Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[jinny1]

Ben Nason OR Jake Carlisle?

Adam Cooney OR Matthew Pavilich OR Bernie Vince OR Andrew Swallow??

 

[thomas_m18]

higgins vs harvey vs buddy

Hmmmm, Buddy is the X-Factor, but Higgins will get marginally better. Both are up and down, but Buddy will probably cause you to lose more sleep and pull out more hairs.

Having said that, I think Buddy offers a tiny bit more upside

OK, straightforward:

Ben Warren or Taylor Walker?

Probably Warren. Looked good in the NAB, and I'm not sure how many points T.Walker has been getting, but if it's anything like last year... Also the fact that I love the fact that there's Ben Warren and Warren Benjamin on the same list. Good stuff, but make sure you don't get them mixed up in Supercoach

MY QUESTION

Ben Howlett or Jarrod Kayler-Thomson?

Looking for creativity and cheap prices for the last mid. Leaning towards Howlett, already elevated and should play round one, B&F for Peel (I think) last season.

Although JKT could pull a few surprises.

I am liking Howlett a tinge more, but thoughts?

 

[maxrm]

Need 2 reserves for my forwardline. But having trouble deciding...

2 of:

D Stewart, Hitchcock, Rocklifff, Duncan, Podsiadly, Dennis-Lane, Gumbleton, David, Lobbe, Fyfe.


and 1 of:

Higgins, Harvey, Gray

enright vs grimes

Moles vs Howlett


bolded players are currently in my team

 

[marshie_blues]

Ben Nason OR Jake Carlisle?

Adam Cooney OR Matthew Pavilich OR Bernie Vince OR Andrew Swallow??

Carlisle

and tough one but i would take vince

heres mine Harvey vs Higgins vs Buddy

and 2 of Jetta, Shuey, Banner and Bastinac

 

[jinny1]

Carlisle

and tough one but i would take vince

heres mine Harvey vs Higgins vs Buddy

and 2 of Jetta, Shuey, Banner and Bastinac

Higgins is going to be a superstar but he is injury prone so id go with a fitter and slimmer buddy...

Shuey and Banner..


Here's mine: The best 465k to 370k Defender??

includes gilbee,adcock,waite,harbrow,gram,mackie

 

[Baxter23]

Carlisle

and tough one but i would take vince

heres mine Harvey vs Higgins vs Buddy

and 2 of Jetta, Shuey, Banner and Bastinac

I am in exactly the same predicament.

I have ended up adjusting my team to get both Buddy & Boomer. I am a bit cocerned about Higgins injury frequency.

Can't split Boomer & Buddy.

As for your next question I am going to wait until the sides are selected for round 1. I don't think there is any other soultion. If anything Jetta will get good scores every now and then but I think he will be up and down. he's just that type of player.

My problem is Ball & Cooney or Any midfielder & Masten???????

 

[maxrm]

currently have Sam Mitchell, but have enough cash left to afford Dal Santo and anyone else priced below him. Could also change a bit to add Lenny Hayes in for Mitchell. Who does everyone think would be the best option?
And also, deciding whether D Swan's worth it, or is L Hayes a better choice?

Thanks in advance.

 

[jd2006]

Question marks over Hayes fitness isnt there? Not 100% sure.

Dal or Mitchell are proven SC stars cant really go wrong either way.

My question is 7th forward $288,000 or less had Ballantyne but injury concerns I've read. Considering the following;

Polkinghorne, Hentschel, Mayne, Staker, Maric (MELB), Warren, Yarran, Walker (ADE)

Its more of an player a - z list but the last forward spot with that amount of cash is really doing my head in

 

[Baker_for_PM]

Go Swan Lenny is not at peak form yet.
R.Murphy vs anyone around that price???

 

[pulpdriver]

B. Goddard, L. Anthony and J. Brennan
or
C. Enright, B. Deledio and J. Brown

 

[maxrm]

Go Swan Lenny is not at peak form yet.
R.Murphy vs anyone around that price???

Josh Kennedy could be a good option this year, Barry Hall would definitely be a better option then Murphy imo and someone like Mark Williams might thrive being the main target at essendon. I'd personally go Hall -> Murphy = Kennedy.

Sorry for all the Q's guys but do u think Montagna can continue on from his amazing form last year? Choosing 2 of him Ablett and Swan...

 

[marshie_blues]

B. Goddard, L. Anthony and J. Brennan
or
C. Enright, B. Deledio and J. Brown

2nd one but i would prob stay clear of brown i think he starts of to slow and there are better options between 450-500K ie higgins, harvey, buddy and maybe even gray

 

[djlowz]

Waite & B.Harvey

vs

Kenelly & Pendlebury

??

 

[IWantToBeGlass]

Afraid I can't offer much on Montagna. See no real reason for him to drop off though.

My dilemma. Have $630 to share between my 4th mid and 7th fwd. Right now it's either:

Masten & Ballantyne

or

Trengrove & Gray

hmmm...

 

[September 27 2008]

Afraid I can't offer much on Montagna. See no real reason for him to drop off though.

My dilemma. Have $630 to share between my 4th mid and 7th fwd. Right now it's either:

Masten & Ballantyne

or

Trengrove & Gray

hmmm...

Ballantyne injury murmor??? Check the Freo board

 

[russea]

Afraid I can't offer much on Montagna. See no real reason for him to drop off though.

My dilemma. Have $630 to share between my 4th mid and 7th fwd. Right now it's either:

Masten & Ballantyne

or

Trengrove & Gray

hmmm...

Hmm after his preseason form i like gray so the 2nd option

 

[russea]

My question
Watson V Cross V Boyd

 

[marshie_blues]

ROK and Goodes
vs
ROK and Pendles
vs
Pendles and Goodes

 

[russea]

ROK and Goodes
vs
ROK and Pendles
vs
Pendles and Goodes

I like the pendles rok option. Both have had strong preseasons

 

[IDIG]

I'm liking Watson. Seems a very decent unique choice and you won't come up against many teams with him. Could be this year's Montagna/Swan???


ROK and Pendles marshie. Not sure about Goodes and his new role. His preseason scores arent exactly comforting either.

 

[Bomber4ever]

Yeah, i'd take Pendles and ROK, not confident in Goodes.

My question: Hurn and Hunt v Gram and Kennelly

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Yeah, i'd take Pendles and ROK, not confident in Goodes.

My question: Hurn and Hunt v Gram and Kennelly

I'd go the first. Hunt looks ready to go pretty large for his $250k price tag and represents excellent value. Kennelly may improve but probably not as much as Hunt. Gram has a great potential upside but Hurn may be a lot more consistent as the go to man in defence.

 

[russea]

Goodwin, Rok and Bastinac
V
Goddard Pav and Moles

The 1st option have had gun preseasons but i dont think you can right goddard and pav off yet. And will the rookies have anything to do with it

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

My question
Watson V Cross V Boyd

Boyd.

The only WBD midfielder to average over 100 last year. No reason why he won't do it again (And maybe more).

 

[russea]

Boyd.

The only WBD midfielder to average over 100 last year. No reason why he won't do it again (And maybe more).

Jobe was essendons only PLAYER to avg over 100 why cant he do that again?