Umpiring

[Kildonan]

After a good effort by the umpires Saints v Hawthorn, I was very disappointed with their effort in the Saints v Collingwood. This was a good win but frustrating in that obvious free kicks were missed consistently for St Kilda yet pitiful decisions went Collingwood's way. These eroneous decisions marred the match.

 

[m.diddy]

After a good effort by the umpires Saints v Hawthorn, I was very disappointed with their effort in the Saints v Collingwood. This was a good win but frustrating in that obvious free kicks were missed consistently for St Kilda yet pitiful decisions went Collingwood's way. These eroneous decisions marred the match.

I really didn't think they were that bad, sure there were a few dodgy ones like the one for the G-train but they were just made to look bad by the constant whinging and the fact that most were in goal range.