List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

[WaynesWorld19]

Surely Hayward is a need if we see Rachele and Rankine as full time midfielders.

What was said was that Fog basically plays the same role as Hayward .....our need is more another KPF, IMO

I still think Curtin could be that mobile CHF .....that role, Buddy Franklin played .....Thilthorpe FF, and Fog the 3rd tall

Put a fleet of quick smalls at their feet .....if you didn't see Darcy Jones play on the weekend, WOW .....you'll see what a super quick player can do in breaking apart team defences

 

[Danger in Texas]

What was said was that Fog basically plays the same role as Hayward .....our need is more another KPF, IMO

Wait what? Hayward is a mobile, pressuring medium marking forward, not exactly a like-for-like with Fog

That’s without even bringing up the fact we have Welsh coming next year

 

[Carn The Texan]

This will not be the offer, from any club.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Wait what? Hayward is a mobile, pressuring medium marking forward

That he isn't .....show me the facts that support this pressuring fwd ....you won't be able to

 

[Danger in Texas]

That he isn't .....show me the facts that support this pressuring fwd ....you won't be able to

Above average for his position both this year and last for tackles, and tackles inside 50

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

What was said was that Fog basically plays the same role as Hayward .....our need is more another KPF, IMO

I still think Curtin could be that mobile CHF .....that role, Buddy Franklin played .....Thilthorpe FF, and Fog the 3rd tall

Put a fleet of quick smalls at their feet .....if you didn't see Darcy Jones play on the weekend, WOW .....you'll see what a super quick player can do in breaking apart team defences

Nah, Hayward plays very different style to Fogarty.

Who claims they play a similar role?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Above average for his position both this year and last for tackles, and tackles inside 50

2.5 tackles is above ave ? .....nah sorry

You didn't even research it

 

[Danger in Texas]

2.5 tackles is above ave ? .....nah sorry

You didn't even research it

Sorry, the tackle average this year is average. Everything else is above average

Importantly, he’s tackling better I50 than literally anyone on our list

 

[Eddie Murphy]

2.5 tackles is above ave ? .....nah sorry

You didn't even research it

14th for i50 tackles last year and rated elite for defensive pressure (going off his bio). At 186cm he’s more mobile than fog. I see him much more in the McAdam mould, a genuine marking target that can apply ground level pressure.

 

[Lawrst]

When is crouch out of contract?

I honest think north should be chasing him, big body, hard worker and proven performer (even if he is limited).

He can get the Inside ball while the younger kids develop. Would do a lot better than some of their current leaders, god they are a mess.

 

[Mostyn]

The point was that the premiers saw fit to give a player a crack

Didn't work out in this case but it's what good clubs do

John Noble did

Turn over every stone

Posters don't want the AFC to take 3 players in the midseason draft because there are DEFINITELY 3 absolute stars there begging to be picked

And it's no egg on the club's face if the players we take end up not making it

Oh, I agree.

I just think the poster was saying that all the folks losing their s**t over the club not taking Carmichael - well, that was a bit silly.

BUT we have to pull every lever in order to find players. Absolutely we should be taking two players, minimum.

 

[Crow till I die]

The talent North has accumulated into that club over the last 2 years is next level. It would not surprise me if within the next 2 seasons they are pushing finals. Its easy to laugh now but they will fly past us. Superior midfield, they will have a better forward line. We have holes in both and but a great backline. St Kilda I think are not confident in their list. Thats why they are about to splash the cash and go all in on a single player.

I have been making that point for a while..when their top end kids get proper AFL fit look out

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Oh, I agree.

I just think the poster was saying that all the folks losing their s**t over the club not taking Carmichael - well, that was a bit silly.

But that's the whole point

It wasn't silly

Sitting out of drafts as we've done in the past, or picking the old guy before Carmichael like we did who was no chance of ever playing a game (and was instantly delisted). That's silly.

Heck, Collingwood have still got him on their list. Even their misses kick our butt

 

[Trigger13]

Statistically, Hayward is marginally more effective than Murphy.

 

[CryptoCrow]

North are looking for an experienced midfielder to help the younger players. We should be offering Laird.

Give them Ned, Murphy, Smithers and Laird for Powell and some late picks

 

[CryptoCrow]

I was impressed with Patrick Weckert from Woodville West Torrens when they were on TV the other week. Only 19 I think and was marking everything and kicking straight from 50. Looks like he's chosen footy over cricket.

Solid country footballer

 

[Crows I Am]

The talent North has accumulated into that club over the last 2 years is next level. It would not surprise me if within the next 2 seasons they are pushing finals. Its easy to laugh now but they will fly past us. Superior midfield, they will have a better forward line. We have holes in both and but a great backline. St Kilda I think are not confident in their list. Thats why they are about to splash the cash and go all in on a single player.

North have focussed on building their midfield, but have ignored the rest of the side with their high picks. They will have an amazing group of on ballers, but the worst defence in the league. They will struggle to push too far up the ladder until they improve their defence significantly.

 

[CryptoCrow]

So here's a few names to discuss for the upcoming MSD
Jack Callinan
Will Patton
Kade de la Rue
Cam Nyko
Will Gould

 

[adelaidecrows]

North have focussed on building their midfield, but have ignored the rest of the side with their high picks. They will have an amazing group of on ballers, but the worst defence in the league. They will struggle to push too far up the ladder until they improve their defence significantly.

Defence is one of the easiest areas of the game to build because you can fill it with second and third round draft picks and with a good structure it can hold up really well. Its the forward line and midfield that are the hardest. This year they will finish low and probably look at more KPP. But thats a list i that will be pretty exciting in the future.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

When is crouch out of contract?

I honest think north should be chasing him, big body, hard worker and proven performer (even if he is limited).

He can get the Inside ball while the younger kids develop. Would do a lot better than some of their current leaders, god they are a mess.

North would be better off chasing someone like Butts as they badly need a key defender... & another key forward.

 

[Scorpus]

LDU - $13-$15m for a 10 year contract is what they said.

10 year contract?

No way they offer that. He'd turn 35 in the final year of his contract

 

[Lawrst]

North would be better off chasing someone like Butts as they badly need a key defender... & another key forward.

Well to be honest they should be chasing 3-4 senior players.

A key defender, a back general in the Hodge roll, a big bodied mid like crouch and try to win some bloody games.

 

[1990crow]

He would make our side better no doubt.

He's basically a good version of Murphy and McHenry. So on that basis throw the kitchen sink

 

[1990crow]

Wait what? Hayward is a mobile, pressuring medium marking forward, not exactly a like-for-like with Fog

That’s without even bringing up the fact we have Welsh coming next year

Weird opinions recently old Wayne.
Hayward a half back. Or a forward like Fog.
Curtin a CHF.

 

[1990crow]

Statistically, Hayward is marginally more effective than Murphy.

Except he actually kicks goals.