2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[MightyRoar]

If I had to choose only between these two, NVB and Pearce.
But I would prefer any rookie and Pearce, pocket the cash as an option

Cheers bud and yeah that's the other option, not totally sold on either of VB or Pearce atm to be honest, just throwing a few options around.

 

[hoddo]

If I had to choose only between these two, NVB and Pearce.
But I would prefer any rookie and Pearce, pocket the cash as an option

+1
Pretty much word for word on what I was about to write.

 

[cdcanman]

Cheers bud and yeah that's the other option, not totally sold on either of VB or Pearce atm to be honest, just throwing a few options around.

Well Pearce did everything he could yesterday in order to convince us, or more importantly, to convince Ross the Boss.
With what we know right now, I think he is as good an option as any mid-priced defender. Don't forget, he was locked and loaded first 22 before injury struck. So Ross is a fan

 

[Kadog]

Duffield injury helps cement a spot

 

[cdcanman]

Duffield injury helps cement a spot

Has there been an update on this injury as yet? Is it long-term?

 

[felsty]

Fisher and Goldstein v Smith/Simpson and Maric

 

[MightyRoar]

Well Pearce did everything he could yesterday in order to convince us, or more importantly, to convince Ross the Boss.
With what we know right now, I think he is as good an option as any mid-priced defender. Don't forget, he was locked and loaded first 22 before injury struck. So Ross is a fan

Oh yeah most def......be interesting to see how he performs in the remaining NAB cup games because if he performs well then like you say he is as good an option as any mid-priced defender and will present as a very good cash cow!!

 

[toxic]

Has there been an update on this injury as yet? Is it long-term?

Talk of bruised ribs

 

[cdcanman]

Oh yeah most def......be interesting to see how he performs in the remaining NAB cup games because if he performs well then like you say he is as good an option as any mid-priced defender and will present as a very good cash cow!!

If he were to return to his best, he could well end up a viable D6 this year

 

[cdcanman]

Talk of bruised ribs

If that's all it is then I doubt it impacts on Clancee's inclusion or otherwise come Rd 1.
Some talk it was a shoulder. I didn't see it but read that this morning. Then again, journo's know squat about injuries

 

[Kadog]

Talk of bruised ribs

Thought it was a shoulder?

 

[Knighta21]

Selwood V Beams V Sloane V Priddis ???

 

[MightyRoar]

Fisher and Goldstein v Smith/Simpson and Maric

Fisher and Goldstein for me......Goldy is a given and SC is all about risk and reward. Fisher is a fallen prem not a mid pricer and with a full preseason under his belt I think he can return to his lofty hights of the past.....big fan of Fisher!!

 

[MightyRoar]

Selwood V Beams V Sloane V Priddis ???

After his first NAB cup game I'm leaning towards Beams.....obv like a lot of players we'll have to see how they perform over all the preseason games but tonight's game against the swans will shed a bit more light on how Beamsy is looking.....

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Fisher and Goldstein v Smith/Simpson and Maric

Smith/Simpson and Maric IMO. Fishers body too much of a concern.

I would pick Smith just ahead of Simpson IMO. Simpson is reliable & longer high soring SC history of course.
Smith has more upside as still developing.

 

[toxic]

If that's all it is then I doubt it impacts on Clancee's inclusion or otherwise come Rd 1.
Some talk it was a shoulder. I didn't see it but read that this morning. Then again, journo's know squat about injuries

Thought it was a shoulder?

So did I but freo board and apparently RTB were saying it was ribs

who knows

either way Clancee may be named captain next week, he is simply that good! and he's 6ks LIGHTER

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Clanceeeee Pearce or Gary Rohan?

 

[Flandersss]

Clanceeeee Pearce or Gary Rohan?

Clanceeeeeeee.

 

[Amazing Bombers]

Clanceeeee Pearce or Gary Rohan?

Clancee if named for round 1 , seriously underpriced for what he can score imo.

 

[toxic]

My..YES my Clanceeeeee train is full.

GTFOff all of you cheap defender hunters

 

[Flandersss]

My..YES my Clanceeeeee train is full.

GTFOff all of you cheap defender hunters

I'm sorry! toxic

Please don't hurt me

 

[Judd_Magic]

Which two defenders out of -

Hurn
M.Johnson
Adcock
R.Murphy

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Which two defenders out of -

Hurn
M.Johnson
Adcock
R.Murphy

Murphy Hurn. Wait on Johnson to see if other Freo KPD's are fit and if they are get him over Bobby

 

[toxic]

Which two defenders out of -

Hurn
M.Johnson
Adcock
R.Murphy

Murphy will be the highest points scorer of the lot

 

[Judd_Magic]

Murphy will be the highest points scorer of the lot

Who do you think will be the second Toxic?