Nick Riewoldt vs Luke Hodge

[Mitchell54]

I voted Riewoldt

 

[dinger]

Hodge is absolutely brilliant and a fantastic leader, however Reiwoldt has been consistently brilliant in a team that has been wildly inconsistent in terms of performance - and being in AA 5 times reinforces this. Reiwoldt for me by a bees dick.

 

[detox]

Riewoldt only because a dominant chf Is the most valuable player in any team. Not much in it though.

 

[MinerBoy]

Hodge is absolutely brilliant and a fantastic leader, however Reiwoldt has been consistently brilliant in a team that has been wildly inconsistent in terms of performance - and being in AA 5 times reinforces this. Reiwoldt for me by a bees dick.

I haven't done the numbers but I'd guess that the Saints have been up in contention for as long as the Hawks over the length of their careers with similar years down at the other end.

 

[Gone Critical]

Hodge is a beauty but Roo is at another level up so ges my vote

 

[thetank]

Riewoldt easily.

Hodge is this decade's Michael Voss, sustained playing ability getting overrated because of premiership success.