Changes v Bulldogs

[RangaInTeal]

IN: Harvey OR Impey
OUT: Wines (inj.)

I'm with Steve;
Out: Wines
In: Harvey

 

[Schulzenfest]

If Wines is out and we need a replacement midfielder, Amon over Ah Chee for the quick Etihad track, especially when we already have both Moore and Young in the side. Plus (going off the stats at least) he had a better game in the SANFL. Probably not the week for Harvey, the running Bulldogs half backs at Etihad would kill him.

 

[NoddyHolder]

I'd go Ah CHee for Ollie - or Impey to cover a slippery small forward if they have one worth worrying about.

 

[RossFC]

Arch for Wines

 

[Papa G]

Maybe you should have watched the game, no one who watched the game would make that call....

I was sober too. I don't rate Hoon, never have rated Moore and Sam Gray isn't an AFL player. Along with Neade (who I do rate) we just can't ever be a great side with all these players in the team. 1 undersized player we can carry, 3 makes us look small and weak.

 

[x_les_x]

0% chance harvey is debuting on such a fast track as etihad.

 

[Wargreymon90]

I don't understand people who don't rate muffins

 

[scottjr]

Moore can possibly do a little bit of extra work at the clearances. Etihad we need run.

 

[Shane_Mag]

Out: Wines

In: Ah Chee

 

[ab56452001]

I don't understand people who don't rate muffins

That's one reason at least , MUFFINS , for god sake , that's sickening , worse than Tristan or Gillan or something poncy like that.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

I don't think the team can have three short people in at once. So one of Gray, neade or Hoon had to go.

Out - wines, Hoon /gray
In - ah chee, krak

 

[ab56452001]

I don't think the team can have three short people in at once. So one of Gray, neade or Hoon had to go.

Out - wines, Hoon /gray
In - ah chee, krak

Hoon atleast till he puts on 20kg , mind you Jakey manages very well with around 50kg.

 

[edgie]

With Wines out, and Young and Moore, our 2 backup inside mids, already be playing, will Ken be #PortAdelaideBrave with selections and not a like for like player, and change it up?

IN: Ah Chee or Mitchell

 

[Malibu#27]

I'm with Steve;
Out: Wines
In: Harvey

Aren't we playing at the dome. No chance we bring in a slow too for a small. Need to think mid for mid.

 

[Long live PAFC]

Things looked better today. Lack the polish but things are on the improve. Don't think anyone deserves to come out after that. So, on a fast deck against a fast team, Impey, Krak, Amon and Ah Chee would all have to be in line.

You would think Moore and Young cover Ollie's inside work so an Amon/Impey to come in for outside run and dash and Impey is the better defending so he should come in.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Gut feel it will be Monfries in for Wines with Gray/Monfries/Young being sub.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Wines' season could be over - i hope not - he is really important to the midfield group. But i wouldnt risk him either

 

[scottjr]

Gut feel it will be Monfries in for Wines with Gray/Monfries/Young being sub.

Did I see Gus having 2 weeks off somewhere?

 

[ImportExport]

who says Wines is out, Hinkley seemed to think hes a chance depending on how bad. It couldnt have been to bad for him to come back on in the first place

 

[dinger]

How the * has Hoon became a whipping boy? Are we all watching the same player? Jesus ******* christ.

 

[Jean Claude Vas Deferens]

Hoon, Moore, Gray. Too many unconvincing players.

Agreed Pappa. He has to go. Needs to be dropped for next week's game, no doubt about it….


…….you are talking about Robbie yeah?

 

[ImportExport]

Hoon was ok, i gave a few hospitals and received a few himself

 

[scottjr]

who says Wines is out, Hinkley seemed to think hes a chance depending on how bad. It couldnt have been to bad for him to come back on in the first place

Ken did indicate no risk would be taken with Ollie. Ollie came back on because he is Ollie but he couldn't hold the ball when he picked it up. He'll be four or five weeks out.

 

[RustyCage]

Did I see Gus having 2 weeks off somewhere?

On 5AA Josh Carr said he'd be having the weekend off and coming back through the Magpies the week after

 

[Chewy316]

It finally looked today like the structures were clicking. I wouldn't change the look of the side much. Reward the players for a pretty solid game. Ollie will be out, replace him with Ah Chee and play him as the sub. We looked fine from 1/4 time with one less inside mid. Arch is the perfect sub, and starting Colquhoun is probably necessary on the Etihad fast track.