Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[esorhali]

Alright guys, dilema over 6th forward

Reimers vs Medhurst vs Zeibell

was also thinkin bout kennedy(WC) or the tomahawk for that spot but i want a bit of cash left over

I am having the same dilemma...leaning towards Medhurst , mainly due to his experience. He seems injury free this year and if he can recapture his form he should go alright. I was toying between Medhurst, Dangerfield or Ziebel.

Another one ..Franklin v Higgins v Gianciracusa v Gray v S. Johnson

Currently have franklin but not sure...?? Help !!!

 

[staedtler]

Pav or Brown?

Enright or Heath Shaw?

Higgins, Gia or Gray?

Malceski, Hunt or Ladson?

 

[staedtler]

Hall and Dangerfield

or

Tippett and Ballantyne?

 

[Ed D]

3rd defender needed: Just under $600k to splash.

Selwood v Mitchell v Bartel ....... (Have Ablett, ROK, Ball, Trengrove, Martin)

Selwood, although I'd pick NDS and Pendles over them all.

Not sure if this known by everyone on this thread yet.

Pods may only get 3 games in before Mitch BROWN comes back from injury which means he will go back to the VFL until mid year when he can be re-elevated unless anyone else gets injured in the mean time.

Brown's injury is coming along faster than they excpected.

Don't they have more than one LTI?

Mitchell Banner or Luke Shuey?

Probably the last decision I need to make.

Depends how much risk you want to take. I have them both and think they'll do well, but see Shuey as a higher risk/higher reward type player over Banner, who I see as a more solid but lesser scoring.

 

[Bomber4ever]

Hall and Dangerfield

or

Tippett and Ballantyne?

First option definately looks better to me. I think the first option will have a bigger price and will be more consistent.

Schoenmakers v Waters

Ziebell and Hitchcock/Gumbleton v Warren and Rohan

Thanks

 

[September 27 2008]

First option definately looks better to me. I think the first option will have a bigger price and will be more consistent.

Schoenmakers v Waters

Ziebell and Hitchcock/Gumbleton v Warren and Rohan

Thanks

a) Higgins/Griffen/Ball + Scully + Trengove

b) Pendlebury + 2 of Jetta/Shuey/Banner

Can you please bold which player/s you would choose from which option

Thanks

 

[jinny1]

Lecras OR Robbie Gray OR Kurt Tippet OR Porplyzia Pr Steve Johnson OR Higgins?

Franklin OR Pavilich?

and Ballantyne OR chris Mayne??

 

[Baxter23]

Lecras OR Robbie Gray OR Kurt Tippet OR Porplyzia Pr Steve Johnson OR Higgins?

Franklin OR Pavilich?

and Ballantyne OR chris Mayne??

For me Higgins, even with the injury concern. He is going to be a superstar.

IMO Buddy. They will score similar and you save cash.

 

[Baxter23]

I've heard Jay Nash is flying at training and is taking all of the kick outs in the drills.

Mention of him having a midfield roll to.

Another option and only $220k.

Anybody heard any different.

 

[douls]

I've heard Jay Nash is flying at training and is taking all of the kick outs in the drills.

Mention of him having a midfield roll to.

Another option and only $220k.

Anybody heard any different.

Not 100% but that is also what i have heard. Ripped it up pre season so far.

 

[thomas_m18]

Mitchell Banner vs Luke Shuey?

Asked before, but still unsure.

I think Shuey has more upside, but 50/50

 

[eugene_tomas]

broughton v duffield v newman????

and pods v gumby v hitchy

 

[Rhino5]

broughton v duffield v newman????

and pods v gumby v hitchy

I like Duffield out of those three and Hitchcock in the other lot.

Mine is Heath Shaw vs Duffield. Not sure that I trust either, but they both have a fair bit of upside IMO.

 

[jinny1]

i would go for banner but i have both on my team..

franklin or tippet?

 

[Powerade 08]

I've heard Jay Nash is flying at training and is taking all of the kick outs in the drills.

Mention of him having a midfield roll to.

Another option and only $220k.

Anybody heard any different.

LOL. As Jay Nash buddy 2010 I am pretty much forced to agree, get on him, he will win the brownlow.

 

[thomas_m18]

i would go for banner but i have both on my team..

franklin or tippet?

Franklin. If you can afford him, he's a better pick.

MY QUESTION

Joel Selwood and James Podsaidly or Bryce Gibbs and Cameron Hitchcock?

Pods might find it tough to find a spot on Geelong's list, because as a rookie, if Mitch Brown gets well, Pods will have to go back on the rookie list.

Like the look of the second one a little better now.

The forward will be on the bench.

 

[Sunday Red]

i would go for banner but i have both on my team..

franklin or tippet?

Franklin - providing you have a bench player to cover a Round 1 zero from the suspended Hawk.

Heath Shaw vs Chris Newman?

 

[peteshep]

Vince and J.Brown

Vs

Griffin and ROK

griffin to break out?

 

[Baxter23]

LOL. As Jay Nash buddy 2010 I am pretty much forced to agree, get on him, he will win the brownlow.

Oh I love the sarcasim!!!!!!!

 

[thomas_m18]

Franklin - providing you have a bench player to cover a Round 1 zero from the suspended Hawk.

Heath Shaw vs Chris Newman?

Newman. Looks more solid, not sold on Shaw just yet. Maybe a good upgrade target later.

Franklin. If you can afford him, he's a better pick.

MY QUESTION

Joel Selwood and James Podsaidly or Bryce Gibbs and Cameron Hitchcock?

Pods might find it tough to find a spot on Geelong's list, because as a rookie, if Mitch Brown gets well, Pods will have to go back on the rookie list.

Like the look of the second one a little better now.

The forward will be on the bench.

Anyone please? Leaning towards second one.

 

[larrikan]

+1

Equal... I have them both.....

 

[larrikan]

OK...
A)Franklin or Robbie Gray

and please only replies from experienced supercoachers who know the upsides of both players....my dilemma...there is a possibility with the hawks woeful injuries that supply to Buddy will again be poor like last year giving him some inconsistent scores...then can Gray consistently get 100+ scores and the occassional monster?

B) is anyone else taking the enormously risky but potentially high reward Tippett and Nic Nat ruck combo?

 

[dima_1771]

Franklin easily, and yesi do have that ruck combo good luck to us

Higgins or Gia??

 

[larrikan]

Franklin easily, and yesi do have that ruck combo good luck to us

Higgins or Gia??

I have both...cannot separate them...Higgins is an injury risk but scores high in sc...Gia before his broken leg was a proven sc performer and appears to be back to that form pre season. In saying that I like mids in the forward line in sc.

 

[thomas_m18]

Selwood and Podsaidly

OR

Gibbs and Hitchcock?


Heard if Mitch Brown recovers, Pods has to go back on rookie list.

Leaning towards second one