What is your ex-GWS player success ratio?

[Mofra]

If there's something GWS do well it's draft players then trade them away a few years later (thanks crazy Sossy).

Here is the best 22 of past GWS players:

FB: Sam Frost (Melb), Lachie Plowman (Carl), Jack Hombsch (PA)
HB: Kristian Jaksch (Carl), Caleb Marchbank (Carl), Tom Bugg (Melb)
C: Jack Steele (STK), Taylor Adams (Coll), Anthony Miles (Rich)
HF: Will Hoskin-Elliott (Coll), Tom Boyd (WB), Jono O’Rourke (Haw)
FF: Liam Sumner (Carl) Josh Bruce (STK), Cam McCarthy (Fre)
Foll: Andrew Phillips (Carl), Adam Treloar (Coll), Dom Tyson (Melb)
I/C: Jacob Townsend (Rich), Jonathan Giles (WCE), Jarrod Pickett (Carl), Curtly Hampton (Adel)

Quickly, what is your GWS success ratio? It's simple - take the number of former GWS players on your list, and divide it by the number of premierships ex-GWS players won for your club.

(Note: Carlton you can use the 6 players above, or all nine you're drafted in over the years)

I'll start: Bulldogs - 100% (Tom Boyd)

 

[Geelong Dynasty]

*then

 

[HAPPY BUDDHA]

Did Izzy Folau even play in a win?

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Sorry Mof, but I must have missed Sam Darley in the 2016 premiership photo.

 

[Mofra]

Sorry Mof, but I must have missed Sam Darley in the 2016 premiership photo.

Does he even count? Was virtually a delist and relist.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Will Setterfield will be the best GWS-Exer out of the lot and the OP left him out ?

 

[NetworkNerd]

Will Setterfield will be the best GWS-Exer out of the lot and the OP left him out ?

Definitely a miss from the OP. Much better than Hampton. Replace O'Rourke on half forward flank

 

[NetworkNerd]

Definitely a miss from the OP. Much better than Hampton. Replace O'Rourke on half forward flank

Missed Shiel and Scully too.

Likely just a usual Mofra troll rather than anything serious

 

[SuperSic]

The suns really don’t exist

 

[vjknight]

Jamie Elliott didn't get a guernsey Mofra ?

.Elliott was acquired by Collingwood at the end of 2011 in a deal with Greater Western Sydney (GWS) whereby GWS could pre-list players and on-trade to other clubs.

 

[the avoca drover]

The Tiggers had Jacob Townsend and we were lucky enough to miss out on that clanger king Adam Treloar. Wouldn't have won the flag with that turnip in the side.
Mofra can you do the maths please?

 

[Mofra]

Jamie Elliott didn't get a guernsey Mofra ?

He never played for them so I doubt he counts. I took the best 22 from this article:

Best 22 of former GWS players at new clubs

Gee the Giants would have had incredible depth! How would this team fare in a match?

www.zerohanger.com

 

[Mofra]

Missed Shiel and Scully too.

Likely just a usual Mofra troll rather than anything serious

Definitely a miss from the OP. Much better than Hampton. Replace O'Rourke on half forward flank

Will Setterfield will be the best GWS-Exer out of the lot and the OP left him out ?

How many premierships do they have?

You're just making your respective ratios worse. I try to help you out...

 

[Crabapplepittard]

Shithouse. Lost Phil Davis. Got curtly *en Hampton.

 

[Corpuscles]

Does it count DOUBLE if Swans have donated a few Coke heads to the giaaaants?

Mummy is still there (their) MVP!

 

[Mofra]

Does it count DOUBLE if Swans have donated a few Coke heads to the giaaaants?

Mummy is still there MVP!

Just to help you out, I'll allow you to list Lance Franklin as everyone thought he was going to GWS until you pinched him

 

[Corpuscles]

Just to help you out, I'll allow you to list Lance Franklin as everyone thought he was going to GWS until you pinched him

Thanks muchly!

We always get the BEST! you can all share the little fishies!

But hey we are FAIR, we allowed J Dunkley to be taken. SUPERSTAR in the making!

Good luck to your team in the finals.


I expect an entry into the TEX pitcha thread should you beat the Crowalots!

 

[crazywildhorse]

If there's something GWS do well it's draft players then trade them away a few years later (thanks crazy Sossy).

Here is the best 22 of past GWS players:

FB: Sam Frost (Melb), Lachie Plowman (Carl), Jack Hombsch (PA)
HB: Kristian Jaksch (Carl), Caleb Marchbank (Carl), Tom Bugg (Melb)
C: Jack Steele (STK), Taylor Adams (Coll), Anthony Miles (Rich)
HF: Will Hoskin-Elliott (Coll), Tom Boyd (WB), Jono O’Rourke (Haw)
FF: Liam Sumner (Carl) Josh Bruce (STK), Cam McCarthy (Fre)
Foll: Andrew Phillips (Carl), Adam Treloar (Coll), Dom Tyson (Melb)
I/C: Jacob Townsend (Rich), Jonathan Giles (WCE), Jarrod Pickett (Carl), Curtly Hampton (Adel)

Quickly, what is your GWS success ratio? It's simple - take the number of former GWS players on your list, and divide it by the number of premierships ex-GWS players won for your club.

(Note: Carlton you can use the 6 players above, or all nine you're drafted in over the years)

I'll start: Bulldogs - 100% (Tom Boyd)

Ironically, I know a guy in Germany called Sossy, he grows organic potatoes

 

[Elmer_Judd]

The Tiggers had Jacob Townsend and we were lucky enough to miss out on that clanger king Adam Treloar. Wouldn't have won the flag with that turnip in the side.
Mofra can you do the maths please?

Jacob Townsend is the biggest cameo/one hit wonder player since the great Ted Hopkins ...

 

[the avoca drover]

Jacob Townsend is the biggest cameo/one hit wonder player since the great Ted Hopkins ...

Probably, but he is Leeton’s favourite son.
It makes me wonder, whose playing career would you prefer? Lids, who won’t ever play in a flag side, or Towno?

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Probably, but he is Leeton’s favourite son.
It makes me wonder, whose playing career would you prefer? Lids, who won’t ever play in a flag side, or Towno?

Lids definitely.

That is like saying who had the better career, Tony Lockett or Brad Pearce ???

 

[the avoca drover]

Lids definitely.

That is like saying who had the better career, Tony Lockett or Brad Pearce ???

Very true.
Or Mario Bortolotto and Sam Newman.
You hear so many players say that they play to win a flag. I wonder what they would really choose. 250 games on good money and no flags or 30 games on base money and a flag?

 

[FurTheWin]

Will be 100% when Cameron makes his move to the Cats next year

 

[Mofra]

Will be 100% when Cameron makes his move to the Cats next year

Yeah, good call. Leon Cameron would be an upgrade on Chris.

 

[Bay Giant]

Yeah, good call. Leon Cameron would be an upgrade on Chris.

Ebola is an upgrade on Lolly Leon Cameron.