Chris Judd or Nat Fyfe, whose first 100 games were better ?

[00Stinger]

Judd

 

[Jafa]

Is that how it works for you? Switching to the team that wins the grand final? Most supporters seem to support the same team for life. In which case would make Yeo and McGovern Fremantle supporters through till the end.

Lol. Watch your game idiot.

 

[brendan84]

Fyfe would have had already at that time as well.

But so many huge names. Impossible to say anyway.

Not many huge names back then? Do you even football campaigner?

 

[Spoken4]

Lol. Watch your game idiot.

I can't until 6.30pm on free to air

 

[Claude Balls]

As I assume most people with a half-decent memory capacity are saying this thread, Judd's first 100 were significantly better.

 

[Footyfan85]

What is this crap?

 

[Bell Ringer]

Your living memory is pretty average. Lockett, Voss, Hird and Wanganeen had all won Brownlow's before 100 games, Carey was already ripping teams apart week to week, McLeod had two Norm Smiths, Dunstall had kicked 419 goals, Lockett 387, Ablett Snr 332 from the wing...

There's lots of competition for the mantle.

John Coleman's first 97 games went alright .

 

[wce4premiership]

Judd's were better.

Overall Selwood's were better. Fyfe is better now but he's really come on recently, he wasn't going strong from the get go.

 

[tacopavlich]

Fyfe has reached Judds level but Judd was clearly better in his first 100 games. He was a monster from day 1.

 

[Footyfan85]

Fyfe has reached Judds level but Judd was clearly better in his first 100 games. He was a monster from day 1.

Hahaha reached Judds level?
How quickly we forget

 

[BF Tiger]

"Chris Judd or Nat Fyfe, whose last 100 games were better?" might be a better question.

 

[underthestars]

ben cousins.

 

[Spoken4]

ben cousins.

yeah...nah

 

[loki04]

Imagine if he went to Hawthorn after 2007... He'd probably be the unanimous GOAT that Ablett is looking like now.

He was headed to pies before the visy deal was offered, so much so he attended our mad monday.

Career wise would of been much better off then Carltank.

 

[Always Ballin]

He was headed to pies before the visy deal was offered, so much so he attended our mad monday.

Career wise would of been much better off then Carltank.

Oh boy,

Swan, Pendles, Judd

 

[Sylvia Saint]

I can still remember Judd kicking 5 explosive goals in a half against the Lions in their prime, would have been 2003. This board went into absolute meltdown and there was even a 'Chris Judd board' set up for a few days.

He was an absolute freak!

 

[loki04]

Oh boy,

Swan, Pendles, Judd

2010 and 2011 mid group of:

Jolly, Ball, Judd, Pendles, Swan, Beams, Thomas (non injured and in form), Sideass and Wellingham

 

[clogged]

Yeah well - what the heart really wants is grand final wins and that's something Freo just don't heart. West Coast know how to do it so I reckon they might just stay.

You guys aren't making another GF for more than a decade.

 

[Shoei]

How does a player become a "Champion" after just 100 games?

 

[ydraw]

Judd, Fyfe has just arrived at prime Judds level this year. Could end up better though, is a more compete player.

I think it's arguable Fyfe arrived at that level last year. Would have romped in the Brownlow if not for 4 weeks of suspension.

 

[Rod Stroker]

Judd easily.

But Waite's first 100 games at North will have him covered. His potential is off the charts.

 

[jackdanielz3]

Even as a Freo fan I have to say Judd, at West Coast he was the best midfielder I have ever seen

 

[re cat]

Who was younger? Didn't play only 1 game in the 2's?

 

[clivenator26]

Judd comfortably. Not that there is any shame in coming second to that, he was stunning. Fyfe's next 100 barring injury may tip him over, let's hope so.

I'm just happy seeing the WCE fans repeating the Freo fans of 02-07 nitpicking every missed shot at goal or missed target like its proof he is overrated. Both are awesome and a joy to watch.

 

[tacopavlich]

Hahaha reached Judds level?
How quickly we forget

If Fyfe had been playing at this level for the past 4 seasons instead of the last 2, then this thread would have merit.