Untouchables

[Schulzycrow]

I want to keep Keath..pay him the contract to keep him.
Then get rid of Hartigan.

Lets not sit here and say we should have kept Keath down the track.

Problem is we might get something for Keath trade wise Hartigan...pack of twisties.

 

[Golumless]

Judging any player (particularly young uns) based on their performance under this regime is fraught.
Bring in coaches and a system that players believe in and watch players like Milera, Gallucci, EH, Fogarty, Stengle improve. For that matter, im not convinced Gibbs is cooked either. He plays like a fringe player at the moment, but he was absolutely elite at Carlton. The Carlton fans I know were genuinely shattered to lose him. Maybe he’s just magically transformed into an average footballer, but I suspect his 2019 performance is linked to the way the club is run.

This is actually the likely scenario wth Gibbs. Unfortunately, a large portion of a player's performance does rely on external factors, such as structure, and how you cover their weaknesses. That said, fix structures, and you should get an upswing in performance from Gibbs, it probably won't be as much as you are expecting just due to age/weariness.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Problem is we might get something for Keath trade wise Hartigan...pack of twisties.

We don't need more picks as will have plenty after players are traded out.

 

[Truck25]

Why is there so much hate for Kelly?
He's been one of our better players this year.
It's like everyone's stuck in 2017, which is ironic because that's when the same people want us to stop focussing on

A major part of the problem for the last 2 years is ball movement out of defense, Kelly, Harto and Tahlia are excellent stoppers but god awfully slow with ball in hand. you can carry 1 stopper but not 3. Big reason we can't move the ball. Keath is better than Harto and Doedee much better than Kelly with ball in hand and comparable on defense. End of the Day Kelly is just way to slow to move the ball.

 

[Damp Squarie]

Problem is we might get something for Keath trade wise Hartigan...pack of twisties.

Keep Hartigan as "Terrible Depth" then...we did it last year with Otten
We will get done in any trade for Keath; it's what we do.