Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2024 Father Son watch MKIII. Operation Ashcroft jnr. Featuring various academy boys.

  • Thread starter Thread starter briztoon
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Prove me wrong please Sam Day and kick at least 20 goals and brake the record of the most goals you have ever kicked in a season
 
So, 44 players on our list; 36 primary listers and 8 rookies including 2 x Cat B.

Ideally all 44 players would be available, but surely the first intra should be the 22 premiership players (obviously Joe was the 23rd) v the 22 premiership hopefuls.

The Premiership Hopefuls 22 could look like this:

BR.TORRENTD.GARDINERT.DOEDEE
HBL.BEECKEND.JOYCEK.COLEMAN
CB.REVILLEL.ASHCROFTS.BRAIN
HFL.LYOYDS.DAYW.MACLACHLAN
FL.McCARTHYH.SMITHT.GALLOP
RO.McINERNEYD.ROBERTSONJ.TUNSTILL
INTS.MARSHALLB.RYANZ.ZAKOSTELSKYD.CRAVEN
Interesting hypothetical if all fit, IMO that side would have a red hot chance of beating the Tigers 2025 first 23.
 
Looking at that we do actually have the edge of too many tall forwards for them to get enough game time (assuming everyone is fit).

Day, Smith, Lloyd, Gallop and Ryan competing for one spot in the seniors and then 3 spots in the two's.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Looking at that we do actually have the edge of too many tall forwards for them to get enough game time (assuming everyone is fit).

Day, Smith, Lloyd, Gallop and Ryan competing for one spot in the seniors and then 3 spots in the two's.

Having 5 competing for 4 spots isn’t an issue
 
Prove me wrong please Sam Day and kick at least 20 goals and brake the record of the most goals you have ever kicked in a season

With silver service from a premiership mid/forward line (not the perennial league whipping boys) he should pass that mark around mid-season if he plays from round 1. Even Charlie "the witches hat" Dickson would. Pretty sure, like Jarrod Lion, he will have a point to prove to everyone.
 
Looking at that we do actually have the edge of too many tall forwards for them to get enough game time (assuming everyone is fit).

Day, Smith, Lloyd, Gallop and Ryan competing for one spot in the seniors and then 3 spots in the two's.

Gallop won't be ready for years to come I imagine, but better too many to pick from to keep than too few.
 
Having 5 competing for 4 spots isn’t an issue
I'd argue it can be for most positions. Its a fine line between too many for anyone to get enough time and an injury crisis when you dont have enough to play.

Id say we have recent history where having Fort, Lane, Smith and was it Eagles? all playing meant we struggled to give them enough ruck game time.

This is probably hitting the sweet spot as we know its unlikely they will all be fit for every match. Maybe its better to put it at 7 forwards competing for 6 spots across 2 teams (and then the two rucks as well).
 
I'd argue it can be for most positions. Its a fine line between too many for anyone to get enough time and an injury crisis when you dont have enough to play.

Id say we have recent history where having Fort, Lane, Smith and was it Eagles? all playing meant we struggled to give them enough ruck game time.

This is probably hitting the sweet spot as we know its unlikely they will all be fit for every match. Maybe its better to put it at 7 forwards competing for 6 spots across 2 teams (and then the two rucks as well).

It was an issue when we had Fort, HSmith, Lane, Fullarton and Buzza
 
It was an issue when we had Fort, HSmith, Lane, Fullarton and Buzza

Lane was very tall and very immobile though. I’d assume two 20 year old 193 cm talls in Lloyd and Gallop would be fine playing in other positions including third tall with Fort, Smith, Day, and Ryan being tall forward and rucks (one playing in seniors).


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Gallop won't be ready for years to come I imagine, but better too many to pick from to keep than too few.
More than likely you're right although I wouldn't be surprised if he gets a few games(and maybe more than most think), his body is very well developed for an 18 year old, looks strong in the contest against men already.

It would be amazing if we follow up Logan Morris with another young key ready to go... Hippy will have to step up even more in 2025 and demand the oppositions best KPD go to him to take pressure off Morris/Gallop.
 
I await the media complaining about Brisbane adding another player drafted in the top 3.
On this. Can anyone explain why the drafts have all had the picks offered 5 differently? All seems a bit mickey mouse to me. Today "passes" are being counted as picks but last night they were not 🤔

20241122_155631.jpg

Vs

20241122_155617.jpg
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I’m going to believe we hid Ty as best as possible, while giving him just enough exposure to publicly say we didn’t hide him at all.

Genuinely think we did tbh. His big knock was his workrate, then goes and plays his one and only VFL game in the prelim and shows fantastic workrate. If he gets the repeat effort part of AFL football down, I reckon if nothing else he could be a very handy VFL player for us. Best case, he plays above his height thanks to his physicality and provides a great third banana pairing to Hipwood and Morris.
 
I have decided not to lose sleep over that one Grasshopper17
I won't lose sleep over it either, but only because I'm still losing sleep on why are some of the rows at the top of this page bolded but some of them aren't 😂🤦

Ah, OCD, sometimes a blessing, right now a curse...
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I’m going to believe we hid Ty as best as possible, while giving him just enough exposure to publicly say we didn’t hide him at all.

Genuinely think we did tbh. His big knock was his workrate, then goes and plays his one and only VFL game in the prelim and shows fantastic workrate. If he gets the repeat effort part of AFL football down, I reckon if nothing else he could be a very handy VFL player for us. Best case, he plays above his height thanks to his physicality and provides a great third banana pairing to Hipwood and Morris.
I've seen little of Gallop and not much more of Day over the years to be honest. Certainly never really paid him much attention, even when he played against us.

Assuming we play 3 tall forwards in opening round, who's partnering Hipwood and Morris in our front third in your views?
 
More clips:
From final regular season fixture 2024 (against soon to be QAFL Premiers Morningside

Ty Gallop - 8 Goals (could easily have been 10)



(It pays to watch more than 1 shot at goal before deriding someones kicking action ....... :rolleyes:)
 
I've seen little of Gallop and not much more of Day over the years to be honest. Certainly never really paid him much attention, even when he played against us.

Assuming we play 3 tall forwards in opening round, who's partnering Hipwood and Morris in our front third in your views?

I think we will try fast track Henry Smith, but honestly can see a world where Sam Day has a great pre season and plays a lot more football than people think.

Still, Smith is our future ruckman and suspect he'll be given the Oscar treatment just as O got with Stef.
 
Every Recruiting team would have watched Ty's VFL debut ............... I wonder whether the Geelong recruiting team watched this one as well ??
 
Why are people talking about Starcevich like him leaving is a foregone conclusion? Have I missed something?
With a squad as talented as ours, I think its impossible to keep everyone. And i'm not talking about fringe players, but some of our genuine superstar players as well. We can't give everyone a top contract, and it wouldn't surprise me if Western Australian clubs came in and offered him more than we could possibly give him. I hope we don't lose him though, as I rate him as one of our most important players. Was an unsung hero in the GF
 
Why are people talking about Starcevich like him leaving is a foregone conclusion? Have I missed something?

Hasn't re-signed must be gone.... Other clubs will come at him with more money than we can offer. Fifth in the coaches votes in a grand final, but not worth a first round pick, only a second rounder....
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom