2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Flandersss]

Clancee would be a lock if his spot was guaranteed in Freo's 22

I think Ross likes him, just injuries that were holding him back.

43 games in the first 2 seasons Ross was there, says something.

 

[Flandersss]

J Lewis v Parker

Luke Parker.

 

[Flandersss]

Swan vs Ziebell +20k
Deledio/Buddy/Martin vs Devon Smith + 40-60k
Nic Nat vs Z.Smith + 80k
Rich vs Wells
Griffen vs any other mid 500-550 (not swallow)
Enright vs Kelly vs Hibberd
Jacobs vs Mumford
Mayes vs Geary vs Pittard vs KK
Harbrow vs Fisher

1. Swan.
2. Buddy.
3. Nic Nat.
4. Rich.
5. Wines.
6. Kelly.
7. Jacobs.
8. KK.
9. Fisher.

 

[PoopingHindi]

tossing up between Hickey (if fit) and Zac Smith for R2

thoughts?

 

[TN25]

Don't like Pittard?

Young rebounding defender in a very good side, 72 sc points in limited game time against WC aswell.

I don't mind him, I just wouldn't pay 358k for a 65 averaging defender

 

[TN25]

tossing up between Hickey (if fit) and Zac Smith for R2

thoughts?

Hickey. He'll be out number 1 ruck next year and he'll continue to improve. Smith coming back from an ACL, I'm not sure how he'll go

 

[Flandersss]

I don't mind him, I just wouldn't pay 358k for a 65 averaging defender

No different to picking KK.

Looking for that improvement 80-85+ avg.

 

[TN25]

No different to picking KK.

Looking for that improvement 80-85+ avg.

IMO KK is much more likely to improve.

 

[Flandersss]

IMO KK is much more likely to improve.

Fair enough, I think that too.

That's why I have KK & Pittard

With a sprinkle of Clanceeeeeee.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Hickey. He'll be out number 1 ruck next year and he'll continue to improve. Smith coming back from an ACL, I'm not sure how he'll go

i was leaning towards Hickey as well. concerned that he doesnt get enough of it around the ground though and the new ruck scoring will really hurt him

also KK > Jasper. but im picking neither

 

[Flandersss]

KK > Jasper. but im picking neither

I think this aswell, helps when your a #4 draft pick.

Slim pickings premium wise in defence, no one screams "pick me".

 

[Jiska]

Gibson + Vandenberg

Or

KK + Newton ?

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Zach Merrett or Daisy Thomas?

 

[Daniels]

Gibson + Vandenberg

Or

KK + Newton ?

KK + Newton

 

[KardiniaPark]

Gibson + Vandenberg

Or

KK + Newton ?

A.

Zach Merrett or Daisy Thomas?

Id rather play a man down.

 

[Goats]

Gibson + Vandenberg

Or

KK + Newton ?

Will Vandenberg be elevated for round 1? If so then he and Gibbo.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Will Vandenberg be elevated for round 1? If so then he and Gibbo.

It seems so but i'm still cautious of Roos. Not convinced you'd get a solid block out of him even if he did start R1.

 

[gerrardwatson]

Treloar vs Prestia
Griffen vs Wines vs Crouch
Maric vs Naitanui
Deledio vs Martin
Beams vs sloane
and rank in order KK Haynes Savage Docherty Ibbotson
(sorry for clogging)

 

[Flandersss]

Treloar vs Prestia
Griffen vs Wines vs Crouch
Maric vs Naitanui
Deledio vs Martin
Beams vs sloane
and rank in order KK Haynes Savage Docherty Ibbotson
(sorry for clogging)

Trelour.
Wines.
Nic Nat.
Martin.
Sloane.
KK, Docherty, Haynes, Ibbotson & Savage.

 

[MightyRoar]

Treloar vs Prestia
Griffen vs Wines vs Crouch
Maric vs Naitanui
Deledio vs Martin
Beams vs sloane
and rank in order KK Haynes Savage Docherty Ibbotson
(sorry for clogging)

Either or with the first one as both have groundings for improvement and would both be a viable selection.
NicNat.
Lids.
Beams.
KK and neither of the rest.

 

[Kadog]

Gibson + Vandenberg

Or

KK + Newton ?

Gibson Vandenberg

 

[Lums23]

Treloar vs Prestia
Griffen vs Wines vs Crouch
Maric vs Naitanui
Deledio vs Martin
Beams vs sloane
and rank in order KK Haynes Savage Docherty Ibbotson
(sorry for clogging)

Prestia
Wines (just)
NN (as long as he isn't sore heading into the start of the year)
Martin
Sloane (beams riskier, could score better but new team so new role slightly unknown)
Docherty, kk, Haynes, Ibbo, Savage (believe savage is injured)

 

[JuddgementDay]

cant really decide...
danger, luey & whitecross
OR
a swallow, maric & brown

 

[KardiniaPark]

Prestia
Wines (just)
NN (as long as he isn't sore heading into the start of the year)
Martin
Sloane (beams riskier, could score better but new team so new role slightly unknown)
Docherty, kk, Haynes, Ibbo, Savage (believe savage is injured)

Beams is pretty safe. He'll be full time mid, rest forward - kick goals. He's a great player, I wish I could squeeze him in. I just hope he doesn't rise too much before I can nab him. If any of my premiums go down before R1 I'll be jumping straight to him.

 

[Kadog]

cant really decide...
danger, luey & whitecross
OR
a swallow, maric & brown

Luey will struggle
Whitex no certainty to start
Danger stud

Option 2 although I'd go Griffen Maric & cheaper defense rookie