2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[TheOz]

I enjoyed the Bulldogs dudes and their bitchfest on here before, bring it back!

 

[Conz9]

Interested to see:
Priddis vs Jordan Lewis vs Heppell

- all a likely chance to finish in top 10 but who will have the higher average?!?

 

[TheOz]

Interested to see:
Priddis vs Jordan Lewis vs Heppell

- all a likely chance to finish in top 10 but who will have the higher average?!?

Priddis imo, Eagles main extractor and will always be in and under at the coalface. Whilst Lewis had a tremendous season last year, the Hawks have an incredibly even spread of players and unlike Priddis, Lewis has only averaged 100+ once (109.4 last season) and at his age, history doesn't bode well for him being able to improve on that.

Don't rate Heppell as a SC player.

 

[Conz9]

Priddis imo, Eagles main extractor and will always be in and under at the coalface. Whilst Lewis had a tremendous season last year, the Hawks have an incredibly even spread of players and unlike Priddis, Lewis has only averaged 100+ once (109.4 last season) and at his age, history doesn't bode well for him being able to improve on that.

Don't rate Heppell as a SC player.

Yeah thanks, i was thinking along the same lines,
could priddis go bigger than sloane and jpk?

Also i think heppells consistency and importance in the essendon team will see him become sc elite very soon, unsure if it will be this year though which is my only worry

 

[TheOz]

Yeah thanks, i was thinking along the same lines,
could priddis go bigger than sloane and jpk?

Also i think heppells consistency and importance in the essendon team will see him become sc elite very soon, unsure if it will be this year though which is my only worry

Don't think he has the ceiling that those two have.

 

[jjsmitty8]

Jack Macrae, Brad Crouch or Jack Steven?

Pick two.

 

[toxic]

TBH Courtney Johns was rough to not get a game ahead of Lucas and Lloyd, the man was set for big things

Wasnt set for big things ever, by all reports he was born with a BIG thing and used it extensively for the good of many

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Wasnt set for big things ever, by all reports he was born with a BIG thing and used it extensively for the good of many

Yeah I was being sarcastic, the bloke was a deadset spud. Jack Redpath would give him a run for his money

 

[MightyDons4]

Higgins vs Lumumba vs Docherty vs Rampe vs Langdon

Please rank them 1st 2nd 3rd etc

 

[MightyDons4]

Jack Macrae, Brad Crouch or Jack Steven?

Pick two.

Steven and Crouch

 

[Goats]

Higgins vs Lumumba vs Docherty vs Rampe vs Langdon

Please rank them 1st 2nd 3rd etc

In order of highest average.
Higgins, Docherty, Rampe, Lumumba, Langdon.

 

[jjsmitty8]

Lobbe and 35k or Goldstein?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Lobbe and 35k or Goldstein?

Have to see Lobbe number with Ryder in the team.

 

[toxic]

Lobbe and 35k or Goldstein?

Lobbe if no ryder

 

[Kadog]

Wasnt set for big things ever, by all reports he was born with a BIG thing and used it extensively for the good of many

Courtney John Holmes??

 

[Pedro]

Cheers. Now after that, what about Josh Kelly or Taylor Adams?
I feel like Adams will get more time in the midfield for the Magpies, but Adams can get suspended & give away a few frees so I'm not sure.

Neither for me, but If forced to choose, Josh Kelly. More likely to hit the side of a barn.

 

[Lums23]

Jack Macrae, Brad Crouch or Jack Steven?

Pick two.

Crouch and steven. Griffin and liba out from last year's team leaves macrae a potential tag target

 

[stevebbb]

keen for some opinions.

(if Hibberd is banned) Simpson vs Kelly
Newnes vs Rampe vs Sutcliffe vs KK
Murphy vs Danger vs Jack vs Wines vs Swallow
Goldy vs Maric
Bartel vs Franklin

 

[toxic]

Simpson
KK
Danger
Maric
buudy

 

[Lums23]

keen for some opinions.

(if Hibberd is banned) Simpson vs Kelly
Newnes vs Rampe vs Sutcliffe vs KK
Murphy vs Danger vs Jack vs Wines vs Swallow
Goldy vs Maric
Bartel vs Franklin

Simpson
Wines
Goldy (unless you need the extra 40k)
Buddy

 

[New_Frrost11]

keen for some opinions.

(if Hibberd is banned) Simpson vs Kelly
Newnes vs Rampe vs Sutcliffe vs KK
Murphy vs Danger vs Jack vs Wines vs Swallow
Goldy vs Maric
Bartel vs Franklin

Simmo
Newnes (or KK)
Murphy (really struggled last year and has heaps to prove this year - will kill it.)
Neither (Goldy if I have to choose)
Jimmy B

 

[MightyRoar]

Langdon v Pearce

 

[MightyDons4]

keen for some opinions.

(if Hibberd is banned) Simpson vs Kelly
Newnes vs Rampe vs Sutcliffe vs KK
Murphy vs Danger vs Jack vs Wines vs Swallow
Goldy vs Maric
Bartel vs Franklin

Simpson
Newnes
Not a fan of any of these options, if I had to choose one I'd take Wines
Maric
Bartel

 

[Unique Name]

Yeo v Mayes

 

[gcsunsfc]

Cripps vs. Ben Newton?

and does anyone think that either Lamb / Krakouer / Lonie is safe enough for a F6 position?