Player X v Y v Z

[Suma Magic]

Bonner v Christensen

Would also appreciate thoughts for each dot point. Cheers.

Bonner

• injury risk?
• JS 7/10
• Expected average 75

Christensen

• injury risk - high
• JS - 8/10
• Expected average 80

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Bonner v Christensen

Would also appreciate thoughts for each dot point. Cheers.

Bonner

• injury risk?
• JS 7/10
• Expected average 75

Christensen

• injury risk - high
• JS - 8/10
• Expected average 80

Bonner with ease
JS 9/10
expected ave 75-80

Christensen. injury - medium
JS 10/10
Ave 70-80

 

[Suma Magic]

Bonner with ease
JS 9/10
expected ave 75-80

Christensen. injury - medium
JS 10/10
Ave 70-80

I'm making the swap based on your advice.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

LDU + P McCartin

v

JOM + Venables

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

LDU + P McCartin

v

JOM + Venables

The latter.

Can't trust LDU and Fatty McFartin

 

[Keg on legs]

Danger & Oliver
V
Kelly & Crouch

Jelly and crouch

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

The latter.

Can't trust LDU and Fatty McFartin

means I have to field 2 of ZGL/Fritsch/Venables/Ryan

 

[DraftPunk]

langdon
venables
garlett
waterman

What's your reasoning for the order?

I would have thought Garlett has the best JS of the lot. Venables didn't strike me as much of a scorer from what I saw in JLT.

 

[Keg on legs]

Pick a combo

Hibberd / savage

Mclean / trackies

Min left over cash $68k

Max left over cash $170k

 

[Flandersss]

Jelly and crouch

Because Danger & Oliver might be underdone?

 

[Flandersss]

Pick a combo

Hibberd / savage

Mclean / trackies

Min left over cash $68k

Max left over cash $170k

Piggerd & McLean

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

What's your reasoning for the order?

I would have thought Garlett has the best JS of the lot. Venables didn't strike me as much of a scorer from what I saw in JLT.

Langdon IMO has the best JS. Pressure forward and spots opened up due to SJ and Dev leaving.

Garlett is another Pickett IMO, but probably slightly fitter than Pickett was.
Waterman will be dropped when JJK comes back

Venables is a first round pick. Hasnt played for a while. scoring may be low to start with, but he can pump out a couple of 75s/80s

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Pick a combo

Hibberd / savage

Mclean / trackies

Min left over cash $68k

Max left over cash $170k

hibberd
McLean

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Pick 2 of

ZGL/Venables/Garlett

 

[Flandersss]

Pick 2 of

ZGL/Venables/Garlett

ZGL & Garlett

 

[DraftPunk]

Langdon IMO has the best JS. Pressure forward and spots opened up due to SJ and Dev leaving.

Garlett is another Pickett IMO, but probably slightly fitter than Pickett was.
Waterman will be dropped when JJK comes back

Venables is a first round pick. Hasnt played for a while. scoring may be low to start with, but he can pump out a couple of 75s/80s

Yeah fair call, Langdon prob a better chance to get on the end of a few in a better side too so might go with him.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Pick 2 of

ZGL/Venables/Garlett

ZGL tackles ....Venables midfield minutes ....Garlett Nah!

 

[Keg on legs]

ZGL tackles ....Venables midfield minutes ....Garlett Nah!

+1

 

[atlas1]

Pick 2 of

ZGL/Venables/Garlett

I have all 3

 

[Keg on legs]

hibberd
McLean

Bob Cobb

Thoughts why piggy over sav guys?

 

[Flandersss]

Bob Cobb

Thoughts why piggy over sav guys?

I just don’t get the Sav love tbh. He’ll get tagged if he kills it. Never averaged above 87. I don’t think Joey impacted like some are making out on here. Main distributor out of defence means easier to shut down IMO

 

[Keg on legs]

I just don’t get the Sav love tbh. He’ll get tagged if he kills it. Never averaged above 87. I don’t think Joey impacted like some are making out on here. Main distributor out of defence means easier to shut down IMO

Thats my only worry with him. How we will handle any attention? Maybe not too well. But geez he has been scoring delightfully in the jlt


Splendidly in fact

 

[Old Stuckup]

Byrne vs C Ellis?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Byrne vs C Ellis?

byrne for js

 

[_M_16_]

My final X vs Y dilemmas for the year

McGovern vs Lloyd?
and
Matt Crouch vs Cripps?

Cheers