MVP Votes v St Kilda

[Here2tellyouwhy]

5. Kennedy
4. Hurn
3. Sheed
2. Petrie
1. McGovern

 

[squashface]

5 Kennedy
4 Petrie
3 Redden
2 Hurn
1 Mitchell

 

[flamingEMBERS]

5. Kennedy
4. Sheed
3. Mitchell
2. Duggan
1. Hurn

 

[fidstar]

5 Kennedy
4 Hurn
3 Petrie
2 Redden
1 Sheed (was BOG at half time)

HM - Hutchings first 3 quarters, Mitchell,

 

[RookiePick]

5. JJK
4. Sheed
3. Redden
2. Duggan
1. Gov

HM - Petrie tries hard. Lecca had a reasonable game i thought.

DHM - schoey, shep and nelson were awful.

St Kilda just totally outworked us as much as anything. A lazy effort in general off the ball.

 

[Magnum27]

5 Kennedy
4 Petrie
3 Sheed
2 Redden
1 Hurn

 

[kranky al]

5)jk
4)hurn
3)sheed
2)redden
1)gov

 

[Adzam]

5) Kennedy
4) sheed
3) Hurn
2) Petrie
1) redden

 

[SloppyJoe]

5 JK
4 Hurn
3 Petrie
2 Sheed
1 Redden

 

[KO_KO]

5 JK
4 Hurn
3 Petrie
2 Redden
1 McKenzie

 

[bombard]

5. Kennedy
4. Petrie
3. Hurn
2. Sheed
1. Hutchings

 

[Jandamarra]

He's just signed on for 5 years at probably close to one mill per year, he's had an excellent year, doesn't matter what he achieves on the football field now.

He's had a shit year

 

[fidstar]

He's had a shit year

This.

He started well, but has fallen in a hole. While it's not the only reason, his reliance on Nic Nat is pretty evident.

 

[Goldenblue]

5. Kennedy
4. Sheed
3. Redden
2. Petrie
1. Yeo

 

[eaglesfan84]

He's had a shit year

This.

He started well, but has fallen in a hole. While it's not the only reason, his reliance on Nic Nat is pretty evident.

I think you missed my attempt at sarcastic wit?

He scored the deal of a lifetime, so now his football can be absolute rubbish yet he'll still consider this year a great succees and he'll think he's had a great year.....

 

[fidstar]

I think you missed my attempt at sarcastic wit?

He scored the deal of a lifetime, so now his football can be absolute rubbish yet he'll still consider this year a great succees and he'll think he's had a great year.....

My comment wasn't really aimed at you. I was just agreeing with another poster. While he's been far from our worst player, I'm surprised he hasn't got more criticism from the general public/board (though, to be fair I don't read every thread).

 

[QS]

5. Drew Petrie - We lack desire. For another week, this bloke led our tackle count comfortably. If that doesn't humiliate the younger players into pulling their socks up and actually putting in a shift, nothing will.
4. Josh Kennedy - Too good for his teammates.
3. Jack Redden - So much better lately with more responsibility.
2. Jeremy McGovern - Very good for much of the game.
1. Dom Sheed - Second half putrid. Lucky he played so well first half. Did a tagger go to him? Actually disappeared.

Lazy post but these are my votes too for pretty much the same reasons.

 

[JADED]

5. Kennedy
4. Redden
3. Lecras
2. Hurn
1. Petrie

(Sheed if not for the disappearing act)

Could give Gaff votes purely for 3of15 kicks on his right foot. Surely the coaches had a word to him about getting in to so much trouble doubling back to his Left. He's a well known player now so the entire league are reading him like a book.

 

[CM9000]

5. Josh Kennedy
4. Shannon Hurn
3. Drew Petrie
2. Jack Redden
1. Dom Sheed