astrovic
Premiership Player
That.
But possibly it's just other coaches not really worrying about the hurt associated with those possessions.
Talk of him ever being reported is laughable too, unless of course it's for time wasting.
Nah.
As an opposition coach you don't want any opponent getting free and easy footy and having the time to deliver it without any pressure. Allow that and you're basically hoping that the opponent will torch the footy for no reason, and even the worst ball users at AFL level don't do that very often. Even blokes with dodgy kicks have disposal efficiency ratings around 70% for a reason, namely unpressured disposal. Coaches would have their players getting 100% unpressured disposal if they could.
What you want as the opposition is to permanently deprive the best ball users (like Wells or Harvey) the footy as much as possible, which forces the footy in the hands of weaker ball users (and I accept Gibson falls into this category) and then pressure them into turning the ball over or torching it. Pressure, and the inability to execute skills under pressure, is what causes bad use of the footy. Gibbo is a repeat offender in this regard - when they can catch him.
So no coach is going out there planning to have Gibson being unaccounted for and getting the ball wherever he likes. They're not deliberately trying to squeeze the hell out of our backline, only to allow a defender an easy possession to Gibson at HBF 30 metres in the clear, relieving that pressure and moving us out of the danger zone. The aim wasn't to pressure the defenders into giving it to Gibson all on his own cos he's gonna torch it, cos that's just dumb. And Gibbo burning his man to get into space to receive the pressure relieving kick out of defence - that has just as much hurt factor as a centre clearance or a decent inside 50. The holy grail of defensive footy is a turnover inside forward 50 (and an immediate shot on goal), and having a player continually get into space to receive the outlet kick ruins that.
And Gibbo's next possession doesn't need to hurt, it needs to find a teammate. 9 times out of 10 that possession is safe and predictable (last thing you want is kicking to a one on one at half back - you need to find an open man) and Gibbo executes perfectly well when doing this.
So that ability to get 30m in the clear has nothing to do with opposition coaches allowing him space - that's the last thing they want. It means someone hasn't been able to go with him.
Where Gibson falls down is his ability to execute the difficult stuff, the stuff that Harvey and Wells are brilliant at. In particular hitting a forward inside 50 under pressure (both Gibbo and the forward). It hurts when he scrubs or bombs one in rather than hitting someone lace out. He's not Robinson Crusoe here - hell, there's a reason the big names in the league earn the big bucks and that's cos not many players can pull off that stuff. But again we set up pretty well to ensure that the good ball users are the ones delivering the ball inside 50 wherever possible, so we play pretty well to those strengths and weaknesses.