Autopsy Roast & Toast - Round 2 v Collingwood & changes for GWS Rd 3

[dean33]

I wouldn't mind Markov, Butler, George getting another game or two. Especially is Caddy is still unavailable


OUT: Jack - injury.
Omitted: Short, Weller, Ellis

IN: Garthwaite, Houli, Balta, Moore


Houli Astbury Garthwaite
Broad Grimes Vlastuin
Mcintosh Cotchin Edwards
Higgins Moore Rioli
Butler Lynch George
Nankervis Martin Prestia
Balta Markov Graham Lambert


edit: Balta to backline, CCJ as 2nd ruck if Grimes suspended

I like your ins but we’re not dropping short. Markov would be the other to get dropped.

 

[Marcel Proust]

I like your ins but we’re not dropping short. Markov would be the other to get dropped.

Short defensive abilities are general woeful.
Without Rance he has been and will continue to be exploited

Markov should get 3-4 games before giving up on him - he is always removed after a small sample size

who was playing on DeGoey btw?

 

[Charlie Pannam]

Why is Weller in the team and Bolton is not

Perceived lack of defensive pressure - he still lacked a bit in that area on Thursday arvo I thought a few average tackling attempts. But on the flip side has real attacking flare and is working a lot harder in the midfield role.

Weller - nah let’s just shelve that idea now. Has a crack but a very limited player

 

[Marcel Proust]

Perceived lack of defensive pressure - he still lacked a bit in that area on Thursday arvo I thought a few average tackling attempts. But on the flip side has real attacking flare and is working a lot harder in the midfield role.

Weller - nah let’s just shelve that idea now. Has a crack but a very limited player

Maybe Jayden Short should be teaching Bolton how to tackle at training

 

[Charlie Pannam]

Maybe Jayden Short should be teaching Bolton how to tackle at training

Towna to be tackling coach

 

[clark1980]

2 definite outs - jack and Grimes. garthwaite will probably come in for Grimes. jacks replacement is the interesting one. balta to help out our ruck, Moore as a straight replacement or do we prefer the 1 tall forward set up and bring in another small. Weller and butler could be in a little trouble, depending on how many changes they want to make.

 

[Rezza Tiger]

Backs to the wall

Best

Will feel so much better than a flawless season if we can turn it around

 

[Marcel Proust]

Backs to the wall

Best

Will feel so much better than a flawless season if we can turn it around

the kids will get a lot of development-games too

 

[dean33]

Short defensive abilities are general woeful.
Without Rance he has been and will continue to be exploited

Markov should get 3-4 games before giving up on him - he is always removed after a small sample size

who was playing on DeGoey btw?

Broad spent most of the night on de gooey with grimes taking Elliot. Nah short is a weapon from defence, need his run, he is also very good offensively as testified with his 2 goals on Thursday night.

 

[joelsyt]

It’ll be interesting to see who steps up into those giant leadership holes with Jack and Rance out. Saw signs from Nankervis, Grimes and Lynch that they were prepared to do that, which was good to see at least. Need some of our kids though to also take that step.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

legit cant see us winning a game till the hawforn match

We won't beat whoreforn.

 

[Hoos]

We won't beat whoreforn.

They're not much.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

dusty should be dragging us over the line to win games instead hes coasting

Become vanilla, was at his best when he was rogue threatening to kill campaigners with chopsticks

 

[TJTIGER]

Why is Weller in the team and Bolton is not

As far as I can tell Shai needs to get in touch with his inner Mongrel, run both ways & tackle with aggression........Just from my brief observations since we drafted him (I'm a big fan of his potential & skills)....

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

They're not much.

I know , we wont beat them.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Season is ova guys.. we will always have 17

You #ECO ?

 

[Sir_Loin]

Short defensive abilities are general woeful.
Without Rance he has been and will continue to be exploited

Markov should get 3-4 games before giving up on him - he is always removed after a small sample size

who was playing on DeGoey btw?

You’d think Short would have worked on this defensive skills in the preseason. Love his offensive game but we can’t afford for him to be running around the backline as unaccountable as he has been. He needs to sort it out ASAP

 

[Hoos]

You’d think Short would have worked on this defensive skills in the preseason. Love his offensive game but we can’t afford for him to be running around the backline as unaccountable as he has been. He needs to sort it out ASAP

Play him on a forward flank or on a wing. Especially when Houli comes back.

 

[Sir_Loin]

Play him on a forward flank or on a wing. Especially when Houli comes back.

Mate unfortunately you can’t hide in this side if you don’t put defensive pressure on. A big part of our problem against the pies was our inability to put defensive pressure on up the field. He’d be found wanting up the field as much as behind the ball IMO, unless he pulls his finger out. From what I’ve seen of him he’s pretty soft at going hard at the contest, it’d take a big turnaround for him to get better at that side of the game.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Play him on a forward flank or on a wing. Especially when Houli comes back.

Not the worst idea
Kicked 2 on the weekend
Debuted as a forward
If Houli comes back I wouldn’t mind short going forward

Would be better then butler straight away

All providing bachar is back

 

[parmy2balmey]

Our midfield problem

is that prestia?

 

[SA_Tiger11]

Love the tiges. We will be right. Backs against the wall, everyone’s written us off. Love it.

 

[BruceTempany14]

Lol why not George?
I don’t get too fussed about who should come in and go out but I wouldn’t lose any sleep if he got the arse.

He’s gotta go . Sorry , Bolton needs to have 10 plus games in a row to show his worth , otherwise at the end of year we will get bobcus for him . Then you watch , he will go somewhere else and be a superstar !!!!!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Sir_Loin]

I’d bring in Jack Ross. We need more grunt with Dusty out of form and playing forward more. He’s shown enough IMO to get a call up.

 

[parmy2balmey]

the kids will get a lot of development-games too

that’s a huge assumption
my bet is dimma tries to hang on to the season by playing retreads