what if?

[Fastcrew]

Back in 07 when we did the Judd deal, instead of trading Kennedy to the eagles we traded fev, would we be in a better position now?. I know it's not good to dwell on the past but i can only wish that we did the above deal.

Your thoughts on what would be better Kennedy or henderson and pick 12?

 

[Kreuzerlenko]

Kennedy would be great, especially now. But I'm willing to give Hendo a chance and I'm definitely still happy with the Judd trade at the moment, what the future will bring i don't know but for now I still think we're the winners.

 

[Chism]

Henderson and Pick 12 is still untapped potential. Pick 12 could be anything and we have not even selected it yet!!

Kennedy is good there is no doubt but we have Juddy and you have to give away quality to get quality in return hence the Kennedy situation. (This is the reason Collingwood never trade well as they over estimate ALL their hacks)

Very happy the way the Blues have gone about these recent trades and all looks good for the future.

 

[transmed_999]

Back in 07 when we did the Judd deal, instead of trading Kennedy to the eagles we traded fev, would we be in a better position now?. I know it's not good to dwell on the past but i can only wish that we did the above deal.

Your thoughts on what would be better Kennedy or henderson and pick 12?

If fev was offered up in the judd deal i think fev plus pick 20 may of been enough to get the deal done. We may of been able to then still keep pick 3. Although Kennedy was alot younger he was still unproven where as Fev was a proven goal kicker and still age 26/27.

So in that scenario we would of still kept kennedy and pick 3.

In this instance i reckon kennedy and pick 3 is a better outcome then henderson and pick 12.

Otherwise i think henderson and pick 12 is better then kennedy alone.

 

[rofltown]

I think Kennedy is a good player but he seems to be over rated by a lot of Carlton supporters..... carlton supporters seem to rate him more highly than eagles supporters for some reason. When he kicks 50 goals in a season then i'll start to pay attention..