Bluemour Melting Pot XX - Snark Free Zone

[HBF]

Nothing.

So more than usual eh.

 

[Malifice]

How do the newbies slot in?

I think Butler becomes Eddie's replacement in the long term (and in the short term, he is injury cover for Eddie/Paps/Martin/Cunners).

Eddie Charlie Papley
Martin McKay McGovern

Cunners starts on Bench for mid/forward rotations.

Martin through the midfield thanks.

 

[MrJimmy]

We're talking about the same Phillips here right? Tall guy? Orange hair? Huge arms and skinny legs? Takes a grab occasionally and is a decent tap ruck but doesn't get on the park too much and has minimal effect around the ground? A trade involving that guy, a quality KPF and a small forward that everyone would slot in their best 22? Not sure Phillips has the currency needed for that...

 

[HBF]

Papley worth something between 15 and 20
Martin worth between 22 and 30


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Cheers BT

 

[ShanDog]

View attachment 757333

You could maybe articulate why you think what I said is worthy of a facepalm instead. That's pretty ****ing rude to be honest.

 

[DIG]

Hearing two first rounders for Phillips.

 

[ShanDog]

Hearing two first rounders for Phillips.

Apparently he's a star.

 

[Brutalitops]

Whilst posters are giving their 2 cents on liking of posts, I’ll give mine on something.

Can everyone stop quoting ITK posters, begging for news. Stop replying to their posts, only to ask them for more.

If they didn’t give more information in the post they posted 5 minutes ago, they most likely don’t have any.

It’s embarrising

Even more embarrassing is when you go to the DT&FA board and you see Carlton supporters posting it as gospel. "Our ITKs said so, so its a done deal", "Barrass said this", "EB said that", "just wait till EP/carlton09/MS3 posted comes true. Youll see".

Its called tact. Try employing some.

 

[HBF]

I agree with you, but will the Swans consider such a the trade? I'd drop the change.

Beat me to it.
Wonder if Sydney would take 9 and Macreadie

 

[bigblueboy]

Helping Kelly get out of Gtown - 9 and 41 for 14 and 24
Papley - 14
Martin - 24

 

[Opine]

Even more embarrassing is when you go to the DT&FA board and you see Carlton supporters posting it as gospel. "Our ITKs said so, so its a done deal", "Barrass said this", "EB said that", "just wait till EP/carlton09/MS3 posted comes true. Youll see".

Its called tact. Try employing some.

My son says to me that b70, and or 10c, said so; almost daily.

 

[GT619]

You're just saying that coz you put out the barass signal and he answered.

Well it’s part of my job.makes me feel important

 

[MrJimmy]

You could maybe articulate why you think what I said is worthy of a facepalm instead. That's pretty ******* rude to be honest.

sorry ShanDog didn't mean to come off rude. In fact I agree with everything you said... in theory. You might just want to go back and take another look at the OP is all...

 

[Brutalitops]

My son says to me that b70, and or 10c, said so; almost daily.

How olds your son though?

 

[resolute_blue]

If Phillips does move on, then Casboult stays and two years are offered up by the CFC.
Fair is fair.

More than happy for Casboult to finish his career at our club. He deserves it and so do we.

Agree, this would be a good result. I’d much prefer Levi on the list than Phillips if it was one or the other so I really hope it pans out this way.

Levi can play forward, ruck, and proven more than serviceable down back. Also, Phillips way more injury prone than Levi.

Regardless of Phillips geez I hope Levi stays...

 

[Zlatan]

Helping Kelly get out of Gtown - 9 and 41 for 14 and 24
Papley - 14
Martin - 24

If I’m Sydney, knowing we had 9 and traded it away for 14, I’d tell us to hit the road.

9 + steak knives for Papley
2020 2nd rounder for Martin

Both clubs will try to extract the maximum they can from us until deadline day.

From now on, the minute anyone asks for any of our players, the price should be 3 1st rounders. Whether it’s Cripps or Polson makes no difference.

 

[Opine]

How olds your son though?

In his 20's; but he loves b70

 

[ShanDog]

sorry ShanDog didn't mean to come off rude. In fact I agree with everything you said... in theory. You might just want to go back and take another look at the OP is all...

Holy crap have I totally missed the sarcasm of the suggestion??

 

[reubsblues]

Helping Kelly get out of Gtown - 9 and 41 for 14 and 24
Papley - 14
Martin - 24

If only it was that simple, it will take the whole 2 wks to get to that exact trade

 

[Juddernaut08]

In his 20's; but he loves b70

LOL

 

[Mr_Plow]

If I’m Sydney, knowing we had 9 and traded it away for 14, I’d tell us to hit the road.

9 + steak knives for Papley
2020 2nd rounder for Martin

Both clubs will try to extract the maximum they can from us until deadline day.

From now on, the minute anyone asks for any of our players, the price should be 3 1st rounders. Whether it’s Cripps or Polson makes no difference.

I'm willing to relax Polson's value to 2 first rounders.

Otherwise, agree.

 

[Brutalitops]

In his 20's; but he loves b70

Still, its one thing to say that to you in person (?). Its another entirely to be plastering their names on foreign boards. Whats posted on the Carlton board should stay on the Carlton board. Post the bluemours, fine. But leave their names out of it cause you come across as an absolute spanner.

 

[bigblueboy]

If I’m Sydney, knowing we had 9 and traded it away for 14, I’d tell us to hit the road.

9 + steak knives for Papley
2020 2nd rounder for Martin

Both clubs will try to extract the maximum they can from us until deadline day.

From now on, the minute anyone asks for any of our players, the price should be 3 1st rounders. Whether it’s Cripps or Polson makes no difference.

Exactly why we need to make it clear to sydney that on pick 9 is on the table for all to see. Get in first or potentially miss out on the best pick outcome ... and Daniher.

 

[ShanDog]

Man, I thought you were all jerks.

Turns out I'm just an idiot.







Inb4 situation normal

 

[MrJimmy]

Holy crap have I totally missed the sarcasm of the suggestion??

Just a little..... But i blame the trade period. It tends to mess with ones sense of reality. I should know, I lost my mind years ago.