Analysis What are they worth?

[pluggeranddoc]

If as touted a few want out and, assuming we have guessed correctly as to who they are what Draft picks would you accept for each of the following:
-Steven (top10)
-Billings(as above)
-Acres (10-20)
-Dunstan(20-25)

My guess in brackets
I would do the first two in an instant less keen on the other two.

Thoughts?

 

[Mat Mann]

double your numbers
-Steven (top20)
-Billings(as above)
-Acres (20-40)
-Dunstan(40-45)

 

[Remboy]

I agree with the OP. As much as I don't want to lose any of these guys if another club wants them they can pay up.
Hopefully with the new appointments that have happened they will decide to hang around.

 

[Saint_Dos]

-Steven (mid first rounder: Pick 5-15)
-Billings (mid-late first rounder: Pick 10-20)
-Acres (late first early second rounder: Pick 20-30)
-Dunstan & Newnes (mid second rounder: Pick 25-35)
- Weller & Longer (third rounder)

Is all based on what the clubs are and there needs.

 

[saintsrfreak]

double your numbers
-Steven (top20)
-Billings(as above)
-Acres (20-40)
-Dunstan(40-45)

Jack Steven is worth at least as much as Bryce Gibbs was, top 20 is having a laugh. JB as well I think would pretty easily fetch a top 10 pick.

 

[St Kilda Death]

Criminally undervaluing Billings.
To me you get the draft value by working out where they would go if they were available in the draft.

If he entered this years draft, at 24yo...
Carlton would probably take him.
I highly doubt he would make it past 7.
Therefore his value is 1-6.
Add in he is contracted so the scales need to be tipped in our favour..
2 first rounders.

Stuv. Of similar value, but getting old, so probably the 1 first rounder will do.
Oh wait is he contracted too?
Make that 2 first rounders.

I dont think they are going anywhere btw.
But fun to have af yarn.

 

[Sir Skid]

Ah the meat market in full flight.
Gotta love this time of year........ when we've had the season from hell anyway

 

[plugger66]

If as touted a few want out and, assuming we have guessed correctly as to who they are what Draft picks would you accept for each of the following:
-Steven (top10)
-Billings(as above)
-Acres (10-20)
-Dunstan(20-25)

My guess in brackets
I would do the first two in an instant less keen on the other two.

Thoughts?

Steven top 10. Billings 10 to 20 Acres 20 to 30. Dunstan 40 to 50.

 

[pluggeranddoc]

Steven top 10. Billings 10 to 20 Acres 20 to 30. Dunstan 40 to 50.

So apart from Steven not one of them is worth anywhere near the draft pick we used to draft them!

 

[Savage Kent]

Stuv: 5-10 or mid teens + starting best 22 player (i.e. if trade with crows pick 14 + Gallucci or McGovern)
Billings: 10-20
Acres: 15-25
Paddy: Mid-late 2nd round at best
Bruce (same as Paddy)
Dunstan: 25-40

 

[cartel]

Stuv: 5-10 or mid teens + starting best 22 player (i.e. if trade with crows pick 14 + Gallucci or McGovern)
Billings: 10-20
Acres: 15-25
Paddy: Mid-late 2nd round at best
Bruce (same as Paddy)
Dunstan: 25-40

Agree but I'd want more for Bruce as he at least has some proven output, albeit is coming off injury. Worth more to us than on the market currently.

 

[Jade Buddha]

Largely depends on how bad a club wants that player.

E.g. St.Kilda are approached by Brisbane for Steven, in that case St.Kilda can raise the bar.

 

[plugger66]

So apart from Steven not one of them is worth anywhere near the draft pick we used to draft them!

Acres is close. The rest aren’t.

 

[Pardon me]

Any that are contracted 2 first rounders or gtfo

 

[plugger66]

Any that are contracted 2 first rounders or gtfo

So dunstan is worth 2 first rounders if contracted. No. Actually none are unless it’s 17 and 18 and that’s probably only Steven

 

[saint66au]

So apart from Steven not one of them is worth anywhere near the draft pick we used to draft them!

If they were...we'd be playing far better footy and wouldnt be looking at trading