Jake Stringer - The Revenge of Membrey

[cleveland]

This belongs in the Bay not on the main board

 

[Ok Boomer]

Dropped just before finals, must not be very good.

Will trade for McGinnity because we are nice.

 

[Milanista28]

Dogs caught wind he wants out to the Bombers. That's what my source says.

 

[Super Hans]

Why the hell was this seperated from the other thread? Now it just looks stupid.

 

[go you pups]

Why the hell was this seperated from the other thread? Now it just looks stupid.

Mods trolling

 

[burningdwarf]

Everyone's favourite Saints troll with some fine commentary on Membrey before he joined us;

Wouldn't mind membrey. Good sign that players want to come with us, despite some numpties claiming nobody does

After Membrey joins;

What does membrey actually do? Doesn't kick goals, doesn't get the ball, not a defensive forward by any means.

You'd probably rather give mccartin some game time as the third tall. Membrey is shit

Saints lost deal getting him for free;

You do know it's spelt Membrey right? Plus he is a third tall at best, a completely different position. Lucky st Kilda didn't give up much for him, Sydney won the deal as it is already

Redpath has shown more at both AFL and VFL level than white ever did. And Redpath hasn't shown much.

What do you think now that he has kicked more goals than Stringer this year in four less games and now seems unlikely that he'll be caught because Jakey is playing VFL?

At least you have a standalone VFL team so he'll hopefully develop into a decent player.

 

[Ekomaira]

Everyone's favourite Saints troll with some fine commentary on Membrey before he joined us;

After Membrey joins;

Saints lost deal getting him for free;

What do you think now that he has kicked more goals than Stringer this year in four less games and now seems unlikely that he'll be caught because Jakey is playing VFL?

At least you have a standalone VFL team so he'll hopefully develop into a decent player.

haha love it

 

[dewah07]

stringer having a shocking year and your bragging membery has kicked 2 more goals lol

for arguments sake if you did the ladder on goals per game for everyone on that list members is 7th in the league

 

[BallaratBulldog]

I do admit I laughed both then and now, but its a bay 13 thread that never got moved.

 

[Boxhead_31]

 

[underthestars]

most overrated player in the domp. last season was his version of woewodin and conney's brownlow years - except they won a brownlow.

 

[Ozil]

Reckon the media kicks up this much of a fuss if Membrey gets dropped?

 

[Cadillac]

for arguments sake if you did the ladder on goals per game for everyone on that list members is 7th in the league

Count me as one who is a massive Membrey fan mate. I find it staggering he's listed under 190cms. I definitely think it helps Membrey's game being alongside Mccartin and Bruce though. Stringer hasn't had much help up forward and our entries inside 50 have been abysmal at times. But Stringer certainly prefers to play the 3rd tall forward role. Can go back to that once we get Crameri back and another big forward to help Boyd. I'd be silly too say he hasn't been disappointing though. Membrey's certainly had the better year.

 

[Falchoon]

View attachment 278544

2 more goals,more marks, more shots on goal, better % at goal and 3 less game. thats who

and would cost 1/10th

Stringer's marks tally stands out, more akin to the forward pockets listed.

 

[Leeda]

Tall or short? if the clothes fit then who cares?

 

[joop]

Everyone's favourite Saints troll with some fine commentary on Membrey before he joined us;

After Membrey joins;

Saints lost deal getting him for free;

What do you think now that he has kicked more goals than Stringer this year in four less games and now seems unlikely that he'll be caught because Jakey is playing VFL?

At least you have a standalone VFL team so he'll hopefully develop into a decent player.

You should know by now when ManOfClay is caught out like this he never replies. Like after when we beat the dogs, he didn't post anything until the North v Saints game when we were getting beaten.

 

[Laverde2Smack]

What a nice burn [emoji106]

 

[joop]

Reckon the media kicks up this much of a fuss if Membrey gets dropped?

A player as good as Membrey doesn't get dropped.

 

[Theo X]

Why was this bumped, Membrey is a dud and Stringer is a gun.

 

[Wojcinski]

 

[joop]

Why was this bumped, Membrey is a dud and Stringer is a gun.

One is averaging nearly 3 goals a game, the other has been dropped to the VFL. Very thorough analysis from you once again.

 

[burningdwarf]

Why was this bumped, Membrey is a dud and Stringer is a gun.

Is Membrey the one that's kicked about 10 goals against your team in two wins this year?

Hate to see what'll he do against you once he stops being a "dud".

 

[aussierulesrules]

Why was this bumped, Membrey is a dud.

He'd be leading the goalkicking at 10 clubs right now, including yours- despite him having played 4 less games than Hogan for the year and 5 less than Watts.

 

[Doggstats]

Wondering which mod made this new thread? Considering he turned a Jake Stringer thread into a Stringer vs Membrey thread I'm guessing a St.Kilda mod, but can't count out a LolNorf mod either.

Either way this belongs in the bay now.

 

[JusticePunisher]

Wondering which mod made this new thread? Considering he turned a Jake Stringer thread into a Stringer vs Membrey thread I'm guessing a St.Kilda mod, but can't count out a LolNorf mod either.

Either way this belongs in the bay now.

Correct it's clear to all Membrey is the better player. Comparing Stringer to him is ridiculous.