Geelong and Hawthorn record monumentally embarrassing 1300 page shitfight thread. (Part 2)

[Freofalcon]

I think your lost Falcon this is thread is for dynasty supporters.... and handbaggers.

I've had a couple of beers.

Felt like going for a wander.

 

[Hoooops]

We should really only allow opposition supporters in here if they're helping the Hawfies. It's only fair.

 

[OnTheRocks]

We should really only allow opposition supporters in here if they're helping the Hawfies. It's only fair.

 

[Hoooops]

View attachment 311127

Yes?

 

[William Wonka]

Vickery is the Hawks #2 forward.

You questioned my maths recently Chappy, im going to question yours here.
I personally rate Roughy, Gunston, Bruest, Cyril and Poppy above Vickery at the moment, so I would say Shoenmakers and Vickery are fighting off for #6.

 

[ChappyUK]

You questioned my maths recently Chappy, im going to question yours here.
I personally rate Roughy, Gunston, Bruest, Cyril and Poppy above Vickery at the moment, so I would say Shoenmakers and Vickery are fighting off for #6.

Expensive No 6 ruckman.

 

[William Wonka]

Expensive No 6 ruckman.

Now ruckmen on the other hand we are a bit light on for.

McEvoy was strongly considering quitting football to concentrate on farming (yeah yeah I know) and his back was giving him big problems.

Then Ceglar does his ****in knee!

Fitzpatrick as our only ruck was not appealing.

 

[JD Tomahawk]

They really need to set up a dog park at York park for all the tassie hawk members.

 

[ChappyUK]

Now ruckmen on the other hand we are a bit light on for.

McEvoy was strongly considering quitting football to concentrate on farming (yeah yeah I know) and his back was giving him big problems.

Then Ceglar does his ****in knee!

Fitzpatrick as our only ruck was not appealing.

Vickery is your 1st or 2nd ruckman. I think that's worse than 6th forward.

 

[William Wonka]

Vickery is your 1st or 2nd ruckman. I think that's worse than 6th forward.

Yeah its not great

 

[A Cut Above]

Vickery is the Hawks #2 forward.

Roughead
Gunston
Sicily
Rioli
Bruest
Puopolo

...........Vickery. Nice try though.

 

[ChappyUK]

Roughead
Gunston
Sicily
Rioli
Bruest
Puopolo

...........Vickery. Nice try though.

Sicily ahead of Cyril. At least there's one Hawk who doesnt overrate him.

 

[A Cut Above]

Sicily ahead of Cyril. At least there's one Hawk who doesnt overrate him.

I listed the tall forwards first. Sttttrrrrriiikkeee two, would you care to take another swing?

 

[ChappyUK]

I listed the tall forwards first. Sttttrrrrriiikkeee two, would you care to take another swing?

You're about 10-0 down at the bottom of the 9th so you need a few strikes.

Wherever you rate Vickery you're willingly paying him 500k a year to pull on a Hawks jumper.

 

[Lethality]

Hawthorn can pay Vickery whatever they want, as long as they're not giving up first round picks willy nilly like Geelong are

 

[ChappyUK]

Hawthorn can pay Vickery whatever they want, as long as they're not giving up first round picks willy nilly like Geelong are

Solid logic that.

 

[A Cut Above]

You're about 10-0 down at the bottom of the 9th so you need a few strikes.

Wherever you rate Vickery you're willingly paying him 500k a year to pull on a Hawks jumper.

I rate Vickery higher than any tall forward on Geelong's list except Tom Hawkins, who is so shockingly immobile he ruins your entire forward structure.

 

[ChappyUK]

I rate Vickery higher than any tall forward on Geelong's list except Tom Hawkins, who is so shockingly immobile he ruins your entire forward structure.

Well that's surprising

 

[A Cut Above]

Well that's surprising

Clarko will probably turn Vickery into the game's premier Forward/Ruck. I'm sure he could transform Motlop into a 50 goal a year forward like Bruest, its little wonder the fat bastard lacks motivation playing under Chris Scott who's hampered his development.

So has Scott developed anyone into an A grader? The only player I can think of is Harry Taylor and he would've learned everything he knows from Scarlett, Lonergan & Enright instead. Well at least Scott's realized how shit he is at developing talent so now he blows 1st rounders on hacks from Carlton instead of exploring the draft.... hmm maybe I've been harsh on Stephen Wells because after all he was recruiting A graders when Bomber Thompson was there to develop them.

 

[ChappyUK]

Clarko will probably turn Vickery into the game's premier Forward/Ruck. I'm sure he could transform Motlop into a 50 goal a year forward like Bruest, its little wonder the fat bastard lacks motivation playing under Chris Scott who's hampered his development.

So has Scott developed anyone into an A grader? The only player I can think of is Harry Taylor and he would've learned everything he knows from Scarlett, Lonergan & Enright instead. Well at least Scott's realized how shit he is at developing talent so now he blows 1st rounders on hacks from Carlton instead of exploring the draft.... hmm maybe I've been harsh on Stephen Wells because after all he was recruiting A graders when Bomber Thompson was there to develop them.

Rinse. Repeat.

 

[hawkman]

Clarko will probably turn Vickery into the game's premier Forward/Ruck. I'm sure he could transform Motlop into a 50 goal a year forward like Bruest, its little wonder the fat bastard lacks motivation playing under Chris Scott who's hampered his development.

So has Scott developed anyone into an A grader? The only player I can think of is Harry Taylor and he would've learned everything he knows from Scarlett, Lonergan & Enright instead. Well at least Scott's realized how shit he is at developing talent so now he blows 1st rounders on hacks from Carlton instead of exploring the draft.... hmm maybe I've been harsh on Stephen Wells because after all he was recruiting A graders when Bomber Thompson was there to develop them.

Taylor was an A grader before Scott arrived

 

[RedVest4]

Clarko will probably turn Vickery into the game's premier Forward/Ruck. I'm sure he could transform Motlop into a 50 goal a year forward like Bruest, its little wonder the fat bastard lacks motivation playing under Chris Scott who's hampered his development.

So has Scott developed anyone into an A grader? The only player I can think of is Harry Taylor and he would've learned everything he knows from Scarlett, Lonergan & Enright instead. Well at least Scott's realized how shit he is at developing talent so now he blows 1st rounders on hacks from Carlton instead of exploring the draft.... hmm maybe I've been harsh on Stephen Wells because after all he was recruiting A graders when Bomber Thompson was there to develop them.

Sam Menegola (A Grader)

 

[William Wonka]

Sam Menegola (A Grader)

Played 7 games.
7.
(I know the records say 8 but I refuse to believe he was actually on the ground in the QF.)

 

[11sjw]

It bothers me that you traded a Brownlow medallist!

as opposed to paying one not to play this year.

 

[ChappyUK]

as opposed to paying one not to play this year.

Hawks are paying part of Mitchell's wage next year.