St Kilda should trade #1 for Blues deal... What you think?

[Alfredo Rojas]

I think Saints should heavily consider this trade, win-win for both sides

- Carlton offer Kane Lucas (few years experience can slot into senior side, top pick himself)
- Blues also put up pick #6 & 3rd round pick in exchange for;

Saints pick #1... I reckon both sides would benefit as Saints still gain top 10 pick and early 3rd round pick plus a ready to go player

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

So St Kilda are trading down pick 1 to pick 6 for pretty much no benefit (Lucas is a spud)? In your dreams perhaps.

 

[Upgrayedd]

I think Saints should heavily consider this trade, win-win for both sides

- Carlton offer Kane Lucas (few years experience can slot into senior side, top pick himself)
- Blues also put up pick #6 & 3rd round pick in exchange for;

Saints pick #1... I reckon both sides would benefit as Saints still gain top 10 pick and early 3rd round pick plus a ready to go player

You know Kane Lucas has only played 5 games this year? He's not a ready to go player, He's a midfielder who's supposed to be hitting his prime but cannot crack a bottom 8 team


It's one of the most lop sided trades in history, It would make freo's pick 1 for Croad/Mcpharlin look like a masterstroke on their behalf

 

[Tragic sainter]

Where do we sign?! Lucas is exactly is a star that could carry us to a premiership! We would probably have to throw in our second rounder too so the trade looked a little more even.

 

[footyfan000001]

Thought this thread was going to be legit...

 

[Two Planks]

Pick 6 and Lachie Henderson would be fair.

 

[SizeMatters]

I reckon the Lions might consider it though. Pick 5 for Pick 6 + Lucas looks fair enough. We need some depth in our Ressies team.

 

[Simon Wiggins]

I reckon the Lions might consider it though. Pick 5 for Pick 6 + Lucas looks fair enough. We need some depth in our Ressies team.

I'd be all over that

 

[De Iulio2Wiggins]

I think Saints should heavily consider this trade, win-win for both sides

- Carlton offer Kane Lucas (few years experience can slot into senior side, top pick himself)
- Blues also put up pick #6 & 3rd round pick in exchange for;

Saints pick #1... I reckon both sides would benefit as Saints still gain top 10 pick and early 3rd round pick plus a ready to go player

I'm a Blues supporter and this still looks like the worst trade in the history of trades.

Save the #6 pick, why not just give them Lucas, McLean and a free one month gold subscription to Josh Bootsma's SnapChat?

 

[DT_35]

Lol you cannot be serious...

 

[Suma Magic]

This guy is a notorious troll. Look at any post on any thread.

 

[Pie in the Sky]

Thought this thread was going to be legit...

You obviously haven't seen the op post before then.

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

This guy is a notorious troll. Look at any post on any thread.

How is this trolling? Why is not lagit fair trade?

 

[Heisenberg_]

How is this trolling? Why is not lagit fair trade?

How is it a fair trade?
St Kilda pretty much gives up pick 1 for pick 6.
Kane Lucas holds zero value at the trade table and if Carlton actually came to St Kilda with that offer, they would rightfully be laughed at and they wouldn't do any business with you for a long time.

 

[apuchar]

You know Kane Lucas has only played 5 games this year? He's not a ready to go player, He's a midfielder who's supposed to be hitting his prime but cannot crack a bottom 8 team


It's one of the most lop sided trades in history, It would make freo's pick 1 for Croad/Mcpharlin look like a masterstroke on their behalf

McPharlin was worth every cent and we on-traded Croad back to Hawthorn for pick 10. We did alright.

 

[coryne]

How is this trolling? Why is not lagit fair trade?

Because we would be lucky to be able to use Lucas to upgrade our 2nd rd selection let alone our 1st. He is probably worth an early 3rd rd selection at most ................

 

[Jab]

Don't make me post another gif