Changes for Round 1 Finals 2013

[kierez4ever]

Shame about today but who would have thought we would make it!

Do think we need hard bodies and an a decent KPF.
Renouf and Stevenson didnt do enough. I dont think you can play both Logan and Cassisi and Hombsch wasn't great

In: Hartlett, Gray, Carlile, Butcher
Out: Renouf, Stevenson, Hombsch, Logan

 

[cj_09]

Butcher doesn't get a start in our first finals game in years.

Seriously, what the **** has he done to deserve a spot???

 

[Janus]

Hartlett, Gray and Carlile in, and we win that game easily.

 

[Peck]

OUT: Renouf, Stevenson, and I have no idea who. Probably Pittard or Hombsch, maybe Logan.
IN: Carlile, Gray, Hartlett

I'm very excited about next week!

 

[Portmanteau]

Renouf, Stevenson out

Hartlett, Gray in

Logan?

 

[FallingLiefs]

Shame about today but who would have thought we would make it!

Do think we need hard bodies and an a decent KPF.
Renouf and Stevenson didnt do enough. I dont think you can play both Logan and Cassisi and Hombsch wasn't great

In: Hartlett, Gray, Carlile, Butcher
Out: Renouf, Stevenson, Hombsch, Logan

That's pretty close for me.. Butcher/Neade gets a crack if they performs tomorrow, otherwise probably Kane Mitchell comes in to be sub.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

OUT: Renouf, Stevenson, Logan, Pittard
IN: Carlile, Gray, Hartlett, Mitchell

Hombsch made some terrible decisions tonight but his defensive work is good and we need more of that type. Trengove up forward + second ruck. Pittard is just not good enough. Mitchell is the perfect sub for us.

B: O'Shea - Carlile - Jonas
HB: Cassisi - Hombsch - Broadbent
C: Cornes - Ebert - Hartlett
HF: Wingard - Westhoff - Monfries
F: Trengove - Schulz - Gray
R: Lobbe - Moore - Boak
I: Colquhoun, Wines, Young
S: Mitchell

 

[Percel]

Probs the wrong thread but good luck fellas, hope you can rebound and have a god run.

 

[PJ Power]

Butcher has to play.
If Hinkley is going to continue to throw up that rubbish of playing Westhoff behind the ball all the friggin time, he has to pick another tall forward and it ain't Renouf.

Hombsch, Stevenson, Logan and Renouf all pissed away their chances today. Pittard is another who refuses to consolidate his.

Ins:
Butcher, Carlile, Hartlett, Gray, Mitchell as sub and nothing else.

 

[edgie]

Why are we blaming Renouf for not doing enough in the forward line when Lobbe was there just as often?

 

[El_Scorcho]

Easiest changes all season.

Out:
Renouf, Stevenson, Logan

In:
Hartlett, Gray, Carlile

 

[b0ydman]

In: Hartlett, Gray, Carlile, Mitchell MUST be the sub
Out: Renouf, Stevenson, Hombsch, Pittard

Logan stays. Go in hard son

 

[b0ydman]

Why are we blaming Renouf for not doing enough in the forward line when Lobbe was there just as often?

We will need pace, can flog Lobbe into the ground one last time

 

[Shane_Mag]

Out: Renouf, Stevenson, Logan

In: Carlile, Hartlett, Gray

 

[edgie]

It will depend greatly on whether we play Richmond or Collingwood

 

[Forzaport]

Out: Renouf, Stevenson, Logan

In: Carlile, Hartlett, Gray

This IMO.

 

[PatientMental]

The obvious changes will happen.

I'm still dirty that Newton didn't play today. And I will continue to do so.

 

[RobbieGray17]

OUT: Renouf, Stevenson, Logan, Pittard
IN: Carlile, Gray, Hartlett, Mitchell

Hombsch made some terrible decisions tonight but his defensive work is good and we need more of that type. Trengove up forward + second ruck. Pittard is just not good enough. Mitchell is the perfect sub for us.

B: O'Shea - Carlile - Jonas
HB: Cassisi - Hombsch - Broadbent
C: Cornes - Ebert - Hartlett
HF: Wingard - Westhoff - Monfries
F: Trengove - Schulz - Gray
R: Lobbe - Moore - Boak
I: Colquhoun, Wines, Young
S: Mitchell

Agreeed except this. If you're going to take out Pittard, it wouldn't be for Mitchell. Despite the clangers, if you watch the games, Pittard does the team things, the 1%ers, and thats why he gets selected. Needs to work on his decision making.

 

[tribey]

Out: Needless lairising
In: Clinical efficiency

With all that dicking around at 6-7 goals up we all but drove Carlton to the snow, gave them a free lift pass and yelled nothing but 'French Fries!' until the final siren.

 

[PJ Power]

I will repeat....Hinkley has persevered all year with playing big numbers behind the ball, usually with Westhoff one of them. If that is going to be the case next week, then he has no choice but to play Butcher.
The 'G is a big ground and you can't let the opposition multi-team Schulz.

Butcher plays regardless of form.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Looks like it's going to be Richmond next Saturday at the MCG.

Collingwood would probably better with that 1 day rest advantage for us but can't see Richmond losing this.

 

[PAFCsince1870]

?

If Richmond win we play Collingwood ?

FWIW

Out: Renouf
In: witches hat

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Oh shi, I keep thinking we're 8th

 

[Waspy79]

Looks like it's going to be Richmond next Saturday at the MCG.

Collingwood would probably better with that 1 day rest advantage for us but can't see Richmond losing this.

We will play Collingwood.

 

[Jones2ByrneJones]

Why did we bring in Renouf for Gray? Was this planned, hence his exclusion from Norwood's league side?