Round 5 trades

[Mongoose528]

Any thoughts on this team?

Was going to go a little sideways and go Cripps to a 550k plus mid but maybe a waste of a trade?

Team looks good, I'd hold.

 

[Test Tickle]

whats his reasoning behind this?

He believes that because Hodge wasnt injured, got up and kept playing, Parsons will get off.

 

[buttox]

Pretty happy with my defence now.
Adams doc laird Lloyd otten Newman.
Set until byes IMO.

 

[RobZombie]

Also, any news on Hibberd? Surely with North's season almost over he will be due to come back in?

Got a head knock in the VFL. Was playing well up until then. Had 15 touches in half a game.

Anderson, Clarke and EVW all smashed it yesterday and look to be ahead of him for the time being. Mountford (24d 10 tackles) and Wagner (20d 3 tackles) also going well. Would like to think Swallow and Thompson are on thin ice but ... Scott .

Probably needs to convince the match committee he should be playing ahead of Gibson. He'll be back at some point. Worth it as a DPP floating donut for me (and only D/M link with Adams) as long as I've got other rooks to cull.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Some of the trade suggestions in this thread

Matthew White, honestly. Keep them coming.

 

[JRyan23]

SHould I consider Matera? Any one else looking at him

 

[rocker_oz33]

Pretty happy with my defence now.
Adams doc laird Lloyd otten Newman.
Set until byes IMO.

Noice Butt..........,man.

 

[Quazza]

Roughies BE is exactly the same as his Average..... makes for some interesting decisions

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Is Brandon Mateara breaking out or has he just got lucky?

 

[JRyan23]

Is Brandon Mateara breaking out or has he just got lucky?

That's what I want to know. He is expected to go up over 120k in 2 weeks

 

[Keg on legs]

No trades for me.

Need a lot more mooing from my cows yet. Get busy punks!

 

[PoopingHindi]

Some of the trade suggestions in this thread

Matthew White, honestly. Keep them coming.

Trolloar to Mundy this week. lock it in

 

[reload141]

What do Melbourne fans think Spencer will average?

 

[rocker_oz33]

If Spencer had dpp.
Ruff to him.

 

[Faz 2000]

Is Brandon Mateara breaking out or has he just got lucky?

You should bring him in and find out.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Roughies BE is exactly the same as his Average..... makes for some interesting decisions

Interesting.
Could always wait a week wont drop to much if he stinks it up again.

 

[Hairy Lager]

****!!! $900 off
Pickett > Spencer
FMSCL

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

I've lost patience with Roughy. I only see him averaging ~75, so I'm thinking of trading him to Spencer via Nank back to the forward line. I think Spender can average 90 and give me a net gain of around 15ppr.

That gives me $168,600 that I'd like to use for an upgrade somewhere, but the only obvious one that I can afford is Tuohy to Doc. A couple of issues with that: 1. I've already got Simpson and Marchbank, so this will give me 3 Carlton players in DEF (though Marchbank hopefully becomes Shaw before Blues Round 11 bye); and, 2. I started with Tuohy hoping that he'd be a keeper and he hasn't actually been terrible, maybe he'll get better?

Other options are Treloar to Bont/Dusty/Pendles, but Treloar has been serviceable and I still think he'll be a keeper... Steele to Macrae?

Thoughts?

 

[vanders]

The only non playing rookies I have are Eddy and Hibberd. Hannan Stewart and Pickett aren't making me much money but if I use 1 trade this week to get a rookie on the bubble in I'm left with 24 trades. As long as the spud rookies are playing this week I'll keep them and hope they put up a decent score.

If Pickett doesn't pull his finger out I'll trade him to Fisher next week.

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

What do Melbourne fans think Spencer will average?

See above, I reckon 90ish.

 

[rocker_oz33]

****!!! $900 off
Pickett > Spencer
FMSCL

Wait a week.
Picktruck will work hard to make that hard earned for you.

Edit fuuuu shame Spencer does have fuuuu DPP.

 

[PoopingHindi]

I've lost patience with Roughy. I only see him averaging ~75, so I'm thinking of trading him to Spencer via Nank back to the forward line. I think Spender can average 90 and give me a net gain of around 15ppr.

That gives me $168,600 that I'd like to use for an upgrade somewhere, but the only obvious one that I can afford is Tuohy to Doc. A couple of issues with that: 1. I've already got Simpson and Marchbank, so this will give me 3 Carlton players in DEF (though Marchbank hopefully becomes Shaw before Blues Round 11 bye); and, 2. I started with Tuohy hoping that he'd be a keeper and he hasn't actually been terrible, maybe he'll get better?

Other options are Treloar to Bont/Dusty/Pendles, but Treloar has been serviceable and I still think he'll be a keeper... Steele to Macrae?

Thoughts?

i have a radical idea.
you could always keep the cash and use it on a genuine upgrade when the opportunity arises.

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

i have a radical idea.
you could always keep the cash and use it on a genuine upgrade when the opportunity arises.

Lol, as if! That's just crazy talk, I want filthy points NOW!

 

[jellyfish]

Anyone watch balics game... the 37 first round is throwing me off only because i watched fishers game and he was very good with his pressure etc.. is it bad that im thinking about going early one week on fisher and missing balic?
Someone talk me out of it

 

[Deliverance]

Duck firmly believes that Parsons will get off.

Duck is also deranged

Duck also thought it was OK to boof one of his best mates missus.

It looked bad, but Hodge wasn't injured, but still surely a week for a hit like that.

Intentional, medium/low impact, headshot. So minimum one week, maxim 3 weeks.