List Mgmt. Treloar officially nominates Pies as his pref club (Mods: please use this thread for all AT posts)

[Captain Embubry]

Given the amount of time we seem to have been into Treloar for and the amount of potential star power he adds to our team, there just seems no possible outcome where we dont land him and he slips to Richmond. You have a player like that nominate your club and you get the deal done. Simple as that. Fair enough Richmond fans trying to hold onto some hope, but in my view it just doesn't happen for them.

 

[inamedthegiants]

^^^^
Okay what is your Source on these inamedthegiants ?

A player who plays for the Giants - who is one of the closest to Treloar, who was one of the first Treloar spoke when we rejected his managements offer the last time - which was close to the time when we played Richmond this year.

 

[PicaBoo]

So he is KB’s Source

In his defense. What is the point of inviting him and then trashtalk the minute he posts. Seriously [emoji53].
He got enough trust in his source to shout the Richmond board beers for 1 hour in Canberra. That is more confidence then I have seen from posters here

 

[TradeDraft]

In his defense. What is the point of inviting him and then trashtalk the minute he posts. Seriously [emoji53].
He got enough trust in his source to shout the Richmond board beers for 1 hour in Canberra. That is more confidence then I have seen from posters here

I did not Invite Him. He came by himself

 

[inamedthegiants]

OK, this reeks of desperation from your part in the hope that there could be a bidding war for Treloar's services. He has chosen Collingwood, and a deal will get done.

The Tigers supporters are a bit bi-polar and going onto their board trying to drum up Treloar's value with false sources, only gets their (false) hopes up and preparing them for a fall isn't helping things.

Mate the deal to land Treloar will net us 2 first rounders, with either club.

If I was pushing up his price I'd be on the Carltank board offering him and Bugg and Hampton for their number 1.

Haggling over a couple of first rounders would be redundant.

 

[TradeDraft]

A player who plays for the Giants - who is one of the closest to Treloar, who was one of the first Treloar spoke when we rejected his managements offer the last time - which was close to the time when we played Richmond this year.

So going by You. He be Happy to Go to Carlton IF they Entered the Market? They won’t they would try and push him into the Draft

 

[TradeDraft]

OK, this reeks of desperation from your part in the hope that there could be a bidding war for Treloar's services. He has chosen Collingwood, and a deal will get done.

The Tigers supporters are a bit bi-polar and going onto their board trying to drum up Treloar's value with false sources, only gets their (false) hopes up and preparing them for a fall isn't helping things.

Mate the deal to land Treloar will net us 2 first rounders, with either club.

If I was pushing up his price I'd be on the Carltank board offering him and Bugg and Hampton for their number 1.

Haggling over a couple of first rounders would be redundant.[/QUOTE]

So how the Negtionans going between Collingwood and GWS at the Moment then? inamedthegiants ?

 

[PicaBoo]

I did not Invite Him. He came by himself

Beg to differ

A lot of this is coming from inamedthegiants so he's more than welcomed to talk Treloar talk on our board right, because his sources conflict with a lot of other people's sources.

And you liked that post btw

 

[popin]

Mate the deal to land Treloar will net us 2 first rounders, with either club.

If I was pushing up his price I'd be on the Carltank board offering him and Bugg and Hampton for their number 1.

Haggling over a couple of first rounders would be redundant.

Mate your on every Treloar thread , go have a kitkat

 

[inamedthegiants]

So going by You. He be Happy to Go to Carlton IF they Entered the Market? They won’t they would try and push him into the Draft

No, and I can be quoted on this on the main board, the club would consider sending him to the PSD if he picked only one destination and that destination, wether it be Collingwood, Demons or Mars FC tried to low-ball us.

 

[inamedthegiants]

Mate your banned on every Treloar thread , go have a kitkat

Fixed.

 

[popin]

No, and I can be quoted on this on the main board, the club would consider sending him to the PSD if he picked only one destination and that destination, wether it be Collingwood, Demons or Mars FC tried to low-ball us.

Your posting psd for the 100th time lol seriously get over it la la land

 

[TradeDraft]

Beg to differ

So where is your Proof then PicaBoo

 

[Madagascar]

Mate the deal to land Treloar will net us 2 first rounders, with either club.

If I was pushing up his price I'd be on the Carltank board offering him and Bugg and Hampton for their number 1.

Haggling over a couple of first rounders would be redundant.

But then what's the purpose of you posting on four different boards on bigfooty, The Drafts board, Richmond board, Collingwood board and I presume GWS board? If you are certain it'll net you two first rounders, then aren't you wasting your time?

You're not fooling me, and I doubt you're fooling anyone else. You are concerned about what you may or may not be remunerated for Treloar, and we can understand that, we were in the same position with Beams last year.

You're best bet is a bidding war and you are going onto the Richmond board with false sources offering them false hope.

 

[inamedthegiants]

Your posting psd for the 100th time lol seriously get over it la la land

I'm not saying PSD.

I'm saying the club has considered it.

 

[inamedthegiants]

But then what's the purpose of you posting on four different boards on bigfooty, The Drafts board, Richmond board, Collingwood board and I presume GWS board. If you are certain it'll net you two first rounders, then aren't you wasting your time?

Because fans from opposition teams throw up trade bait, in your fans' instance Witts, and I want to debate his worth to us a club.

The same way that Fremantle fans think that 2 very late first rounders would net a contracted KPF.

People offer up their thoughts, and as this is a forum I get the ability to debate that.

Especially when I'm drawn across in to your by your good self.

 

[jmac70]

Now I'm really confused.

 

[inamedthegiants]

Mate the deal to land Treloar will net us 2 first rounders, with either club.

If I was pushing up his price I'd be on the Carltank board offering him and Bugg and Hampton for their number 1.

Haggling over a couple of first rounders would be redundant.

So how the Negtionans going between Collingwood and GWS at the Moment then? inamedthegiants ?

Can clubs discuss trades already?

 

[popin]

I'm not saying PSD.

I'm saying the club has considered it.

You live in fantasy world mentioning psd again like it's going to happen cos you have so much hatred towards collingwood as I seen your posts on other threads. You want Treloar to join anyone else but collingwood #growup #getoverit

 

[PicaBoo]

Now I'm really confused.

It is all clear. We get Treloar but reality hasn't caught up with us yet.

 

[jmac70]

Because fans from opposition teams throw up trade bait, in your fans' instance Witts, and I want to debate his worth to us a club.

The same way that Fremantle fans think that 2 very late first rounders would net a contracted KPF.

People offer up their thoughts, and as this is a forum I get the ability to debate that.

Especially when I'm drawn across in to your by your good self.

What other names were you considering for your club?

 

[inamedthegiants]

You live in fantasy world mentioning psd again like it's going to happen cos you have so much hatred towards collingwood as I seen your posts on other threads. You want Treloar to join anyone else but collingwood #growup #getoverit

No.

A club official (high ranking) mentioned to me the PSD.

It could have been an option.

It looks highly likely we'll be more than adequately compensated and that won't happen.

 

[frizzle]

So how the Negtionans going between Collingwood and GWS at the Moment then? inamedthegiants ?

Can clubs discuss trades already?[/QUOTE]


If you think they aren't already talking, you're crazy.
Bucks even said on AFL360 he has spoken to Treloar's management & Treloar himself, since he selected the Pies as his new home.
They will come to an agreement that suits both clubs.
Just the same way both clubs did when Adams & Heater swapped clubs.
Was a win/win for both clubs & I expect that to continue.

 

[inamedthegiants]

What other names were you considering for your club?

Honestly, none.

I can't see a player aside from your untouchables who would improve our list.

But the majority of Pies fans kept mentioning Witts' name.

That's why I asked for 2 first rounders and this years second.

 

[DaicosianMarvels]

Now that Buckley said the talks have started, if these guys cant manage to agree on a deal in a month I would be pretty disappointed.

I am confident a deal will get done that makes GWS happy and Collingwood.