Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[WaynesWorld19]

Let the comparisons start .....

 

[Choppers]

Newcombe v Rowbottom

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Newcombe v Rowbottom

OR

Newcombe v Rowbottom v Warner ?

 

[AzzaLow]

OR

Newcombe v Rowbottom v Warner ?

Warner , Newcombe , Rowbottom If we are talking face value ( Horse is hard to trust with his rotations at the best of times ) but all ones to look for come constant pre-season news/practice games.

 

[TDS7]

OR

Newcombe v Rowbottom v Warner ?

I don't trust Warner or Newk to stand up to the attention they're bound to get now as the go-to damage midfielders for their teams. Both are still young as well, they might have good games but against the teams that run a tagger their scores will get hit pretty hard. I'd rather Hopper or Sheed for greater value since I don't know if any of the 5 will be keepers but at least they'll get a bit more cash to leap up to upgrade targets.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

OR

Newcombe v Rowbottom v Warner ?

Probably better to find a bit of cash and go for one of BSmith/Anderson/Green/LDU.

 

[sutts]

OR

Newcombe v Rowbottom v Warner ?

Of those three, Warner for me.

I have Warner in my keeper league squad. I expected a rise last season, but not to the extent we saw. I'm not as worried as others about the potential tag he cop. Uses the ball well and runs all day. Will be fine.

Rowbottom is a fine player but I don't see him being in the top 10 players in his position at season end, and isn't likely to generate much cash.

I haven't watched Newcombe as closely but I do like what I see. Looks to have the potential to score like Neale, loves the contest and seems to find the ball with ease. Should be the man next season, hopefully like of Ward and Worpel step up to spread the load so the focus isn't solely on him.

 

[Makeshift Park]

OR

Newcombe v Rowbottom v Warner ?

Or... Cunners.

 

[Th3 DoG FaTh3R]

Who will surge and become an uber premo defender?
Nick Blakey 475k vs Ed Richards 460k

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Who will surge and become an uber premo defender?
Nick Blakey 475k vs Ed Richards 460k

Neither Young is the one

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Neither Young is the one

What about Little Nicky? him vs Young?

Who will surge and become an uber premo defender?
Nick Blakey 475k vs Ed Richards 460k

You tell us regarding Richards. Is he going to be that main hbf, or Dale or does Helmet get yet another chance?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

What about Little Nicky? him vs Young?


You tell us regarding Richards. Is he going to be that main hbf, or Dale or does Helmet get yet another chance?

Both Daicos & Young will average over 100 next season

In regards to Richards the Bulldogs have Liam Jones back in the team and also Bruce who Bevo has said will train with the Defenders. How will this effect Richards and his role nobody knows. A big risk at $460k in my opinion

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Both Daicos & Young will average over 100 next season

In regards to Richards the Bulldogs have Liam Jones back in the team and also Bruce who Bevo has said will train with the Defenders. How will this effect Richards and his role nobody knows. A big risk at $460k in my opinion

Yeah I have both penciled in ATS. Little Nicky is going to get a lot more attention this year. He's a gun, so I'll back him to get through it.

 

[Th3 DoG FaTh3R]

Agree both Naicos and Young look set for life in the 100 PPG territory.
Richards and Blakey both have the capacity but less certain of it happening.
I'm bias which is why I'm canvassing the neural network of bigfooty intelligence.

 

[Northernsoul74]

What about Little Nicky? him vs Young?


You tell us regarding Richards. Is he going to be that main hbf, or Dale or does Helmet get yet another chance?

Helmet being thrown all over the place in training.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Helmet being thrown all over the place in training.

Bevo should throw him in the bin

 

[Me Myself and I]

Bevo should throw himself in the bin

EFA

Helmet being thrown all over the place in training.

Metaphorically, physically or both??

 

[kananooks]

parish vs brayshaw vs walsh?

 

[VeinGlorious]

parish vs brayshaw vs walsh?

Walsh is nursing a back issue and isn’t in full training at the moment bud.



Parish.

 

[kananooks]

marshall or taranto? (cameron swinging between r/f)

 

[Jiska]

marshall or taranto? (cameron swinging between r/f)

Marshall, but weren't you questioning his selection in the other thread? Get on board.

Rozee or Butters?

 

[King_Steele]

Marshall, but weren't you questioning his selection in the other thread? Get on board.

Rozee or Butters?

Rozee

 

[buttox]

Marshall, but weren't you questioning his selection in the other thread? Get on board.

Rozee or Butters?

Butters for me. He finished last year strongly after everyone had traded him out.

 

[Jiska]

Butters for me. He finished last year strongly after everyone had traded him out.

Leaning that way. I started 2021 with him. Even when he got injured at half time he gave my team a 108. Haven't touched him since but he showed enough.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Helmet being thrown all over the place in training.

Footage..