Votes round 15

[saj_21]

I don't think anyone has started a thread yet...

4 - Bruce
2 - Wheatly
2 - Dunn
2 - Garland
1 - Miller
1 - Valenti

 

[omit]

5 - Bruce
2 - Miller
2 - Dunn
2 - Garland
1 - Valenti

 

[dee-molishon]

4-Garland (killed murphy only person who has this year!!)
3-Whelan
2-Miller (Should have had more chances early on if newton was out of the way)
2-Bruce
1-Dunn(good effort on cooney)

can i give negitive votes to the following
-5 Sylvia (was either injured, played out of position or like me was filthy a dud like newton could take his spot in the foward line after 3 good weeks himself)
-3 Newton (Your finished, if he gets a game from here on in its purely for trade bait)
-2 Jones (tried hard but kicking went back to last year)
-2 Wheatley (lost count of how many times he fumbled the ball for no apprerant reason)

 

[Supermercado]

4 - Garland
3 - Dunn
1 - Bruce
1 - C. Johnson
1 - Martin
1 - Valenti
1 - Miller

 

[Brock 'n' Roll]

5 -Garland
4 -Dunn
3 -Bruce
2 -Miller
1- Wheatley (for that massive kick)
-5 to the melbourne fans what a joke, there would have been 2-3k tops

 

[Marns]

4 - Dunn (held a brownlow favourite to 17 touches. dunny's reinvented himself)
2 - Miller (the three late goals help him out here, but he still led well all day when the delivery was rubbish)
2 - Martin (thought he was pretty good on an opponent in minson who outsized him)
2 - Garland (kept murphy to 15 touches, no goals, and got 21 himself)
1 - Bruce (although he didn't use it well, still got plenty of it)
1 - Buckley (if for nothing else, his willingness to have a crack and break through the lines - got to love his acceleration)

5 -Garland
4 -Dunn
3 -Bruce
2 -Miller
1- Wheatley (for that massive kick)
-5 to the melbourne fans what a joke, there would have been 2-3k tops

Although I'm pretty sure it resulted in a turnover, how nice was it to see the torpy pulled out? Went to the middle of the ground! For all his faults, you've still gotta love Wheatley's massive kick.

 

[Deenamite]

4- Dunn
3- Garland
3- Bruce
1- Martin
1- Miller

 

[Flowerpower]

How can anyone give votes in what was a disgraceful games for the punters that paid their hard earned at the gate?

Lowlights outweighed highlights 50 : 1 !

Martin I thought was the pick of the bunch - really tried hard.

What is the go with handballing backwards 100m then turning it over? Ever single time................

Newton is terrible. Get rid of him now.

Jones tries hard but the game has past him by. No speed = no future.

Garland - the kid will be very good.

I left half way through the last because it was sooooooo boring - not just that we were losing - I'm used to that!!!!!!!!!!

Biggest lowlight - my 4 year old son asking for a doggies scarf because the Dees, in his exact words, "can't kick the ball"..........

 

[Marns]

Jones tries hard but the game has past him by. No speed = no future.

Now there's a new one. The game has passed him by...unbelievable.

Is it that sort of insight that plagues the minds of melbourne supporters and keeps many of them away?

I left half way through the last because it was sooooooo boring - not just that we were losing - I'm used to that!!!!!!!!!!

The 4th was our best quarter.

 

[Supermercado]

Only because the Dogs had given up

 

[Marns]

Only because the Dogs had given up

Doesn't matter. It was still more entertaining than the majority of the game.

 

[hulld]

4. garland
3. bruce
2. dunn
2. miller
1. PJ (nearly mark of the year)

 

[Flowerpower]

Now there's a new one. The game has passed him by...unbelievable.

Is it that sort of insight that plagues the minds of melbourne supporters and keeps many of them away?

YES! Never have I seen a bloke run in circles like Jones. I actually think he can play but obviously team rule is to hit the open target at all costs and not break forward and kick long to forward targets.

Jones would be a hero at the Pies (scum). Because they play yardage footy........

And why shouldn't it be ? - we get dished up crap every single week with the occasional committed effort.

The 4th was our best quarter.

When the game was over! Dogs couldn't give a sh*t!

 

[JuveRule]

3 - Garland
2 - Dunn
2 - Miller
2 - Bruce
1 - Martin
1 - Valenti
1 - Wheatley

 

[Flowerpower]

Now there's a new one. The game has passed him by...unbelievable.

Is it that sort of insight that plagues the minds of melbourne supporters and keeps many of them away?

I quote from Clint Bartram,

We're just worried about playing our best footy and hopefully the supporters come along and like what they see so far."

As Gordon Ramsay says.......""F*ck me"".......

 

[master bate]

How can anyone give votes in what was a disgraceful games for the punters that paid their hard earned at the gate?

Lowlights outweighed highlights 50 : 1 !

Martin I thought was the pick of the bunch - really tried hard.

What is the go with handballing backwards 100m then turning it over? Ever single time................

Newton is terrible. Get rid of him now.

Jones tries hard but the game has past him by. No speed = no future.

Garland - the kid will be very good.

I left half way through the last because it was sooooooo boring - not just that we were losing - I'm used to that!!!!!!!!!!

Biggest lowlight - my 4 year old son asking for a doggies scarf because the Dees, in his exact words, "can't kick the ball"..........

1. Stop complaining, yes we flooded to try and nullify their forward line (which worked as we kept them to their lowest score all year) to give us the best chance of winning, you still got to see some exciting young players and you can say you saw Martin and Garland play their first few games. What were you expecting to pay for Nadal V Federer at Wimbledon.

2. Their were plenty of lowlights but did you not enjoy PJ nearly taking a ripping mark and the young players having a crack.

3. Agreed

4.When you drop men back it is hard not to handball backwards, in recent weeks the players have started to fix their run and carry, it was a step backwards but not huge.

5. Who do you plan to replace Juice with, it's not like we have a plethora of young forwards to get development into. At the moment he is the best we have and could have kicked 3 goals easily, something Miller took years to do.

6. Jones has areas to improve in, but he is from the same draft as Buckley and Bartram, don't give up on him yet.

7. Agreed

8. The last quarter was entertaining, and whilst the dogs had slackened off it was still fun to watch, why you would leave then bemuses me.

9. I hope you didn't buy him the scarf.

 

[2 Dogs]

4- Martin
4- Dunn
4- Valenti

Chose to shy away from the usual suspects. Bruce was ok, but hardly used it, or earned the amount of bal he got today. Valenti was inspired, especially in the 2nd half. Martin showed why he is such a talent, 2 games and while he had the occasional lapse of concentration gave me hope that carroll will never play agin, and the days of bags of goals from gorilla forward may soon be at an end. Dunn is a gun. Could soon overtake Bate as the more important player from that draft.

Also stop voting for Wheatley. He is supposed to be one of the best kicks in the team, yet continually misses targets and turns the ball over. I cringe everytime he gets the ball. Either learn to use the ball, or bring in someone who can, Petterd anyone?

 

[the hawk]

How can anyone give votes in what was a disgraceful games for the punters that paid their hard earned at the gate?

Lowlights outweighed highlights 50 : 1 !

Martin I thought was the pick of the bunch - really tried hard.

What is the go with handballing backwards 100m then turning it over? Ever single time................

Newton is terrible. Get rid of him now.

Jones tries hard but the game has past him by. No speed = no future.

Garland - the kid will be very good.

I left half way through the last because it was sooooooo boring - not just that we were losing - I'm used to that!!!!!!!!!!

Biggest lowlight - my 4 year old son asking for a doggies scarf because the Dees, in his exact words, "can't kick the ball"..........

what are you on about you spud? jones is quick enough and gets the hard ball.. newton is a good young player who is getting better and will develop into a much better forward than blokes like brad miller.. flowerpower you have no idea what your talking about

 

[Pipefitter]

4 - Dunn
2 - Garland
2 - Bruce
2 - Martin
2 - Miller

 

[DemonJim]

5 - Garland
4 - Dunn
3 - Bruce

 

[demonboy13]

5 - wheatley
3 - bruce
2 - garland
1 - miller
1 - dunn

 

[dee-molishon]

5 - wheatley
3 - bruce
2 - garland
1 - miller
1 - dunn

come on get serious, did you watch the game or just look at the stat sheet. He was shit

 

[Bartram_Class]

5 - Garland
3 - Dunn
1 - Bruce
1 - Valenti
1 - Miller
1 - Martin