Review 2014 Post Season Member Briefing (fan forum)

[MyManLynch]

They are some that are asking just Stupid Questions.

There are a Few There but some I do wonder listening to what they have said

Every member has a right to be there. Every member can ask any question they like...it's their right.
Injury questions have been asked. Recruiting questions have been asked. Fitness, training loads, etc.
I would like to ask about the non performance of some of our senior players this year.

 

[Bard]

Bucks saying it was Ball's decision to retire, but that he had spelt out to him he'd probably play mostly VFL next year.

Luke Ball said as much in his interview. Basically said he sat down with Buckley and was told that it's hard for players to accept when to retire etc etc. Pretty obvious he was told it was time to move on.

 

[Yidaki]

Ben Kennedy update - Just put on sweater. Was getting a bit cold in the room. Oh, it was a green sweater if you all wanted to know.

 

[motr]

Luke Ball said as much in his interview. Basically said he sat down with Buckley and was told that it's hard for players to accept when to retire etc etc. Pretty obvious he was told it was time to move on.

Perhaps a bit of an insight into Buckley's conversation with Dawes.

 

[Babylove]

Apparently there's a bloke in a beanie who's upset that the club won't ditch the players who did their knees

 

[Bring_Back_Brad]

Someone just asked if brad dick was being rookied in 2015.

 

[mattys123]

Love this;

@wesy_b: Hine: would select Sharenberg 100 times over again #piesreview

And some whinged after he did his knee that "we'd made a mistake".

 

[TradeDraft]

Found that Intresting that Bucks has said the Media is Full of S**T and have no Idea.

I smell something from Goldy’s Manager more then the Reporters

 

[TradeDraft]

Love this;



And some whinged after he did his knee that "we'd made a mistake".

Shows that Hine thinks that Scharanberg when Fit will be something very special

 

[Babylove]

Love this;



And some whinged after he did his knee that "we'd made a mistake".

That may have been the Beanie Bloke (that's what Paige is calling him)

 

[Bard]

Love this;



And some whinged after he did his knee that "we'd made a mistake".

To be fair, do you honestly think he'd answer any differently? Imagine the debacle if he said, "No we f@$ked up and should have taken Aish. Scharenberg has no chance of ever playing the footy we once hoped".

 

[TradeDraft]

To be fair, do you honestly think he'd answer any differently? Imagine the debacle if he said, "No we f@$ked up and should have taken Aish. Scharenberg has no chance of ever playing the footy we once hoped".

Not Really but he did not have to sound so excited

 

[Scottabe_pendles]

Shows that Hine thinks that Scharanberg when Fit will be something very special

Or doesnt want to destroy a young players confidence who is about to go through a gruelling rehab...

He's not about to say "If I'd known Scharenberg was going to do his knee we would have taken Aish"

Edit: beaten to it

 

[TradeDraft]

Or doesnt want to destroy a young players confidence who is about to go through a gruelling rehab...

He's not about to say "If I'd known Scharenberg was going to do his knee we would have taken Aish"

Edit: beaten to it

So what they are all saying at this Review is just Crap then?

 

[ThisIsJake]

 

[Scottabe_pendles]

So what they are all saying at this Review is just Crap then?

Not crap at all... but there was only one possible answer to the question which is what Hine gave

 

[Bard]

I was under the impression Paige was a Journo or something LOL.

 

[JOELY]

I was under the impression Paige was a Journo or something LOL.

so is she

 

[TradeDraft]

I was under the impression Paige was a Journo or something LOL.

She works for TACCUP Radio

 

[TheFreshBanana]

Apparently there's a bloke in a beanie who's upset that the club won't ditch the players who did their knees

Left straight after his question too

 

[Babylove]

Left straight after his question too

According to Paige he's back.

 

[dirts]

Surely Frost and White should be June and July. Broomhead and Seedsman, September and October.

I see what you did there... Someone needs to give props

 

[Pendles!]

My money is on THATSGOLD.

Just kidding mate!!

 

[DAWESOME!!]

Would love it if Beanie Man turned out to be a regular here.

 

[TradeDraft]

My money is on THATSGOLD

or Hiss from Nicks