Standardised premiership tally

[South of the Yarra]

Maybe you need to believe that, but there is genuinely no pain here. Let me tell ya, I'm very happy we won our flags before the era of less pressure. Melbourne, Geelong & Collingwood won after the emasculation, and that's a fact.

More hurt. Every little inference just shows more pain. That Premiership drought from a bygone era is eating at you.

 

[Tiger2709]

War Premierships and COVID Premierships should receive even lower.

Not all our clubs had draft dodgers playing for them.

Covid flags get double points for difficulty.

 

[Tiger2709]

How many flags would Richmond have cleaned up without the stand rule? 5 ya reckon? Or even 6?

And why are the AFL trying to emasculate them? Is there something we don't know about, like alien overlords that are allergic to black and yellow?

Just ex Geelongites sick of being reamed in final after final (12 v 2)

 

[Tiger2709]

More hurt. Every little inference just shows more pain. That Premiership from a bygone era is eating at me.

Come on its been 43 years surely your over it by now?

 

[caloschwaby]

Says the bloke whos own team has the all time record for getting beat in grand finals!

And all time record for Grand Finals won! Well done champ

 

[Fadge]

There's no point conversing if you have a pre recorded answer and are too upset to acknowledge reality.

Conspiracy nonsense.

Same old Falcon stuff.

+1.

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

Geelong and Carlton supporters say go back to 1877

I've never heard any Carlton supporters trying to claim flags prior to 1897, so not sure what you're basing that off.

 

[Tiger2709]

Ok, fair post, but you aren't counting how you happen to get the players that got you those 3 premierships, you were crap for years getting high draft picks so you hopefully pick up the better draft picks.

Yes I know some teams have been lucky with FS's but imagine how good Geelong could have been if they were also tanking for picks.

We weren't tanking though we were just that bad, still not at Norf levels but pretty ordinary. Geelong wouldn't have got those F/S players so easily under current rules, they rorted the system before it was a system.

Don't forget Dusty was pick 3, thanks Dees and Cotch was pick 2 thanks to Carlolton tanking the Kreuzer cup, also got Rance in 2007

 

[NetworkNerd]

I've never heard any Carlton supporters trying to claim flags prior to 1897, so not sure what you're basing that off.

Spend much time on the bay?

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

Spend much time on the bay?

Not a fan of war zones.

 

[TheUnicorn]

The Greatest Club of The AFL Era 1990-2022 - The Mongrel Punt

Which team has given their supporters the best "bang for buck" since the AFL commenced in 1990? Peter Monagle does the leg work for you.

themongrelpunt.com

 

[Carringbush2010]

The Greatest Club of The AFL Era 1990-2022 - The Mongrel Punt

Which team has given their supporters the best "bang for buck" since the AFL commenced in 1990? Peter Monagle does the leg work for you.

themongrelpunt.com

So if you add this year..........

 

[Fadge]

So if you add this year..........

I suspect a 10 year old wrote the article.

'The major anomaly being Richmond'.

The fact a premiership win was worth 5 times as much as Grand Final loss, and 25 times as much as a Preliminary Final loss, they might as well have just listed the teams in order of number of flags won.

But they're surprised that a team who has barely played finals for 90% of the timeframe referenced, finished behind teams who have finished top 4 more often than they haven't?