Autopsy Round 21, 2023: St.Kilda v Carlton

[StFly]

Dard Ball Get actually the loss was good for us, now we'll be angry and beat Richmond next week.

But Richmond also lost and they'll be angry too. Hmm..might be a feisty one!

We can MMA next week and spend less time on it. Win-win.

 

[jwikked]

If you could ban yourself for a week that’s be great. What a horrendous call. My god.

Do you disagree with the comment, or do you just not like it?
Do you think he’s mentally strong and playing like he wants to be the #1 forward?

 

[PoppedCorn]

We can’t trade king but he’s role has to evolve… it anit Woking atm.

It's CHF leading at the ball
Needs to run and is good on ground ball pick up
A stay at home fwd he isn't imo

 

[Tommy Wigs]

Not all bad. Hopefully go to the draft with some extra, perhaps later, picks and maybe doing some magic on spare salary cap. Mids mids mids.

 

[Cairnsman]

Sinclair

Yeah think Wilkie is more of a leader, both dependable and trustworthy but Wilkie probably more of a leader

 

[Pardon me]

Lost it in the midfield again.
Credit to Carlton, they remembered they were the in form team and punished an insipid side after half time.

It really is becoming tiresome watching the same thing happen every week.

Would not be bothered in the slightest if we lost a number of players over the trade period.
Gresham I’ve had out the door for 10 weeks or more.

Feels like we’ve been saying this for a dozen years; we need mids.

 

[SaintJ]

This just compounds that Petracca screw up …. I know clutching straws but this club and its decisions!!

 

[George]

Two draws and a win will lock in finals for us

Won't beat Geelong or Brisbane so it's curtains. Boys should be over the moon!

 

[SaintJ]

Love Sincs but I’d vote Wilkie

 

[Dard Ball Get]

This just compounds that Petracca screw up …. I know clutching straws but this club and its decisions!!

What

 

[Max the great]

Most these blokes don’t have fight in ‘em.
Absolutely disgusted.

Yep. When it gets tough most of them check out.

 

[Simon Templar]

Watching some on this board oscillate between calling us a s**t house team and then sooking it up when we don't beat the most in-form team of the comp will never stop being a wild experience.

On Pixel 6 using BigFooty.com mobile app

It the passion for our team that upsets us when we see one of the most putrid halves of football.

 

[jwikked]

This just compounds that Petracca screw up …. I know clutching straws but this club and its decisions!!

I live with it quite easily knowing our developmental program would have left Petracca a skinny beanpole who can’t hit targets.
We would have delisted him by now after ruining him.

 

[bird_man]

It's all about standards remember guys.

The standards now at the club are through the roof, don't get too caught up about only kicking one goal in the second half with a near full strength side.

 

[phantom13]

Won't beat Geelong or Brisbane so it's curtains. Boys should be over the moon!

Flight centre at Southland should just close doors tomorrow and head to Linton street.

 

[Ads734]

Yes mids beaten but the forward line was deplorable. Bad games from Caminiti, Sharman, Pou, Butler.
They had their opportunities but blew them all. 1 goal in a half.

Agreed. He's not fit plus anyone who doesn't understand the midfield is the problem has mango sized rocks in there head. Absolutely smacked in the middle second half. Dropped our heads and work rate dropped off to an abysmal level.
Needed our leaders to step up when we were getting torn a new one in there but they went missing. We are a very very soft side when it starts going against us.

It’s Bizzare isn’t it that guys like King get targeted and not the midfield

My apologies Mrs.King. I hope my comments don’t upset Max too much.

Mate you can say whatever rubbish you like, im gonna call you out when you make poor calls. That’s the point of this board discussion. If you’re gonna claim something , be ready to back it up.

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Hill should be dropped for one act alone.
Letting someone mark over you without putting body in is utterly insipid and an insult to your teammates and us.

 

[SaintJ]

Didn’t quote the message I was replying to was about crouch being spent in 4th

 

[L_W_P]

I don't like KPD as captain. If their opponent gets a run on that sort of momentum can be killer. Same with a FF as captain. Missing goals hurts more.

Sinc as skipper for me.

 

[The Jack]

Apart from being an ordinary side, 2 things killed us.

1. King missing from 20m (As is his go to ) late in the 3rd.

2. Gresham not being able to kick over 40m to hit King out the back late in the 3rd.

So disappointing. We got slaughtered in the last qtr. Looked like they had an extras 2 or 3 on the ground. Every contest we were outnumbered,

Was it to be expected? Yes.

Just had Hope after the 1st half.

 

[Sully111]

Dard Ball Get actually the loss was good for us, now we'll be angry and beat Richmond next week.

But Richmond also lost and they'll be angry too. Hmm..might be a feisty one!

OMG

The team we play next week lost this week?

Just our luck

The curse continues

 

[Ads734]

Probably the dumbest thing I've ever heard.

Lets trade a top 3 young key forward because our team kicks it to him too much.

Carlton kept bombing it to Curnow and he only kicked one. They better trade him now

Don’t forget first game back after a shoulder, how did the 26 year old wonder kid from Carlton go today? Reckon they might trade him after that game.

 

[lethalsaints]

Let's get them draft picks

 

[SaintJ]

Hill should be dropped for one act alone.
Letting someone mark over you without putting body in is utterly insipid and an insult to your teammates and us.

Hill is bloody frustrating

 

[Veer Right]

Sinclair

real captains moment when he took on that front on contact, didn’t flinch, stayed in position and intercepted and passed it off.

Him or Wilkie for captain.

Yeah loved Sincs short nothing kicks in defence in the last quarter when we had to retake the lead. Don't attack or anything and lead by example.

Wilkie as captain sounds good. Monster upgrade over our current one.