Macca19
Moderator
- Moderator
- #1
Well...what a game of football. Dunno what to say. Just a really entertaining game of football.
Where should i start.
Well might as well get straight to the point. Martin Ellis should never umpire another game of football again. That was by far the most blatantly one sided umpiring performance ive ever seen from any game of football ive watched. It happened right from the start. They just screwed us over all match. They must have had about 10 free kicks (most of them so called behind the play ones) before we got one. Obviously free kicks arent meant to be even....but that was just bullcrap. I wont ever see a more cheating performance than that ever again. They must have had 8 down the ground frees from behind the play incidents that supposedly happened. Well why didnt Michael and Scott get a free kick against them last week? They got every dodgy free kick you could possibly imagine. We got none. Brett Ebert got a blatant kick in the face...the most obvious kicking in danger ever....yet nothing, but they can pull 10 frees for holding out of their arse. Brisbane supporters can call this biased...but if that happened to them they would be bleating something chronic. Any group of supporters would.
Onto the last quarter fadeout. What the hell was with that. We cant say its a one off either. We always do it. We get a match winning lead....then completely stop. This has happened consistently since 2001 and i HATE it. I absolutely hate it. We rarely thump sides. We always look like thumping them...then we allow the opposition to kick the last 3-6 goals of the match. Always. I for one am sick of it. Why the hell did we play "shut up shop" football 10 minutes into the last quarter. Ridiculous. Here is a chance to thump the Brisbane Lions and get some sort of edge over them mentally, but we stop, allow them to go within probably 1 more minute of play of pinching the match.
Onto the good parts. How impressive were we in the third quarter?? The first half as well was some of the best tough football you will see from both sides. Neither team gave an inch and it looked like being a low scoring battle all night but the last half opened up a lot.
It was a case of pretty much everyone played well. The only player I thought was below par was Chad...again. Too many brain fades, too far behind, too many mistakes. Pity about Surjan getting injured in the first 10 minutes. There were some good signs by the younger brigade today and it was good to see.
Player Reviews:
Primus - Thought he was fantastic. Showed some of the dominant Primus of old tonight and it was good to see. That gather, dodge, handball, recieve then kick straight to Tredrea in the third quarter was outstanding. Definately high in the best players. Great seeing him rucking again.
16 disposals, 5 marks, 21 disposals.
Wakelin - Thought he held Bradshaw extremely well up until the last quarter...but he may have been moved off him by then as it seemed Chad was on him. Top defensive game. Didnt see too much of the footy himself tho.
6 disposals, 3 marks
Montgomery - Excellent first half...slowed down a touch but was really effective early on. Dropped in front numerous times for strong marks.
12 disposals, 7 marks
Wanganeen - He just wont stop playing top football. He could play another 10 years. High in our best. Was everywhere tonight. Top performance.
19 disposals, 6 marks
Lade - Great to see Laser back in form. Top game of football. Marked well, kciked well, rucked well, played well.
10 disposals, 4 marks, 10 hitouts, 3 goals
Francou - Much better than last week and had the better of Voss in the end i thought. Much improved performance.
17 disposals, 5 marks
Shattock - Clearly his best game for us, if not his best game of AFL football ever. Hope he continues that form for the rest of the season. Was assured of himself, took a great grab, did some tough stuff and played as we should expect him to play.
23 disposals, 10 marks
Tredrea - Held well very early on but broke free in the second and third quarters and kicked 4 goals in a row. Doesnt play well in big games? pfft.
12 disposals, 6 marks, 5 goals
Dew - Great across half back...especially in the first half. Another that had a quiet second half but his first was very impressive. Won his own footy a lot of the time too.
16 disposals, 2 marks
K Cornes - Hes just a machine. Good game again. Our most reliable player now. Never plays poor.
18 disposals, 8 marks, 1 goal
Brogan - A bit quiet but had his moments. Took the match saving mark at the end. 9 disposals, 1 mark
White - His best game for us in my opinion. Really took his oppurtunity this week and in my opinion played just as well if not better than the standard Toby game. Top first half but again, slowed in the second.
17 disposals, 7 marks, 1 goal
Cassisi - Very high in our best players for mine. Took Akermanis completely out of the game for all but the last 10 minutes or so. Apparently destroyed him.
17 disposals, 2 marks
Cochrane - Good game today. Not noticed too much but did some nice things
10 disposals, 3 marks
Kingsley - One of our best early but faded as the game wore on. Had plenty of the pill
25 disposals, 9 marks
Chaplin - Found him really impressive in teh first half but didnt get a minute of the second half. Odd move but definately held his own and he likes to create the play.
7 disposals, 2 marks
Ebert - His best game in Power colours for sure. Really showed a lot of potential to take his game another level today. Presented well, marked strongly, led well with plenty of pace and kicked well. Great all round performance. Good to see.
14 disposals, 5 marks
C Cornes - I thought he had a poor game. Was left behind a few times, made some terrible decision errors and his kicking was poor. Dropped plenty of marks as well.
23 disposals, 7 marks
Pettigrew - How bloody impressive was he tonight. That move in the second quarter where he won the ball, ran into the 50 handpassed off for a goal was sensational. He knows how to play, reads the play well and does the team thing a lot of the time.
10 disposals, 2 marks
James - ROOOGGEEERR!! Good first up match for him. Great to have him back
15 disposals, 6 marks, 1 goal
Surjan - As i said, sad that he injured what seemed to be a calf when tackling in the first quarter. Hope it isnt a longterm one.
1 tackle
Walsh - Steady, calm, composed. What a great addition to this club. I love watching Peter play. Great game of football tonight. He just does everything well.
19 disposals, 2 marks
POTY VOtes:
10
9 -
8 - Primus, Wanganeen, Shattock, Tredrea, Cassisi, Walsh
7 - Wakelin, Montgomery, Lade, Dew, Ebert, K Cornes, Kingsley
6 - Francou, White, James
5 - Pettigrew
4 - Chaplin
3 - Brogan, Cochrane, C COrnes
2
1
Where should i start.
Well might as well get straight to the point. Martin Ellis should never umpire another game of football again. That was by far the most blatantly one sided umpiring performance ive ever seen from any game of football ive watched. It happened right from the start. They just screwed us over all match. They must have had about 10 free kicks (most of them so called behind the play ones) before we got one. Obviously free kicks arent meant to be even....but that was just bullcrap. I wont ever see a more cheating performance than that ever again. They must have had 8 down the ground frees from behind the play incidents that supposedly happened. Well why didnt Michael and Scott get a free kick against them last week? They got every dodgy free kick you could possibly imagine. We got none. Brett Ebert got a blatant kick in the face...the most obvious kicking in danger ever....yet nothing, but they can pull 10 frees for holding out of their arse. Brisbane supporters can call this biased...but if that happened to them they would be bleating something chronic. Any group of supporters would.
Onto the last quarter fadeout. What the hell was with that. We cant say its a one off either. We always do it. We get a match winning lead....then completely stop. This has happened consistently since 2001 and i HATE it. I absolutely hate it. We rarely thump sides. We always look like thumping them...then we allow the opposition to kick the last 3-6 goals of the match. Always. I for one am sick of it. Why the hell did we play "shut up shop" football 10 minutes into the last quarter. Ridiculous. Here is a chance to thump the Brisbane Lions and get some sort of edge over them mentally, but we stop, allow them to go within probably 1 more minute of play of pinching the match.
Onto the good parts. How impressive were we in the third quarter?? The first half as well was some of the best tough football you will see from both sides. Neither team gave an inch and it looked like being a low scoring battle all night but the last half opened up a lot.
It was a case of pretty much everyone played well. The only player I thought was below par was Chad...again. Too many brain fades, too far behind, too many mistakes. Pity about Surjan getting injured in the first 10 minutes. There were some good signs by the younger brigade today and it was good to see.
Player Reviews:
Primus - Thought he was fantastic. Showed some of the dominant Primus of old tonight and it was good to see. That gather, dodge, handball, recieve then kick straight to Tredrea in the third quarter was outstanding. Definately high in the best players. Great seeing him rucking again.
16 disposals, 5 marks, 21 disposals.
Wakelin - Thought he held Bradshaw extremely well up until the last quarter...but he may have been moved off him by then as it seemed Chad was on him. Top defensive game. Didnt see too much of the footy himself tho.
6 disposals, 3 marks
Montgomery - Excellent first half...slowed down a touch but was really effective early on. Dropped in front numerous times for strong marks.
12 disposals, 7 marks
Wanganeen - He just wont stop playing top football. He could play another 10 years. High in our best. Was everywhere tonight. Top performance.
19 disposals, 6 marks
Lade - Great to see Laser back in form. Top game of football. Marked well, kciked well, rucked well, played well.
10 disposals, 4 marks, 10 hitouts, 3 goals
Francou - Much better than last week and had the better of Voss in the end i thought. Much improved performance.
17 disposals, 5 marks
Shattock - Clearly his best game for us, if not his best game of AFL football ever. Hope he continues that form for the rest of the season. Was assured of himself, took a great grab, did some tough stuff and played as we should expect him to play.
23 disposals, 10 marks
Tredrea - Held well very early on but broke free in the second and third quarters and kicked 4 goals in a row. Doesnt play well in big games? pfft.
12 disposals, 6 marks, 5 goals
Dew - Great across half back...especially in the first half. Another that had a quiet second half but his first was very impressive. Won his own footy a lot of the time too.
16 disposals, 2 marks
K Cornes - Hes just a machine. Good game again. Our most reliable player now. Never plays poor.
18 disposals, 8 marks, 1 goal
Brogan - A bit quiet but had his moments. Took the match saving mark at the end. 9 disposals, 1 mark
White - His best game for us in my opinion. Really took his oppurtunity this week and in my opinion played just as well if not better than the standard Toby game. Top first half but again, slowed in the second.
17 disposals, 7 marks, 1 goal
Cassisi - Very high in our best players for mine. Took Akermanis completely out of the game for all but the last 10 minutes or so. Apparently destroyed him.
17 disposals, 2 marks
Cochrane - Good game today. Not noticed too much but did some nice things
10 disposals, 3 marks
Kingsley - One of our best early but faded as the game wore on. Had plenty of the pill
25 disposals, 9 marks
Chaplin - Found him really impressive in teh first half but didnt get a minute of the second half. Odd move but definately held his own and he likes to create the play.
7 disposals, 2 marks
Ebert - His best game in Power colours for sure. Really showed a lot of potential to take his game another level today. Presented well, marked strongly, led well with plenty of pace and kicked well. Great all round performance. Good to see.
14 disposals, 5 marks
C Cornes - I thought he had a poor game. Was left behind a few times, made some terrible decision errors and his kicking was poor. Dropped plenty of marks as well.
23 disposals, 7 marks
Pettigrew - How bloody impressive was he tonight. That move in the second quarter where he won the ball, ran into the 50 handpassed off for a goal was sensational. He knows how to play, reads the play well and does the team thing a lot of the time.
10 disposals, 2 marks
James - ROOOGGEEERR!! Good first up match for him. Great to have him back
15 disposals, 6 marks, 1 goal
Surjan - As i said, sad that he injured what seemed to be a calf when tackling in the first quarter. Hope it isnt a longterm one.
1 tackle
Walsh - Steady, calm, composed. What a great addition to this club. I love watching Peter play. Great game of football tonight. He just does everything well.
19 disposals, 2 marks
POTY VOtes:
10
9 -
8 - Primus, Wanganeen, Shattock, Tredrea, Cassisi, Walsh
7 - Wakelin, Montgomery, Lade, Dew, Ebert, K Cornes, Kingsley
6 - Francou, White, James
5 - Pettigrew
4 - Chaplin
3 - Brogan, Cochrane, C COrnes
2
1