List Mgmt. Father/Son Eligible Kids List

[FR0GGY]

Wow. So many baseless assumptions in those two paragraphs.

The sad thing is some will read this and take this opinion as gospel. Not that that is necessarily your fault James but this kind of thing is how rumours start.

Set us straight then please.

 

[Go the Guts]

We got a player here. I think Edwards' boys will come around (looks like a couple of them look likely atm as well) and Connor McLeod will do the same.

What makes you think he isn't already?

 

[androidtommy]

Anyone know what the deal with Oscar McGuiness (2016) is?
Does he play? Is he a draft chance?

 

[Elite Crow]

Anyone know what the deal with Oscar McGuiness (2016) is?
Does he play? Is he a draft chance?

On the run

 

[Sanders]

Not sure why people are getting worked up about this

F/S is dead as far as we want it to be or used to be known. The bidding system means there is only ever a small discount on offer

The days of Hawkins or Scarlett for next to nothing are gone

 

[1970crow]

Not sure why people are getting worked up about this

F/S is dead as far as we want it to be or used to be known. The bidding system means there is only ever a small discount on offer

The days of Hawkins or Scarlett for next to nothing are gone

Not if your 1st selection isn't until rnd 3 each year.

 

[FR0GGY]

Can you in a year that you know your going to take a value FS trade a first round pick for a good player?

 

[PKnox]

Can you in a year that you know your going to take a value FS trade a first round pick for a good player?

I think father son bidding occurs before trade week starts.

 

[Vader]

Can you in a year that you know your going to take a value FS trade a first round pick for a good player?

No. Bidding for F/S players takes place before trading commences. Bids are then locked in and the picks used are quarantined to prevent clubs from abusing the system in exactly the manner you've described.

 

[lunacy]

Not sure why people are getting worked up about this

F/S is dead as far as we want it to be or used to be known. The bidding system means there is only ever a small discount on offer

The days of Hawkins or Scarlett for next to nothing are gone

Who wouldn't want a son of a gun playing for your side?

I agree there isn't much benefit to the lower ranked F/S, but the top ones are still a huge benefit.

Jack Viney went @ pick 26?

Tom Mitchell @ pick 21 was rated much higher.

Luke Macdonald @ pick 8. He is probably the one who didn't provide much benefit as he probably went at his true value.

 

[xchadders]

Not sure why people are getting worked up about this

F/S is dead as far as we want it to be or used to be known. The bidding system means there is only ever a small discount on offer

The days of Hawkins or Scarlett for next to nothing are gone

but if there are 3 f/s kids we can pick, and even if they all get bidded on highly, we can still take them all with r1, r2, r3 picks. so its possible to get them for next to nothing, it just happens that its unlikely to get that many f/s kids in one year, although our 97/98 boys seem to be doing ok.

 

[Sanders]

but if there are 3 f/s kids we can pick, and even if they all get bidded on highly, we can still take them all with r1, r2, r3 picks. so its possible to get them for next to nothing, it just happens that its unlikely to get that many f/s kids in one year, although our 97/98 boys seem to be doing ok.

For a club that has none, I'm not pinning my hopes on having 3 top flight ones in a single year

 

[DREAM TEAM BUFF]

Another lazy 5 goals and BOG for young Jarman last night.

Would be a top 10 pick if he was in this years draft according to some

 

[cmndstab]

F/S can be a big benefit if you finish very high or very low on the ladder, or if you just happen to have the best junior in the country eligible. I'm sure us Crows fans all recognise the difference between a late first-round selection and a top 5 selection.

 

[ams4crows]

Ben Jarman is also available for a hawthorn father son selection. ... does Ben get to decide which club gets him?

 

[PKnox]

Ben Jarman is also available for a hawthorn father son selection. ... does Ben get to decide which club gets him?

This has been discussed in this thread and yes, it is down to his personal choice. But he is a mad Crows supporter and obviously lives in Adelaide so we'd have to be the front runner.

 

[lunacy]

Would be a top 10 pick if he was in this years draft according to some

As a 16 year old?

 

[xchadders]

For a club that has none, I'm not pinning my hopes on having 3 top flight ones in a single year

me either! just wanted to point it out that it is possible. the best chance seems to be with the 97/98 crop coming up, lets hope several of them are afl quality!

 

[threefa9]

So in the 2016 draft , we have pick 14, 30, etc and we trade 14 out (hypothetically), can we then nominate pick 30 for Ben Jarman?

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

So in the 2016 draft , we have pick 14, 30, etc and we trade 14 out (hypothetically), can we then nominate pick 30 for Ben Jarman?

No

 

[threefa9]

No

So we have to use first pick?

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

So we have to use first pick?

If another club before us commits their first round pick we do

 

[radiojake]

So we have to use first pick?

F/S Bidding happens before trade week - So the selections are locked in before any trades can happen. So we can't 'hypothetically' trade pick 14 away to secure Jarman at 30 - EIther a club bids a first round pick on Jarman and we used pick 14, or noone bids on him then we can use later picks on him

 

[cammo6556]

May be a little optimistic, but is there any vision of Ben Jarman playing?

 

[threefa9]

F/S Bidding happens before trade week - So the selections are locked in before any trades can happen. So we can't 'hypothetically' trade pick 14 away to secure Jarman at 30 - EIther a club bids a first round pick on Jarman and we used pick 14, or noone bids on him then we can use later picks on him

Haha yeah that makes sense