Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Richmond have never changed a raft of rules to stop Geelong.
Geelong,the precious pussies have done that to Richmond though.
#boysclub
Then in the midst of Richmond's dynasty Colin Carter tried to fudge the Premiership Cup figures.
Eat a bag of furballs Cats!
1967 and 2020!
You'll NEVER BEAT The TIGERS!
Yeah well I just did. Sorry, but this isn’t the Supreme Court.
Same reason I’ve told you the other 400000 times and you still can’t wrap your head around it. A player can win a medal for being mediocre in year X relative to a player in year Y who was twice as good but didn’t win the medal because someone else happened to be 0.1 per cent better. Player Y has had easily a better season but has no medal to show for it. So when the teo
Players go hypothetically head to head, the medal doesn’t do their kicking and hand passing for them does it. Their kicking and hand passing does their kicking and hand passing. The medals mean jack s**t.
Medals also depend on the system in which they are awarded and are often given in imperfect systems whereby a player can have 6 goals and 30 touches in a game and get 2 votes in a losing game because an opponent in the winning team had 35 and 3, meanwhile someone else in a winning team in another game has 22 and 2 and gets 3 votes.
It’s a s**t system.
That logic can apply to any award. Guess they are all meaningless to you then.
Perfect logic when things don’t go your way, quite ingenious coping mechanism. You’ve always got a way to rat out of the argument by saying it’s all just BS.
That logic can apply to any award. Guess they are all meaningless to you then.
Perfect logic when things don’t go your way, quite ingenious coping mechanism. You’ve always got a way to rat out of the argument by saying it’s all just BS.
Can you honestly not see the logic in PB’s argument? It is sound.
Have another try at comprehending it. Give it your best try. There’s still hope for you if you can open your mind a little.
Do you know - and promise me no Googling Cleansweep17 - who Christopher Marlowe was?
Well I’ll save you a quick Google anyway.
He was the second best playwright of Shakespeare’s lifetime and if you’re into plays and theatre is pretty famous in his own right.
Now imagine there was a Brownlow for writing plays.
I think we know who would have won it most of the time.
Poor old Christopher Marlow would have had to sit there year after year listening to Bill giving pissed acceptance speeches ‘Ye all bless me, I beseech you to continue to grace me into the wee hours with thine presence as we partake in this delightful bitches brew….. and tear The Globe Theatre a new a-hole.’
Meanwhile whoever the hell arrived straight after Shakespeare and Marlowe died was probably shithouse. But he would have won more ‘Brownlows’ than poor old Christopher.
And how does this relate specifically to the Lions and Geelong mids? You saying you have a bunch of player that were better than Voss, Aker and Black but didn’t win Brownlows?
I can and you should agree with me especially since GAJ is considered by most as one of the best of all time because of those exact awards he is saying doesn’t matter.
PB doesn’t like it here because it shows that Lions mids are better than the Geelong ones.
Who wouldn’t pick a midfield with more Brownlow medalists in it like seriously?
Gaz is not considered great because he won awards.
He won awards because he was a great player.
Strange you can’t grasp this.
Oh so now MVP awards are important?
That’s an interesting turn of events
No I didn’t overlook anything. I just responded to the idea that the Brownlow medal somehow a) does all the kicking and b) needs to be won during the relevant period. You’re tying yourself in more knots than a bondage mistress’ favourite rope trying to prove that awards somehow make a player better than their actual quality.
PhatBoy I would be taking that as a complimentWeird unit.
PhatBoy I would be taking that as a compliment
but then you’ve also had players like Jenkins, Menzel and dalhaus. Plus some players probably both of us have forgotten about.
The role players crumble when the stars aren’t on the field. Stengel in 2022 is a massive example.
I have, makes me feel normal
It's getting to the point where none of us can tell the difference between parody and serious posting.Steve Hocking brought in rule after rule after Richmond won all those flags.
The Stand rule reminds us Tigers how salty Shocking and the CFL were after the 2020 Richmond premiership.
I can't see Richmond ever doing something like that.
They are a deluded, pathetic embarrassment.It's getting to the point where none of us can tell the difference between parody and serious posting.
It's that bad.
Long live the CFL!Steve Hocking brought in rule after rule after Richmond won all those flags.
The Stand rule reminds us Tigers how salty Shocking and the CFL were after the 2020 Richmond premiership.
I can't see Richmond ever doing something like that.
It's a great case study.They are a deluded, pathetic embarrassment.
You aren’t. You’ve said yourself.