Votes v Carlton

[goal sneak]

4 - Green
4 - McLean
2 - Sylvia
1 - White
1 - Robbo

 

[omit]

green - 5
McLean - 3
Dunn - 2
Robbo - 1
Rivers - 1

 

[Mclean_05]

4 - Green
3 - Mclean
3 - Rivers
1 - Whelan
1 - Bruce

 

[demonfan9]

Can't be stuffed thinking of players to give votes to.

Surely Robertson doesn't deserve any though?

 

[omit]

Can't be stuffed thinking of players to give votes to.

Surely Robertson doesn't deserve any though?

he presented well and put in second efforts. if he kicked straight he could have ended up with 3 or 4

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

4- Green
3- Rivers
3- Mclean
1- Sylvia
1- Bruce

 

[2 Dogs]

10-Green: Our best.
2- Brock: Killed by Judd but no one else to give votes to

 

[devil demon]

Surely James McDonald gets some votes. He looked to me like the only one trying with his tackling and second efforts

 

[melbournemartin]

Robertson was decent today. He attacked the ball well and presented as a good full forward when Neitz was off. His kicking was average but we can't afford to be that picky in our current state

4 - Green
3 - Robertson
2 - Rivers (did a few good things in defence)
1 - Frawley (was okay)
1 - McLean (killed by Judd but got a little bit himself)
1 - McDonald (was okay)

 

[w00dy]

i thought robbo was great today... really worked hard... green was good too...

5 - Robertson
5 - Green
2 - Sylvia

 

[Headless]

4 - McLean
4 - Green
1 - Robertson
1 - Rivers
1 - Sylvia
1 - Bruce

 

[master bate]

10-Green: Our best.
2- Brock: Killed by Judd but no one else to give votes to

I don't think Brock was killed by Judd, he got a few goals on him but Brock was as effective playing in a terrible side. Judd must still be injured because I watched him closely today and he often didn't chase McLean and dropped away from the play a fair bit, usually he's working hard and maybe he was happy to let other players do the work for him today but if I was coaching him I wouldn't be happy with his effort despite his goals and possessions.

4 - Green
4 - McLean
1 - Rivers
1 - Sylvia
1 - Bruce
1 - Robbo

 

[Bartram_Class]

Robbo better, but not enough to get votes IMO.

5 - Green
4 - McLean
1 - Rivers
1 - Whelan
1 - Sylvia

 

[JuveRule]

4 - Green
3 - McLean
2 - Sylvia
1 - Rivers
1 - McDonald
1 - Frawley

 

[Pjkimber]

4 - Green: ****Attn Dean Bailey**** Please keep this guy in the forward line!
3 - McLean: Thought he played ok against Judd.
2 - Sylvia: Looking better as the weeks pass on
1 - Rivers: Great effort down back
1 - McDonald: Laid some great tackles
1 - Frawley: Is a perfect example to put a youth policy into place!

 

[Supermercado]

8 - Green
1 - McDonald
1 - McLean
1 - Rivers
1 - Bruce

 

[MicksterD]

4 - Green: ****Attn Dean Bailey**** Please keep this guy in the forward line!
3 - McLean: Thought he played ok against Judd.
2 - Sylvia: Looking better as the weeks pass on
1 - Rivers: Great effort down back
1 - McDonald: Laid some great tackles
1 - Frawley: Is a perfect example to put a youth policy into place!

Yep I agree exactly with those votes. Green was easily BOG for the Dees but without McLean I think the margin would have been 100+ He did some hard running and his disposals were a class above most of his team mates

 

[saj_21]

Green - 6
Maclean - 3
Rivers - 1
Sylvia - 1
Frawley -1

 

[Klyntonius]

5 - Green: showed real leadership but needs to back it up this week
4 - McLean: his work was tireless, especially trying to give us an option going forward
1 - Robbo: worked really hard to provide leads but is looking tired these days and can't seem to kick more than 40m
1 - Jones: still turns it over way too much but one of the few who will bust his gut all afternoon
1 - Carrol: every week he works tirelessly against his opponent who gets unpressured ball from the oppositions midfield and Sunday was very much the same.