Mega Thread Possible trades in 2015 for the Crows

[Houston]

Aylett.

correct

 

[Draft Bored]

correct

Edwards chose poorly. He's stuck at that basketcase club for eternity because GWS wanted to bundle him with Aylett.

 

[Houston]

Edwards chose poorly. He's stuck at that basketcase club for eternity because GWS wanted to bundle him with Aylett.

Yeah failing to nominate us really cost him.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

I would all over Hampton, could potentially pry him out cheap.

 

[macca23]

Honestly haven't seen enough of Redden to make comment .......i'd suggest most here also are not in a position to make accurate comment

You don't have Foxtel with IQ WW? I end up watching all 9 games most weeks and I've seen plenty of Redden. He's a classy clever mid-fielder who would add nicely to any new mid-field that he becomes a part of.

I haven't looked at stats at all but my feeling is that he's slightly down on his output this year which is consistent with that of a player playing at a club that he doesn't want to be at.

I'd love to have him at the Crows - particularly if Danger leaves. However if Danger stays he would become less of a priority as a trade but I still wouldn't knock him back. He's a good player.

 

[Footypie32]

Gone backwards this year.

Who wouldn't in that team? Can't judge young key defenders in struggling teams too harshly. If he wanted to come home I'd be interested.

 

[Footypie32]

All this talk of poaching Brisbane and Carlton kids conjures up this image in my mind...

 

[huludicidal]

Honestly haven't seen enough of Redden to make comment .......i'd suggest most here also are not in a position to make accurate comment

Yeah I mean in the 7 or so years he's been in the league it's been really difficult to locate any footage of him. Jack 'Bigfoot' Redden they call him. Is he even real?

 

[Jars458]

You don't have Foxtel with IQ WW? I end up watching all 9 games most weeks and I've seen plenty of Redden. He's a classy clever mid-fielder who would add nicely to any new mid-field that he becomes a part of.

I haven't looked at stats at all but my feeling is that he's slightly down on his output this year which is consistent with that of a player playing at a club that he doesn't want to be at.

I'd love to have him at the Crows - particularly if Danger leaves. However if Danger stays he would become less of a priority as a trade but I still wouldn't knock him back. He's a good player.

Thank you for saving me the trouble to type that. What Macca said.

 

[Sanders]

The thought of Menzel is really exciting, but I'd imagine we would need to give up M Crouch.

Would people do that trade?

I think I would.

Think? I'd do that trade in a heart beat

 

[Sanders]

Honestly haven't seen enough of Redden to make comment .......i'd suggest most here also are not in a position to make accurate comment

Why? Because you haven't watched him therefore no one else could have?

Seriously mate, WTF is your doctor prescribing lately.

 

[FR0GGY]

Why? Because you haven't watched him therefore no one else could have?

Seriously mate, WTF is your doctor prescribing lately.

I think they've accidentally given him the ones for his heartigan.

 

[Danoz]

Aish and Redden rumoured out of BL, Bell and Menzel rumoured out of Carlton, Kerridge and ? out of Crows. Aish and Kerridge to Carlton, Redden and Menzel to Crows, Bell and ? to BL?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I think they've accidentally given him the ones for his heartigan.

Shawly not!

 

[Tantidar]

Aish and Redden rumoured out of BL, Bell and Menzel rumoured out of Carlton, Kerridge and ? out of Crows. Aish and Kerridge to Carlton, Redden and Menzel to Crows, Bell and ? to BL?

Our 1st rounder to Brisbane, and I'd say that's a fair trade all round

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Our 1st rounder to Brisbane, and I'd say that's a fair trade all round

Carlton wouldn't be happy with that ....equating aish and menzel maybe at a stretch (menzel is better) but bell is much more advanced than kerridge

 

[Mike Smyth]

With Scgarenberg, Aish, redden and Dixon all on the market surely we can land a bigger fish this year than the disappoiting lowden/cheney trades.

I

 

[adelaidecrows]

Imagine if we managed to snare Aish, Scharenburg and Redden in one hit. (wont happen but I can dream) If we kept Danger as well, look out!. However I think we would quickly kill our salary cap to be honest so we couldnt afford to do it. Danger plus one would be ideal or any two out of the three.

 

[adelaidecrows]

With Scgarenberg, Aish, redden and Dixon all on the market surely we can land a bigger fish this year than the disappoiting lowden/cheney trades.

I

Cheney isnt a disappointment. I dont think that can be said when we are flying, it would be different if he is out of the side and we are losing every week. He was just unlucky to be injured and the guys who came in proved too good to drop. Kelly can consider himself just as unlucky. Lowden is a development ruckmen but they probably didnt see O'Brien making a huge impact before last season.

 

[BunjiMac]

Hope Justin Reid takes the lead during trade period

 

[Brentmeister]

Imagine if we managed to snare Aish, Scharenburg and Redden in one hit. (wont happen but I can dream) If we kept Danger as well, look out!. However I think we would quickly kill our salary cap to be honest so we couldnt afford to do it. Danger plus one would be ideal or any two out of the three.

Even if Danger goes I think we have more of an immediate need for a tall defender. We have little back up if Talia goes down. Our midfield numbers are exceptional.

 

[BunjiMac]

I'd die if used a high pick for a kpd... Again

 

[Skippy231]

I would not want to spend $350k on Scharenberg based on his current form

We are paying $400k for Mackay. $350k would be a bargain, this kid can seriously play.

 

[BunjiMac]

From all reports looking to stay at collingwood so wouldn't get your hopes up

 

[rezagun]

Hope Justin Reid takes the lead during trade period

over noble?