Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[gutsroy]

I'm tossing up Daniel too. Just think Port win more games than the Doggies which generally means more points.

Johannisen eyeing rd 4 return fwiw, I think.
Can't comment on potential impact on role for Daniel, others might be able to.

 

[Girthquake]

Need help with choosing one of these options for trades and I have 154k ITB:

Gibbons / Atkins > LDU / Cousins
Walsh / Butters > Liba

Already burnt two trades last week so doing no trades is also an option.
Is liba a must have and worth it over some value rookies or is getting in a LDU or Cousins more important?

post your team, you dont need to many any of those trades tho, gibbons aitkens walsh and butters will all make money

 

[RichoTheGreat1]

If I bring in Rocky its this week not sure I can go in with all 3 of Rocky Crouch and Sheed playing with fire.

Rocky needs to do this for another 6 weeks before I consider.

If rocky does this for 6 more weeks he’ll be 600k + and yeah you can still get him in but you’ll burn at least 2 trades doing so when you can burn one now and have a better team.

He’s a different player to last year, wines coming back won’t change his scoring this year, only injury will.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Heavily contemplating.

Heeney to Kelly
Goldy to Gawn (can wait a week and save 10-20k)

 

[brandoncam01]

post your team, you dont need to many any of those trades tho, gibbons aitkens walsh and butters will all make money

2 trades made last week with 154.5k ITB



EDIT: New to this site and thought I'd repost my initial post as well

Gibbons / Atkins > LDU / Cousins
Walsh / Butters > Liba

Already burnt two trades last week so doing no trades is also an option.
Is liba a must have and worth it over some value rookies or is getting in a LDU or Cousins more important?

 

[RichoTheGreat1]

Carlton

Boak has been faulting it up the last 10 years in SC. What makes you think he will suddenly outscore Heeney over the season after 2 games?

Heeney still very likely to end up in the top 6 scorers unless Horse somehow finds enough excuses to stick him in the forward line for 20 more games. On pure ability Heeney is a top 15 player in the comp and available as a forward, you need to give him more than 2 weeks.

Carlton this week to, could kick a few and notch up the ton.

Don’t know why silly horse plays him forward. Midfield pressure and run is what scores goals not big / electric forwards anymore. When your team has run and carry then they’ll kick a lot of goals. Leaving Henry up forward when swans midfield is getting dominated is just a waste of key talent. He has more chance of kicking goals as a mid, not key forward

 

[Gresham2King]

New to SuperCoach this year. Thinking maybe McGrath > Moore seems like a good choice, but any thoughts would be much appreciated

 

[Girthquake]

2 trades made last week with 154.5k ITB

View attachment 646984

EDIT: New to this site and thought I'd repost my initial post as well

Gibbons / Atkins > LDU / Cousins
Walsh / Butters > Liba

Already burnt two trades last week so doing no trades is also an option.
Is liba a must have and worth it over some value rookies or is getting in a LDU or Cousins more important?

looks pretty solid, not a fan of the zorko pick but damage is done there haha, i mean you could go gibbons to LDU but i think norf have a few mids to still come in, Cousins could work but gibbons not scoring bad enough to give him the boot IMO

 

[rocker_oz33]

Daniel doing the kick ins is a big plus.

Hes a shithouse full back. ....

 

[WaynesWorld19]

What role might that be? I thought he was playing the same role as the last few years...

I thought the commentators said last week he was playing Half Forwrd ? .....or was it wing ?

 

[Marlowe]

Carlton


Carlton this week to, could kick a few and notch up the ton.

Don’t know why silly horse plays him forward. Midfield pressure and run is what scores goals not big / electric forwards anymore. When your team has run and carry then they’ll kick a lot of goals. Leaving Henry up forward when swans midfield is getting dominated is just a waste of key talent. He has more chance of kicking goals as a mid, not key forward

Well he is playing forward so far this season because he's injured and being rested a bit.

The optimist in me wonders if, once healthy, he'll explode through the middle.

The realist in me says Horse is a campaigner and won't play kids in the midfield, and playing one of his most talented players through an injury will only cause strife (for the team, the player, and Supercoach).

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Is heeney this years billings? Giving me anxiety thinking about last years memories. #prayforisaac

 

[brandoncam01]

looks pretty solid, not a fan of the zorko pick but damage is done there haha, i mean you could go gibbons to LDU but i think norf have a few mids to still come in, Cousins could work but gibbons not scoring bad enough to give him the boot IMO

Thanks man. Yeah disappointed by my Zorko pick, wanted a POD but bit me in the ass. Guess I'm gonna hold my trades and ride out Zorko and the rookies I have. Thank you again.

 

[Girthquake]

Well he is playing forward so far this season because he's injured and being rested a bit.

The optimist in me wonders if, once healthy, he'll explode through the middle.

The realist in me says Horse is a campaigner and won't play kids in the midfield, and playing one of his most talented players through an injury will only cause strife (for the team, the player, and Supercoach).

he played papley in the middle on the weekend who is the same age , i am hoping heeney gets thrown in the guts when fit but i am 50/50 on keeping him

Thanks man. Yeah disappointed by my Zorko pick, wanted a POD but bit me in the ass. Guess I'm gonna hold my trades and ride out Zorko and the rookies I have. Thank you again.

no probs anytime

 

[Bollox]

Please look up Neale history one of the most consistent sc scorers in past 5 seasons

*Last 4 years.
He's average 109.5 over that period, not too shabby.

IMO Neale should easily have had 150+, he was the spearhead for us in that last Qtr that secured the win.

Cut the cheerleading. Noone doubts how good he is.

The issue, and its a very important one for many of us, is that he has gone from being a #2 mid behind fyfe, to a #1 mid who will attract more attention the better he is going.
Same question Sloane faced.
Same issue we saw in Zorko.
Same issue we see in many others over a long long time.

Neale is now due for that attention.

Not all guys cope well with it.

We dont need to hear how good they are when they are scoring 140's early. We know how good they are. But there are 20 more rounds to go and Neale will now get more attention than ever.

I want to know (from best guesses) if i might be buying another Sloane.

 

[XPISTO]

View attachment 646893

Where is this image from?

 

[CrozaN]

FU bro!

sorry.....still got Greene on my mind!

Hahaha man joking bro, but srsly cmon why list a sick player? basically ur 1 man down and can cause extra damage potentially.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I thought the commentators said last week he was playing Half Forwrd ? .....or was it wing ?

WTF.

Simmo playing forward..?
Why?

If greene wasn't such a kent - simmo would be thrown out of the old poeples village.

 

[TravisJohnstone]

Love it when I have Lloyd and walk out the room for a bit to do something and hear BT hit you with the 'Llllloooyyydddd' from the TV and you're just like 'yes! another +5'

 

[Test Tickle]

So talk in the Richmond thread is that Dusty may have a sprained ACL or bone bruising from a JLT game.
They are relating it to Cotchins knee injury in 2013 which took a few months to come good.

That's good enough for me to trade Dusty OUT!

 

[WaynesWorld19]

WTF.

Simmo playing forward..?
Why?

If greene wasn't such a kent - simmo would be thrown out of the old poeples village.

They definitely said Simmo was playing a different role .....and it wasn't in the DEF 50 .....maybe a 1 week thing ?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Kents stop trading in Neale and TKelly they are massive spuds .

 

[Riviat]

 

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

2 trades made last week with 154.5k ITB

View attachment 646984

EDIT: New to this site and thought I'd repost my initial post as well

Gibbons / Atkins > LDU / Cousins
Walsh / Butters > Liba

Already burnt two trades last week so doing no trades is also an option.
Is liba a must have and worth it over some value rookies or is getting in a LDU or Cousins more important?

I don't have or need any advice (well I mean if you're offering I'll take it). I'm just posting cos I thought you took a screenshot of my team. Legit only 2 premos different lol.

 

[vast]

So talk in the Richmond thread is that Dusty may have a sprained ACL or bone bruising from a JLT game.
They are relating it to Cotchins knee injury in 2013 which took a few months to come good.

That's good enough for me to trade Dusty OUT!

still gets 1 more week for me. Even if he scores 50 only drops 30k. Rookies are the priority this week. Im not gonna trade of speculation.