for Zantuck. Livingston was a no. 4 pick who has a lot of potential and has been unlucky not to play more games while Hulme has been injured most of the year but will add some much needed grunt to the richmond midfield. Thoughts ?

 

[corporal]

I don't think this will work Richmond will never trade their B&F winner and no-one seems to rate Whitnall for some reason. I think that Carlton should look at Zantuck - maybe Livingston+Hulme for Zantuck. Livingston was a no. 4 pick who has a lot of potential and has been unlucky not to play more games while Hulme has been injured most of the year but will add some much needed grunt to the richmond midfield. Thoughts ?

Do not want Hulme whatsoever, would possibly look at Livingston though I have never see him play,

 

[Darth_Tiger]

whitnall for zantuck, a fat washed up has been for a pshychotic raging lunatic with an attitude problem. sounds pretty fair to me. LMAO.