Votes bog-wog

[djudd]

BOG

5.Fev 8 goals great but could of been just a bit better

4.Judd-

3.Murphy(I have backed him from day 1 and im glad i did)

2.Bower (this kid will be a very good player)take note Tbird

1.Betts/Stevo/Carrots(on Hodge)Waite(like fev made 1 mistake)



WOG

5.Cloke(Outmarked by a midfielder)

4.Thornton(Shocking Day plays off his opponent NO respect for Roughy)

3.Houlahan(Tough game today>Ryan went awol)frontrunner

2.Bentley(bring back robbo)

1.Wiggens/Simpson(played his 1 good game for the month last week)
armfield(poor skills)

 

[blues4flag]

5 - Fevola
4 - Paul Bower
3 - Marc Murphy
2 - Chris Judd
1 - Nick Stevens

 

[HeziBarecket]

Votes:

Bower - 5
Fev -4
Bateman -3
Stevens -2
********, I mean ROUGHead - 1

Worst:

5 - Guerreras wig
4 - Cloke
3- Wiggo
2 - Jeff Kennet
1 - Hawthorn team as 'one hit wonders'

Simmo wasn't that bad. He 'sparked' our fightback. Fevola stuffed it up. I hope he learns from it and next week kicks 12 against Freo. It would be poetic justice.

 

[ParaBellum]

5 - Kruezer
4 - Fevola
3 - Bower
2 - Stevens
1 - Judd

 

[TerryWallet]

Best

KRUEZER
Fevola
Waite
Judd


Worst

CLOKE
BENTLEY
THORNTON
HOULIHAN
CHIEF
SULTANA

 

[Stig O'Hara]

5. Bower
4. Kruezer
3. Fevola
2. Stevens
1. Judd

 

[Johnny Utah #9]

BOG

5 - Fevola. Turned on some magic when we needed it most, but fell at the last hurdle. Let's hope he responds like Sticks did in 1993 when he missed against the Dons and kicked the winner against the Hawks the week after.

4 - Judd. Inspirational all day in very heavy midfield traffic.

3 - Bower - Best game by a mile. Out played Franklin all day. Buddy was very lucky to get a dubious in the back free kick in front in the last quarter.

2 - Stevens. Back to his hard running best and used it well all game.

1 - Kreuzer. Did well in the ruck, but more importantly his ground level work was excellent.

WOG

C Cloke had a shocker. Just didn't look right out there today.

Bentley seemed a little over awed. Carlos didn't help him by giving him a shocking pass that landed awkwardly at his ankles. I'll reserve my judgment on Bentley after a couple more games, but he'd want to respond pretty well from today.

 

[jj1978]

BOG
*****
5 - Judd, yes Fev kicked 8 but if not for work by our midfielders Fev wouldn't have had those opps, plus I'm marking Fev down a bit for that "point".
4 - Fev, kick the match-winner would of got the BOG.
3 - Stevens, a crappy 1st quarter then a moment in the 2nd where he went in for a hard ball get and made it and something just clicked!
2 - Kreuzer, when I hear his name that "jizz in my pants" song keeps going through my head
1 - Bower, would of kept Buddy goal-less bar Buddy's ability to kick a freaky goal on a tough angle 55m out... and 1 from those lovely umps.

WOG
******
5 - CLOKE... most saying Bentley.. but it was Bentley's first game for us off the rookie list with nerves etc against the reigning premiers. CLOKE was just SHYTE today an absolute dog of a day.
4 - Houlihan, one of our most experience and with his skills just disappointing.
3 - Russel.. the good last week.. back to the bad this week
2 - Simpson.. maybe the corky but did nothing special today.
1 - Waite... not given the hard job of being a direct opponent to Roughy or Franklin and just was not the Waite we know... a massive dog of a day for him + and that kick out

 

[Stig O'Hara]

2 - Kreuzer, when I hear his name that "jizz in my pants" song keeps going through my head
(

Line of the week

 

[Warsaw]

WOG
******
1 - Waite... not given the hard job of being a direct opponent to Roughy or Franklin and just was not the Waite we know... a massive dog of a day for him + and that kick out

That's shocking, he was good today. Far from our worst

 

[jj1978]

That's shocking, he was good today. Far from our worst

I mark Waite very highly and today he was crap compared to what I expect from him... and that kick out was just woeful!

 

[djudd]

I mark Waite very highly and today he was crap compared to what I expect from him... and that kick out was just woeful!

Like fev made 1 mistake
Waitey was good today

 

[ParaBellum]

Simpson wasn't bad either. Finally kicked a goal on the run (right foot too).

 

[Warsaw]

For what it's worth,
BOG
Fev
Judd
Murphy
Stevens
Kreuzer

 

[serenityNow]

Judd
Fev
Kreuzer (great to watch this young bloke)
Murphy ( and this one)
Bower (oooh and this one too)
Stevens

W.O.G

Cloke(pathetic game)>>>>Daylight>>>>>,Hoops,Thornton,Simpson,Wiggins,Russell..&..Bentley (yes i know first game, i just expected better.)

 

[Doza]

5 - Fevola
4 - Judd
3 - Murphy
2 - Bower
1 - Kreuzer

WOG - Cloke (probably his worst game for the club)

 

[kreuze_missile]

BOG:

5. FEVOLA: 12 scoring shots on goal is a big day out for any forward
4. BOWER: 18 possessions and kept Franklin to 2 goals. Good performance.
3. JUDD: 34 possessions, great game by Judd. Would have featured higher but his direct opponent also played well.
2. CARRAZZO: 19 possessions and a goal. Good forward tag effort on Hodge, kept him out of Fevola's way all day.
1. KREUZER: Tried hard all day, 16 possessions, 22 hit outs and 6 tackles. Very solid effort considering he did majority of the ruckwork against two solid opponents.

WOG:

5. BENTLEY: 9 possessions in total, looked like he might be better suited to VFL
4. CLOKE: 7 possessions. His 10 hit outs saved him from the 5 votes. Terrible performance
3. O'HAILPIN: 10 possessions and a goal. Just looks completely lost on the field. Cant ruck, cant play up forward and cant play in defense. Is a great athlete but I think its time to declare the Irish experiment over and send him home
2. RUSSELL: 14 touches, didn't offer much. I thought he was about to turn his form around but he took a big step back today
1. WIGGINS: 10 possessions, only 2 of which were kicks. Didnt provide the lead up option that he normally does. Lets hope the Herald Sun dont write any more articles on him.