Votes

[windyhill]

3. J.Johnno, 4 qtr effort
2. Nash
1. McPhee

 

[Longy413]

The three Jason's.

3. Johnson
2. Winderlich
1. Nash

McVeigh really close.

 

[topdon]

3. Jason Winderlich
2. Jason Johnson
1. Jay Nash

EDIT: McPhee was shithouse for 3 qtrs. Downhill skiier!

 

[Bomber Bears]

to be fair wasnt the whole side shithouse for 3 quarters?

 

[topdon]

But to be fair, McPhee plays in the backline. That requires manning up on your opponent and not running forward of the ball at every opportunity!

 

[Astute Observer]

to be fair wasnt the whole side shithouse for 3 quarters?

3. Ports Ruckmen
2. Their Midfield
1. Their Small Forwards

Each of which we lack any quality........!!!

 

[Lovett Lover 13]

you couldn't leave nash out of the votes played well he impressed

 

[Big John]

Hard to give votes for best on, could cominate a few for worst on though.

2 players i'll mention are Nash and Laycock. Nash was good, seems to be getting fitter and thought it was Laycock's best game for a while, although it might just seem that way caus Hille was so bad.

 

[tommo_bombers]

3. J. Johnson!!!
2. nash
1. winders

really upset and didn't really watch most of third quarter.

but nash looked real good same with Johno

no one can really say mcphee sucked since he kicked more then lucas and lloyd.


disappointing but 31 points isn't all that bad.

no excuses we should not have been down by 75 points by port adelaides quality

 

[DarthAnnihl8or]

3 - Nash
2 - Winders (GREAT to see him lift this year, just needs to back himself in around 50)
1 - JJ

Mentions to Laycock, McPhee and McVeigh.

Nobody else would get a pass mark, even Fletch. Maybe Jobe but only just.

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

1. McVeigh
2. Nash
3. Watson

 

[wazzabp]

The three Jason's.

3. Johnson
2. Winderlich
1. Nash

McVeigh really close.

Agreed.

 

[EssendonPride]

3 - Nash
2 - Winders (GREAT to see him lift this year, just needs to back himself in around 50)
1 - JJ

Mentions to Laycock, McPhee and McVeigh.

Nobody else would get a pass mark, even Fletch. Maybe Jobe but only just.

Watson? I only heard it on the radio but sounded as if he was pretty much everywhere. Should at least get a pass.

As for everyone else, well yeah

 

[danzan22]

2. Nashy - Good disposal all night, His oponent played well which is a downer.
2. Winders - ran hard alll night
1. JJ - Poor first qtr imo but ade up for it
1. Watson - brilliant last qtr which got us some respect back
No one really deserved 3 votes imo.

 

[DarthAnnihl8or]

Watson? I only heard it on the radio but sounded as if he was pretty much everywhere. Should at least get a pass.

As for everyone else, well yeah

Too many mistakes from Jobe when the pressure was on. Miss kicks and handballs. Probably get a 5.5-6 out of 10 as a result of a good last quarter.

 

[topdon]

Could have easily lost by 100, lost by 31. If you 'have' to lose, i would take that. We saved ourselves at least 6 percentage points, and most importantly kept Port, the Western Bulldogs, and the Kangaroos below us (all on 28). Swans will jump ahead of us if they best Collingwood next weekend.

Big game against the Dees coming up.

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

I thought Laycock showed some good signs.

 

[Longy413]

If the Swans get up, lets hope they do enough to push the Pies below us.

 

[keepzitreal]

3- Winderlich
2 - Watson
1 - Laycock

- Hille was piss poor tonight! He just needs to focus on the ball at the stoppages. His too reactive and not proactive

- We need more players in the team that will carry the ball. Pev, Heff, JJ and Bolton shoud not all be in the team at the same time.

- Didn't have enough players willing to run and carry and open up the game. In each of our losses, Carlton, Collingwood, Hawthorn, North and Port have all run us off our feet. Hope we can get Lovett, NLM, Dempsey, Stanton and Jetta all into the team soon

 

[Bomber32]

3. Winderlich
2. Nash
1. Laycock

 

[DonMania#5]

Pretty hard to give votes, only a few people deserve votes.

3. Winderlich - Gave us run throughout the whole game even when we were getting smashed.
2. JJ - Was hard at it all night, looks like he is getting some form back
1. Nash - Gave us run off half-back and had great disposal unlike a few others.

Apologies to Mcphee, Watson and Mcveigh.

 

[Crave]

I thought Laycock showed some good signs.

Yeah, he instilled my belief that he's not up to playing against opposition ruckmen at senior level.

 

[Crave]

3 - McPhee
2 - Peverill
1 - Watson

 

[Crave]

Too many mistakes from Jobe when the pressure was on. Miss kicks and handballs. Probably get a 5.5-6 out of 10 as a result of a good last quarter.

When he had it, his vision was as trustworthy as ever. He'd get a 7 from me.

 

[DannyJames13]

only listened on radio so far but very exciting to see Nashy and windy doing so well. I heard Laycock showed some more good signs as well