List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[TradeDraft]

Would love Cam McCarthy, but I think that ship has sailed unfortunately.

Long Sailed I think.

Best chance of Getting a KPF off the Giants would look to be Stewart

 

[popin]

Jed Anderson from the Hawks BEEG would be your man

 

[Rusty Beam]

Jed Anderson from the Hawks BEEG would be your man

Very little chance I would think. Seems to be very much in their plans once their older guys start to pull the pin

 

[popin]

Very little chance I would think. Seems to be very much in their plans once their older guys start to pull the pin

are you BEEG?

 

[Rusty Beam]

Sorry I didn't realise once you quote someone it automatically denies other replies.

My bad. I'll keep walking

 

[Black Prince]

Its all so simple......

Wishful thinking I know but time our club grew some balls and go after them. We have been on the back foot lately and forced to trade and accept players/picks we ideally would not have considered or trying to trade without giving much . If Hawthorn can recruit the likes of Burgoyne McEvoy Frawley Lake so should Collingwood .Imagine the impact it would have on the club and team we have . Buckley needs some help and it might save his career.

 

[Apex36]

Long Sailed I think.

Best chance of Getting a KPF off the Giants would look to be Stewart

Stewart is meh. I'd rather leave him where he is and draft a real KPP, not a tall forward flanker like he is.

 

[TradeDraft]

Stewart is meh. I'd rather leave him where he is and draft a real KPP, not a tall forward flanker like he is.

Well the Draft is said to be light on KPF's

 

[TradeDraft]

Jed Anderson from the Hawks BEEG would be your man

Was in interesting how Hawks got Anderson. Got him from GWS in the Gilham Trade few years back

 

[Black Prince]

Would likely require Sidebottom or Grundy plus our first round pick at the minimum.

Might have a chance at one of them for just our first-rounder if they pull a Beams.

Won't be popular but I would offer the first 2 picks and a combination of Witts Blair Goldsack or Oxley .
No doubt they would want a quality midfielder which they could pick up in the draft .

 

[Black Prince]

Was in interesting how Hawks got Anderson. Got him from GWS in the Gilham Trade few years back

How shrewd are they and think Graham Wright heads up recruiting.

 

[TradeDraft]

Would likely require Sidebottom or Grundy plus our first round pick at the minimum.

Might have a chance at one of them for just our first-rounder if they pull a Beams.

and We won’t be Trading Either Steele or Grundy unless as you say they Pull a Beams(Leave on there own Accord) but I am 99% Sure they won't

 

[TradeDraft]

How shrewd are they and think Graham Wright heads up recruiting.

He is the Best List Manager in the AFL at the Moment

 

[Bard]

Won't be popular but I would offer the first 2 picks and a combination of Witts Blair Goldsack or Oxley .
No doubt they would want a quality midfielder which they could pick up in the draft .

There's no chance on Blair or Goldsack. Witts is a possibility if clubs view him at the same value as Grundy. Even then we'd be paying unders, and to lure a player like that without them screwing their club over we'd need to be offering perceived 'overs'. Honestly unless one of them comes out and says they /have/ to come to Collingwood like Beams did, or Griffen did to an extent, it'd be Sidebottom or nothing you'd think.

 

[Bard]

and We won’t be Trading Either Steele or Grundy unless as you say they Pull a Heater

Absolutely, and we can't afford to lose Sidebottom under any circumstances IMO since losing Beams.

 

[popin]

Won't be popular but I would offer the first 2 picks and a combination of Witts Blair Goldsack or Oxley .
No doubt they would want a quality midfielder which they could pick up in the draft .

It might come down to what position we end up in the first round and if there are kids that we can draft for free that could be better than shiel etc but it's all very interesting to come up with ideas and bundles to try trade for a good young player

 

[Black Prince]

Absolutely, and we can't afford to lose Sidebottom under any circumstances IMO since losing Beams.

Agree Sidebottom won't be going anywhere and how good did he look before the injury . Will be elite before the end of the year .

 

[Soaring Magpie]

Would love to see us chase anyone who can provide outside run and carry, guys like the hill bros, Isaac smith. Blokes who can carry for 20 and the deliver the football with precision. It's something we really lack

 

[iGNITER]

Treloar. Exactly what we need.

If not him then Shiel.

 

[TradeDraft]

Absolutely, and we can't afford to lose Sidebottom under any circumstances IMO since losing Beams.

We can’t afford to lose any of our Good Players/Prospect now.

IF so You start wondering the Relationship the Players have with Bucks.

Though I think it’s settled now

 

[TradeDraft]

Would love to see us chase anyone who can provide outside run and carry, guys like the hill bros, Isaac smith. Blokes who can carry for 20 and the deliver the football with precision. It's something we really lack

Suckling could play that Role

 

[hellfire]

Would love to see us chase anyone who can provide outside run and carry, guys like the hill bros, Isaac smith. Blokes who can carry for 20 and the deliver the football with precision. It's something we really lack

That's what Seedsman needs to become for us.

 

[pablo disco bar]

Do not trade witts....I repeat do not trade witts

 

[frizzle]

Do not trade witts....I repeat do not trade witts

This!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Breezer]

Witts is the one player with currency . Particularly if he continues to improve this year . The swans would be keen as mustard and would certainly hand over say a hanibery if he was keen to come back to vic .
Gws have a top ruck man but he is getting on in years so a wits would be tempting to involve in trade if a treloer/ shiel wanted to come home . Aside from our stars , I cannot see who else would interest them .